£13k to spend on an Elise...
£13k to spend on an Elise...
Author
Discussion

theundecided

Original Poster:

225 posts

196 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
Guys,

After some gratefully received advice from this forum, I'm interested in an Elise.

I've about £13k to spend. Just after some advice really, on what this should buy me and what I should be looking for around this money in terms of model etc.

From what I understand, this sort of money should get me a tidy example with the K series engine, FSH and I should only look for examples where the head gasket has been replaced as it's likely to fail at around the 40k mile mark.

Any comments welcome.

Thank you.

kambites

70,720 posts

244 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
For that money you should be looking at either an Elise S2 111S (VVC K-series) or a VX220 turbo.

Don't worry about a full Lotus service history, many independents are better than the main dealers. The head gasket on the K-series does not go on mileage - there are plenty on six figure mileages on the original head gasket and a few have failed at 20k or earlier. The longevity of the head gasket is mostly down to how well the car is treated, it's thrashing the engine before it's up to temperature that really kills it.

Buy on condition not mileage.

Edited by kambites on Sunday 29th November 19:06

theundecided

Original Poster:

225 posts

196 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
kambites said:
For that money you should be looking at either an Elise S2 111S (VVC K-series) or a VX220 turbo.
Cheers.

A bit concerned about what I've read parts are more difficult/expensive to come by. Not sure how true this is. Although I'm genuinely not a snob, I'd rather have a Lotus - I prefer the way it looks.

theundecided

Original Poster:

225 posts

196 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
Kambites, you're right about the servicing, I only ever use independent specialists.

I've eyed up the cost of independent servicing and I'm surprised about how cheap it is.

I assume there's nothing big to go wrong about them, seems it's just the head gasket as the biggest expense so far.

Gad-Westy

16,158 posts

236 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
Is this for road use, a bit of road and trackdays or just track?

If its the first I reckon the S2 111s is a good call (and VXT for that matter), road and track I'd take a look at the S1 160 or a well modded S1. If its track only I'd go for a breather on S1 (actually I'd go for a Caterham but that's not the question!).

There are no bad ones though, so whatever you pick you'll have a ball.

AyBee

11,182 posts

225 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
Having suggested an elise on the other thread, it may well be worth checking out the vx220 turbo. You'll get a lot more for your money and I agree with you on the badge snob side but I think some examples where the badge has been removed (hehe) actually look quite nice - especially in black or blue.....I'm off to find a pic biggrin

Ok, so it hasn't had the badge removed but....

...I love them in this colour biggrin

Edited by AyBee on Sunday 29th November 19:13

theundecided

Original Poster:

225 posts

196 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
It will be my only car, I'm in my mid-twenties with no kids etc so practicality isn't really a concern. It's for every day use.

I do around 7k miles a year, at least half of this is just driving for pleasure.

Gad-Westy

16,158 posts

236 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
theundecided said:
It will be my only car, I'm in my mid-twenties with no kids etc so practicality isn't really a concern. It's for every day use.

I do around 7k miles a year, at least half of this is just driving for pleasure.
A VXT or S2 111s sound perfect then!

In terms of costs, you're right in that there is nothing major to worry about. The main areas of expense on a k-series Elise are, radiators, suspension components, head gasket, brake components.

They're not expensive to run but I think its fair to say that they cost a touch more than the average hot hatch.


kambites

70,720 posts

244 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
The head gasket isn't particularly expensive to fix - usually around 4-500 quid. Don't be too concerned if the coolant looks low; they just expel unwanted coolant and many will run well below the minimum mark. Check for the usual signs of head gasket failure.


Other things to be aware of:

The heater fan resistor pack tends to rust and stop working. It's a front clam off job to replace so a lot of labour. Check that all the interior fan speeds work and if they don't, walk away or negotiate a hefty amount off the price for it.

For some reason the handling is massively affected by the suspension geometry. You should budget for getting the geo sorted out every couple of years, really.

They run on tyres specially designed for Lotus, with different compounds front to rear to balance the handling. As far as I know, these tyres are only available through main dealers. People do fit standard tyres without major problems, but it's just something to be aware of.

Lotus have improved the car with every model year. The last of the common hood leaks was fixed in MY04 - a set of small cup like things on the tops of the windscreen pillars to stop water dripping onto the sills.

