SPD's - Edumacate me!
Author
Discussion

pincher

Original Poster:

10,488 posts

246 months

Thursday 16th September 2010
quotequote all
New to all this, so forgive my ignorance.

Recently got a Specialized Sirrus Sport, which came with toe-clips. These were OK on the first biggish ride I did (40-odd miles) but I think I'd rather have clipless but I'm not sure what to order.

I'll only use the bike on the road, so would I be better off with something like these Shimano M540's or these Shimano R540's

I presume that each uses a different type of cleat?

And will I be restricted in which type of shoe I can buy if I choose one over the other?

Any help appreciated.

walm

10,644 posts

231 months

Thursday 16th September 2010
quotequote all
pincher said:
New to all this, so forgive my ignorance.

Recently got a Specialized Sirrus Sport, which came with toe-clips. These were OK on the first biggish ride I did (40-odd miles) but I think I'd rather have clipless but I'm not sure what to order.

I'll only use the bike on the road, so would I be better off with something like these Shimano M540's or these Shimano R540's

I presume that each uses a different type of cleat?

And will I be restricted in which type of shoe I can buy if I choose one over the other?

Any help appreciated.
If you commute, I would seriously recommend M520s - seem fine to me. Done c.5k miles on them so far with no maintenance required other than the odd lube. £20
http://www.chainreactioncycles.com/Models.aspx?Mod...
They are MUCH easier to clip into than pure road pedals, hence you won't hold people up while you slowly coast along hoping you are stepping on the right side of the pedal which you aren't.

If you MUST have road pedals, get them here for £25:
http://www.chainreactioncycles.com/Models.aspx?Mod...

They do use a different cleat but they are supplied with the pedal and will last for a long while.
You will have a slightly different choice of shoe since the MTB shoes tend to be compatible with MTB cleats and same with road. MTB shoes will let you walk around a little though.

pincher

Original Poster:

10,488 posts

246 months

Thursday 16th September 2010
quotequote all
walm said:
If you commute, I would seriously recommend M520s
Not so much of a commute, more a 'just go out for a ride' type of thing. I had spotted those already but wondered if they would be a bit rubbish for the money? Perhaps not though.

walm said:
They are MUCH easier to clip into than pure road pedals, hence you won't hold people up while you slowly coast along hoping you are stepping on the right side of the pedal which you aren't.
I like easy biggrin. Also quite like the idea of not having to worry about whether or not I am stepping into the correct side.

walm said:
MTB shoes will let you walk around a little though.
This also appeals to me biggrin

So, maybe the 520's along with some MTB shoes would do the trick by the sounds of things.

Although, having said that, there are only a couple of hours left on this and the Sidi's look as though they retail at north of £100. Get them and the SPD's for under £75 and it would be a bargain I reckon??

snotrag

15,624 posts

240 months

Thursday 16th September 2010
quotequote all
M520 are the "standard issue" SPD pedal. Ifyou want SPD rather than spd-sl then there the one to go for.

I'd also say that unless your a serious roadie, stick with regular SPD for practicality, choice of shoes and ease of use.


Edited by snotrag on Thursday 16th September 19:21

shalmaneser

6,420 posts

224 months

Thursday 16th September 2010
quotequote all
Go for M520s for the reasons above. Brilliant pedals, have them on all my bikes. Oldest set are 6 years old, not needed any attention whatsoever apart from a blast of gt85 on the mechanism every now and again.

big_peaches

438 posts

225 months

Friday 17th September 2010
quotequote all
check out the classifieds, i have a set of xt's if you want to try them but not spend full whack on new kit

pincher

Original Poster:

10,488 posts

246 months

Friday 17th September 2010
quotequote all
Well, I ended up bidding on, and winning the eBay auction!

£64 for pedals, cleats and Sidi shoes. Not too shabby IMO.


Jameshs

36 posts

227 months

Friday 17th September 2010
quotequote all
Sounds like a steal to me.

I have currently been using the M520's for 4 months now. Cant fault them other than i dont like the way a MTB shoe flex's. Just upgraded to ulterga but havent had the chance to use them yet so cant comment

Hard-Drive

4,291 posts

258 months

Friday 17th September 2010
quotequote all
shalmaneser said:
Go for M520s for the reasons above. Brilliant pedals, have them on all my bikes. Oldest set are 6 years old, not needed any attention whatsoever apart from a blast of gt85 on the mechanism every now and again.
You saved me typing exactly the same thing. M520s are a no brainer.

That said, on my proper roadie I did make the jump to road SPDs, and they are much more positive, support your foot more, and give me more range before I get sore feet. That said, much harder to get in and out of.

AndrewM

305 posts

265 months

Friday 17th September 2010
quotequote all
Another vote for the M520s here - SJS are doing them for £17.99: http://www.sjscycles.co.uk/shimano-shimano-pd-m520...

Chicane-UK

3,861 posts

214 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
Had the R540's on my road bike for a while and did like them but as has been said, found the single sided design a pain when commuting. If you're trying to set off, on an incline, in traffic trying to get going and get clipped in is a royal PITA.

Decided I was finally ready for clipless on my fixie and had been bought a set of the M520's at christmas so got them on and have really enjoyed them so far. Much better for commute purposes, more float which I've found more comfortable, and they don't seem to let go when you really pile on the effort on both down and upstroke of the pedals.

For £20, they're a bargain.

Alex L

2,592 posts

283 months

Monday 11th October 2010
quotequote all
Good choice of bike Chris, I've got the Sirrus Pro for the road

sjg

7,674 posts

294 months

Monday 11th October 2010
quotequote all
MTB ones all the way. If you want more stiffness, look for racier MTB shoes to wear which tend to have more solid soles.

Jameshs

36 posts

227 months

Tuesday 12th October 2010
quotequote all
Been using SPD-SL'd for about 2 months now and i really rate them. Much more postive than the MTB versions but just a little more tricky to clip in being single sided, but i couldnt revert back