Machine Mart tools
Author
Discussion

Dr_Rick

Original Poster:

1,703 posts

270 months

Sunday 27th December 2009
quotequote all
Machine Mart seem to be having a VAT free day on the 2nd and I'm tempted by their professional tool chest / tool set package. 322 tools, 9-drawer and 7-drawer package with lifetime guarantees on the tools.

Is it worth considering given the price, or is there somewhere else I should be looking?

Dr Rick

Dr_Rick

Original Poster:

1,703 posts

270 months

Sunday 27th December 2009
quotequote all
Or would something like the Sealey package be more cost effective (from Amazon)

Fatboy

8,249 posts

294 months

Sunday 27th December 2009
quotequote all
No experience of the Machine Mart Tools (Clarke IIRC?), but in my experience Sealey tools are not as good quality as Halfords Professional or Draper Expert (IIRC Halfords pro and Draper Expert are the same tools...)


Edited by Fatboy on Sunday 27th December 14:15

Dr_Rick

Original Poster:

1,703 posts

270 months

Sunday 27th December 2009
quotequote all
Fatboy said:
No experience of the Machine Mart Tools (Clarke IIRC?), but in my experience Sealey tools are not as good quality as Halfords Professional or Draper Expert (IIRC Halfords pro and Draper Expert are the same tools..
yep, MM are Clarke tools. Given I have no prior experience of Sealey, I'll take your word on their quality. I'll also try to match up the Clarke package through Halfrauds and their Pro range.

Dr Rick

Noisy

4,489 posts

299 months

Sunday 27th December 2009
quotequote all
I generally buy most of my tools form Halfords now, the pro range has a lifetime warranty, I've only broken a few items, of those which I broke there was no problem swapping them over for new items, some good offers on right now as well.

stigproducts

1,730 posts

293 months

Sunday 27th December 2009
quotequote all
I would advise to be careful buying Machine mart stuff. I have got a fair few bits and bobs and the quality is variable, some stuff is great value some almost useless. It feels lightweight, poorly made and shoddy then is probably is.

Also, Machine Mart’s returns policy appears to be "we will not give you your money back ever, under any circumstances". I have experienced this even when stuff was obviously completely unfit for purpose. Of course, this is not necessarily enforceable in law, but do you really want that hassle? Draper stuff is better I think, as is Sealey; depends what you are buying.

For light use the hand tools are probably fine, if the price is right I would say go for it (with caution, and without expectations too high).

RichB

55,173 posts

306 months

Sunday 27th December 2009
quotequote all
For tools my policy is always buy the best you can afford...

Dr_Rick

Original Poster:

1,703 posts

270 months

Monday 28th December 2009
quotequote all
This is all a precursor to doing DIY and a kit car build. I have a mixture of tools with some bought, some given, in a variety of decrepit boxes. I now want to pull it all together into one secure container.

So are Clarke ball bearing tool chests any good or should I go for a different make. I'm all for ' the best that I can afford but for approx £300 what's/who's the best toolchest to go for?

Dr Rick

Fatboy

8,249 posts

294 months

Monday 28th December 2009
quotequote all
I have very much noticed the difference between my old Halfords toolchest and my brother's Sealey topchest...

BTW I have broken a few sockets, a breaker bar and two ratchets (in ten years!) and in all cases they were swapped without question, even though technically the ratchet mechanisms aren't covered. (Well, the guy in Barrow halford did ask me how the hell I broke a two week old 3/8" drive breaker bar - a fat bloke repeatedly throwing all his weight against it in an attempt to loosen a driveshaft bolt on a 5-series BMW did it hehe)

Edited to add as I misread your post smile - you can esily get a Halford Professional or Industrial rollcab and toolchest for £300 - see here for £199 or an Industrial one for £300 here

Edited by Fatboy on Monday 28th December 21:32

bitwrx

1,352 posts

226 months

Monday 28th December 2009
quotequote all
Save your money.

  • Sheet of 19mm ply. 4 rawlbolts. Garage wall.
  • Hammer, bag of nails.
Certainly no more than thruppence the lot.

Use hammer to bang in the nails in appropriate places to hold the tools you already have. Job done.

Buy the rest of the tools as you need them.

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

282 months

Monday 28th December 2009
quotequote all
For a cabinet I'd look on ebay for a used snap on unit. I've looked at some other new items (halfords, machine mart, cromwell tools) and whilst they seem ok they aren't as good as a used snap on item. They feel terrible when you open the drawers.

Noisy

4,489 posts

299 months

Monday 28th December 2009
quotequote all
I have a cheap cab from Halfords, its not great quality but for what I paid was still ok and lasted 3-4 years already, they have some much nicer roll ball cabs on offer at the moment, if you get a cab you pick up the top box for free.


Dr_Rick

Original Poster:

1,703 posts

270 months

Tuesday 29th December 2009
quotequote all
If I can deal with the ice on the roads I might go for a Halfords deal. £299 for the industrial including the top box is pretty good. Is it worth the extra £100 over the Pro range though?

Anyone come across US Pro from The Bay? Good price point for the amount of storage, but don't know the quality and returns may be a problem whereas Halfords would be around after a nuclear blast.

Incidentally, the tool chest vs ply and nails is negated by the lack of a lock on my garage so I'd like the extra security

Dr Rick

Edited by Dr_Rick on Tuesday 29th December 08:27


Edited by Dr_Rick on Tuesday 29th December 08:33

John MacK

3,170 posts

228 months

Tuesday 29th December 2009
quotequote all
Dr_Rick said:
Anyone come across US Pro from The Bay? Good price point for the amount of storage, but don't know the quality and returns may be a problem whereas Halfords would be around after a nuclear blast.
Costco sell Us-Pro tool cabinets, look good quality, a lot better than Machine Mart cheap cabinets.


Kermit power

29,622 posts

235 months

Tuesday 29th December 2009
quotequote all
Dr_Rick said:
Incidentally, the tool chest vs ply and nails is negated by the lack of a lock on my garage so I'd like the extra security
Wouldn't it make more sense to fit a lock to the garage door? confused

UpTheIron

4,056 posts

290 months

Tuesday 29th December 2009
quotequote all
Dr_Rick said:
Incidentally, the tool chest vs ply and nails is negated by the lack of a lock on my garage so I'd like the extra security
Your local scrotes will be pleased to see you put all your tools in one box with wheels then!

julian64

14,325 posts

276 months

Tuesday 29th December 2009
quotequote all
John MacK said:
Dr_Rick said:
Anyone come across US Pro from The Bay? Good price point for the amount of storage, but don't know the quality and returns may be a problem whereas Halfords would be around after a nuclear blast.
Costco sell Us-Pro tool cabinets, look good quality, a lot better than Machine Mart cheap cabinets.
I have one of these from costco, and I have a machine mart one. The costco one was/is twice the quality and two thirds the price.

Dr_Rick

Original Poster:

1,703 posts

270 months

Tuesday 29th December 2009
quotequote all
UpTheIron said:
Dr_Rick said:
Incidentally, the tool chest vs ply and nails is negated by the lack of a lock on my garage so I'd like the extra security
Your local scrotes will be pleased to see you put all your tools in one box with wheels then!
Yeah, but I'm going to put a nice bolt through the blockwork and chain the trolley to it. Just want to ahve all my tools in one place that is more sturdy and secure than current (£5 B&Q toolbox in plastic).

I'm going to make the most of the local Halfords Pro sale and get a Pro socket set at the same time. Jobs a goodun.

Costco only seemed to have one model when I looked last, but it was the run-up to Christmas so I could have missed it.

Dr Rick