Keeping car in garage - effect on insurance

Keeping car in garage - effect on insurance

Author
Discussion

BMWBen

Original Poster:

4,904 posts

208 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
According to the wisdom of the interwebs, car in locked garage = lower premium.

Not what I'm finding when playing around with quotes, in fact it's going to cost me £150 more to keep my car in the garage than on the street.

Can anyone shed any light on this lunacy?

Cock Womble 7

29,908 posts

237 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Really? I've always assumed that garaged = safer and therefore cheaper insurance.

Is this not the case?

paulw123

3,716 posts

197 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
i found the same, cheapest option was a comunal parking area!! Madness imo

SlowStig

843 posts

178 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Mine is the same, in a locked garage it was £200 more than if I abandon it on the street. Odd as I asked about the driveway and that was £100 extra as well. Basically my insurance company would rather I parked my car somewhere on my street and risk it getting hit or stolen than locking it in the garage.

Crazy.

Gizmo!

18,150 posts

216 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
That's very strange.

When was working in insurance almost every insurer had a 5-10% discount for garaging...

BMWBen

Original Poster:

4,904 posts

208 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Nope. Well, not only am I getting completely stupid quotes anyway, but Admiral:
£1170 in garage
£1022 on street

Nuts!! The following has happened to my cars in the last 5 years when on the street:
1. Smashed by a RRS, new front bumper, headlamp.
2. Keyed
3. Keyed
4. Significant Door ding from someones front swinging as they park.
5. Scratched significantly (non malicious)
6. Boot scratched by someone putting bags on it.
7. stolen.

Are these boys on crack?


Edited by BMWBen on Wednesday 29th September 17:10

Jez64

2,120 posts

192 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Made no difference to the cost of my policy where it was parked....




Deranged Granny

2,315 posts

175 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
The only possible reason I can think of is people with a car that is a tight fit, and thus they scrape the doors/bumper/alloys getting in and out, and then claiming on their insurance. But surely that does not outweigh the damage that happens to peoples' cars on the road?

Edited by Deranged Granny on Wednesday 29th September 17:10

ZOLLAR

19,914 posts

180 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Alot of people cause damage driving in and out of their garages (we are talking about normal people not PH drivers wink )
Think about it "same routine pulled out of the garage a million times i know where the wall/gate is no need to pay full attention" wham
Where if someone is parked on the street they are more aware of their constant changing surroundings i.e. Cars driving past,people on pavement sounds strange but its true.

Edited by ZOLLAR on Wednesday 29th September 17:12

Cock Womble 7

29,908 posts

237 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Well in that case, I'm glad I declared mine as "off street" (which it is) and won't be following up the offer of one of my neighbours to rent his garage.

swamp

1,000 posts

196 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
If your house burns down your car will too (if it is in the garage).

Edited by swamp on Wednesday 29th September 17:20

dave4959

173 posts

199 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
These days with cars being so secure the only way to steal one is with the keys

If a car is in a comunal car park it would be difficult to guess which house the car keys that belong to the car that the theif wants.

However if the car is parked on a drive, it is pretty obvious that the keys for that car will be in that house

Gizmo!

18,150 posts

216 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
dave4959 said:
These days with cars being so secure the only way to steal one is with the keys

If a car is in a comunal car park it would be difficult to guess which house the car keys that belong to the car that the theif wants.

However if the car is parked on a drive, it is pretty obvious that the keys for that car will be in that house
True. But is that going to be statistically significant enough to make the ins co's actuary load the premiums?

swamp

1,000 posts

196 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
A car on your driveway could be squashed by a falling tree that you haven't bothered to maintain.

scratchchin

aizvara

2,060 posts

174 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
SlowStig said:
Mine is the same, in a locked garage it was £200 more than if I abandon it on the street. Odd as I asked about the driveway and that was £100 extra as well. Basically my insurance company would rather I parked my car somewhere on my street and risk it getting hit or stolen than locking it in the garage.

Crazy.
Hmm. This perhaps explains why my insurance premiums went up by £70ish when I moved from a medium risk area to a low risk area (from a C to an A area, postcode risk assessment fans!): at the same time I gained a driveway on which I now park the car, rather than the previous musical-spaces street parking.

Really is bizarre. Can't see how my drive is more risky than two metres around the corner, on the road.

Deranged Granny

2,315 posts

175 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
aizvara said:
SlowStig said:
Mine is the same, in a locked garage it was £200 more than if I abandon it on the street. Odd as I asked about the driveway and that was £100 extra as well. Basically my insurance company would rather I parked my car somewhere on my street and risk it getting hit or stolen than locking it in the garage.

Crazy.
Hmm. This perhaps explains why my insurance premiums went up by £70ish when I moved from a medium risk area to a low risk area (from a C to an A area, postcode risk assessment fans!): at the same time I gained a driveway on which I now park the car, rather than the previous musical-spaces street parking.

Really is bizarre. Can't see how my drive is more risky than two metres around the corner, on the road.
They'll know where to find the keys for the car, so it'll be more likely to be stolen.

anonymous-user

61 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
When I moved 11 months ago my R8 went from being garaged to being parked on the drive. Made no difference to premium at all...go figure?

will_

6,030 posts

210 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
I heard (!) that it was because if a car is stolen from a garage it usually takes the owner longer to notice than if it is parked on the street and therefore the chances of recovering the car decrease and the cost of the claim increases.

Any truth in that?

Oakey

27,804 posts

223 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
It's all part of the magical, mystical, fairyland that is the world of car insurance. Logic, common sense, other rules of normality do not exist in this bizarre parallel universe.

aizvara

2,060 posts

174 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Deranged Granny said:
They'll know where to find the keys for the car, so it'll be more likely to be stolen.
Yeah, I guess that's it. I'm surprised that the higher risk of vandalism or crash damage which comes with street parking doesn't outweigh the fairly unlikely chance of break-and-enter car theft. Especially when in a fairly rural/low risk location.

At the time I just put it down to the fact that I was moving nearer to Cambridge, which seems to mean an increase in prices regardless.