Gearbox Dilemma
Author
Discussion

DannyVTS

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

184 months

Friday 17th December 2010
quotequote all
Do i pay a "specialist" garage £120 to fit me a gearbox on my Saxo.

Or do i spend £20 on a haynes and have a crack at it myself? Can't be that hard can it ??

Danny


DannyVTS

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

184 months

Friday 17th December 2010
quotequote all
I had no idea you could PM on here tbh! But thanks mate

Will Haynes cover it?

Sam_68

9,939 posts

261 months

Friday 17th December 2010
quotequote all
Yes, Haynes covers it.

It will depend on your ability, facilities and affluence how appealing the DIY is, though... £120 would look like a bargain to me, if I had to do it outside or in an unheated garage in these conditions, but then I'm soft and middle aged.

If you're not already doing so (and depending on mileage), consider changing the clutch while you've got the 'box out.

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,918 posts

232 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
Normally I would suggest that you stop being a scared pansy and tackle the job on your driveway. Gearbox fitment is hardly rocket science.

However, given the weather we are having recently, and your recalcitrent attitude to doing the job which is understandable, I would suggest that you should bite the arm off the guys who have offered to do it for £120.

In anyone's book, that's a bit of a bargain, that is. Especially as once you've paid them, you have a bit of comeback if it all falls out of the car 20 miles down the road.



Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

262 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
I would suggest that you should bite the arm off the guys who have offered to do it for £120.
+1

DannyVTS

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

184 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
Does the price not suggest the work is minimal though?

I think £200 all in for the gearbox replacing is a lot less than i was expecting either way.

Off to pick up a haynes and have a browse... £18!!!

paoloh

8,617 posts

220 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
DannyVTS said:
Does the price not suggest the work is minimal though?

I think £200 all in for the gearbox replacing is a lot less than i was expecting either way.

Off to pick up a haynes and have a browse... £18!!!
Or just Google it for nothing??

paintman

7,818 posts

206 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
Haynes does cover this quite well.

doogz said:
It's simple. DIY it.

If you get stuck PM me and i'll see if i can help.

You need to remove the battery, to get at one of the mounts. The other mount is at the aft end of the box, onto the chassis, nearside.

The box is held on with 8 or so allen headed bolts, 8mm allen key needed i think.
Can't remember the size, but you may need to get a set of allen sockets, if they haven't been off before these bolts are usually B...dy tight & allen keys often bend

There is an earth bolted on to the back of the box, that you have to take off.

Obviously, you'll need to crack the hub nuts to get the shafts out, and there is an intermediate support on the offside shaft that you need to loosen off.

Hardest part is lifting the new box back up into place to line it up, they're a bit heavy. If you know anyone that has an engine crane, borrow it, makes it a lot easier.
[b]Make a couple of threaded studs up & screw them into the block at the top in place of the bellhousing bolts. Still a bit of wrestling match but once you've got the gearbox onto these it all slides together much easier. Once fitted remove studs & refit the bolt[/i]

Oh, and don't forget to stick a block of wood and a jack under the engine when you undo the mounts, there are only 3 mounts holding the engine and box to the car, and you're going to undo 2 of them.

Can't think of anything else, it's really fairly easy, an afternoons work.

Edited by doogz on Friday 17th December 12:51[/footnote]
[footnote]Edited by paintman on Saturday 18th December 12:27

Momentofmadness

2,370 posts

257 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
I would suggest that you should bite the arm off the guys who have offered to do it for £120.
+1
+2

I'm a keen DIYer but without the necessary tools / lift etc why even risk injury?

PedantLosesGrip

4,106 posts

226 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
£120? Take it.

Major Fallout

5,278 posts

247 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
For £120! let them do it, why bother getting your hands dirty.


GG89

3,675 posts

202 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
I always thought a new gearbox was mega bucks to have done? I was looking on a site a while back about alot of MINI cooper gearboxes going bang early on in their lifes and the quotes for new ones fitted were around £1k if I remember correctly? hmm..I could be wrong.

DannyVTS

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

184 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
£120 is just for the fitting, about 3-4 hours labour i presume?

Tis a lot of money to an 18 year old!

Oh and you can't get Haynes manuals off google, not for a Saxo anyway

paoloh

8,617 posts

220 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
DannyVTS said:
£120 is just for the fitting, about 3-4 hours labour i presume?

Tis a lot of money to an 18 year old!

Oh and you can't get Haynes manuals off google, not for a Saxo anyway
Can't you Google how to fit though?

DannyVTS

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

184 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
paoloh said:
DannyVTS said:
£120 is just for the fitting, about 3-4 hours labour i presume?

Tis a lot of money to an 18 year old!

Oh and you can't get Haynes manuals off google, not for a Saxo anyway
Can't you Google how to fit though?
The owners club, (and doogz) have told me. I presume the Haynes will be more accurate or have more piccies?


frosted

3,549 posts

193 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
DannyVTS said:
Oh and you can't get Haynes manuals off google, not for a Saxo anyway
It's quite funny !

DannyVTS

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

184 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
frosted said:
DannyVTS said:
Oh and you can't get Haynes manuals off google, not for a Saxo anyway
It's quite funny !
Plus the FBi would get me for piracy.

useyourdellusion

5,648 posts

206 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
I would take information from both the owners club and Haynes to be honest. The former will give you more real life situation info I would imagine and mention any possible problems encountered in difficult conditions, restricted space etc.

Remember Haynes cars are pretty much brand new, hence no seized bolts, no dirt/oil build up etc. etc. and they've got a fully equipped workshop to play in. smile

DannyVTS

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

184 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
dibbers006 said:
Just has a look in the Haynes and in a quick flick through it doesn't appear to have details specifically for gearbox hokey cokey.
is that a haynes for a Saxo?

MrV

2,748 posts

244 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all
DannyVTS said:
£120 is just for the fitting, about 3-4 hours labour i presume?

Tis a lot of money to an 18 year old!

Oh and you can't get Haynes manuals off google, not for a Saxo anyway
My google fu is a bit better than yours smile

http://thepiratebay.org/torrent/3703340/HAYNES_-_D...

If you have the tools and the time allow all day to do your first one just to be on the safe side.Took me 5ish hrs to do my other halfs the first time and 3hrs for the second.