The original radiator has plastic end caps which can fail (and throw the coolant all over you if you have the roof off). This is also a clam off job to repair and hence fairly expensive.

Any second-hand Elise will be covered in stone chips unless it's been armour-fended.

Edited by kambites on Sunday 29th November 19:19

kambites

70,720 posts

244 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
Oh and the VVC mechanism on the 111S can be very noisy. Don't worry too much if it sounds like a diesel at idle, it's pretty normal - some do it, some don't, but it seems to have no effect on reliability.

theundecided

Original Poster:

225 posts

196 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
theundecided said:
It will be my only car, I'm in my mid-twenties with no kids etc so practicality isn't really a concern. It's for every day use.

I do around 7k miles a year, at least half of this is just driving for pleasure.
A VXT or S2 111s sound perfect then!

In terms of costs, you're right in that there is nothing major to worry about. The main areas of expense on a k-series Elise are, radiators, suspension components, head gasket, brake components.

They're not expensive to run but I think its fair to say that they cost a touch more than the average hot hatch.
Unless something fails, I'm just looking at servicing cost, which seem to be on a par with a hot hatch anyhow?

Cheers,

Park'O

656 posts

197 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
You might just about get a Elise S2 111R on your budget, its quicker than the 111S!

willibum

81 posts

222 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
If you want some sound advice, there are a lot of knowlegeable folk on the Lotus forum, www.seloc.org
Everything you ever want to know will be here!!

Mr E

22,708 posts

282 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
Park'O said:
You might just about get a Elise S2 111R on your budget, its quicker than the 111S!
I'm in pretty much the same boat. 111r is different to 111s, but better is a debatable point.

Trying to drive both before I make a decision.

theundecided

Original Poster:

225 posts

196 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
kambites said:
Oh and the VVC mechanism on the 111S can be very noisy. Don't worry too much if it sounds like a diesel at idle, it's pretty normal - some do it, some don't, but it seems to have no effect on reliability.
Kambites - thanks very much for all that. Very much appreciated!!

According to WhatCar, see the link below, they need servicing every 6000 miles - is this right?

Also, as I'm not at all technically minded, I know it may sound a stupid question but how do I know if the car is effected by any of these issues?

I'd prefer it if the car was independently inspected by a specialist - I guess this would cost £200 or so. It seems like a sensible option.

Park'O

656 posts

197 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
Mr E said:
Park'O said:
You might just about get a Elise S2 111R on your budget, its quicker than the 111S!
I'm in pretty much the same boat. 111r is different to 111s, but better is a debatable point.

Trying to drive both before I make a decision.
111R - 223 Bhp/ton and 133/6800 Lb ft/rpm torque pulling it! You'll be overtaking alot more in this one!

Mr E

22,708 posts

282 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
Park'O said:
Mr E said:
Park'O said:
You might just about get a Elise S2 111R on your budget, its quicker than the 111S!
I'm in pretty much the same boat. 111r is different to 111s, but better is a debatable point.

Trying to drive both before I make a decision.
111R - 223 Bhp/ton and 133/6800 Lb ft/rpm torque pulling it! You'll be overtaking alot more in this one!
indeed. But I'm stepping out of a turbo loony wagon that had torque by the bucketload. Engine power is not why I'm interested in the lotus as long as it's sufficient.

kambites

70,720 posts

244 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
I drove both and greatly preferred the 111S to the 111R.

kambites

70,720 posts

244 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
Have a read of the sticky "buyers guide" at the top of this subsection. It's worth joining SELOC too, there's a wealth of information there, both on the Forums and the Wiki.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

242 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
Park'O said:
Mr E said:
Park'O said:
You might just about get a Elise S2 111R on your budget, its quicker than the 111S!
I'm in pretty much the same boat. 111r is different to 111s, but better is a debatable point.

Trying to drive both before I make a decision.
111R - 223 Bhp/ton and 133/6800 Lb ft/rpm torque pulling it! You'll be overtaking alot more in this one!
Main difference between the 111R and 111S is accessibility of the power. In the 111R you need to be on the second cam to get it going, the 111S has a linear delivery.
A 13k 111R - Really?

At 13k I'd look at the 111S and don't worry about HGF. As said its not the end of the world and a cheap enough fix that shouldn't happen again if repaired properly.