Which sounds better.. V8 or flat-6?

Which sounds better.. V8 or flat-6?

Poll: Which sounds better.. V8 or flat-6?

Total Members Polled: 371

V8: 85%
Flat-6: 15%
Author
Discussion

boomerkk

Original Poster:

619 posts

233 months

Darkslider

3,075 posts

196 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
V8, no contest. Porsche sounds wk compared.

supersingle

3,205 posts

226 months

DirtyHarry88

930 posts

195 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
Generally a V8 although hearing a Skyline at full song accompanied with a loud exhaust is something else.

boomerkk

Original Poster:

619 posts

233 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
supersingle said:
well, that's only attainable by the true big boys...

Spiritual_Beggar

4,833 posts

201 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
Out of those....I'd say the V8


Though both are bettered by a V6 with a Supersprint exhaust (I am biased though wink )

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=Vgo6779sS3g

J-P

4,388 posts

213 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
And in a nutshell why you'd have a V8 over a flat 6 - that 996 sounded st!! They should have chosen a normally aspirated one. I drove a 997 C4S and that sounded incredible (admittedly had sports exhaust system!)

gj88

1,961 posts

201 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
I did not even think about it. V8 all the way.

labrit

321 posts

190 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
I've owned a 997 'S' and a 2001 Mustang GT (V8).

V8's sound better without a doubt.

kambites

68,438 posts

228 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
Assuming "flat" means "boxer", the V8 sounds far better.

If "flat" could include 180 degree V6s, I'd be less certain.

DjSki

1,324 posts

202 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
V10 M5 with fuity exhaust......WOW!

Hear them all here.....

http://www.bmwsounds.extra.hu/

HappyS3owner

15,855 posts

236 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
Get an aircooled 911 with no turbo's and try that again...

Spiritual_Beggar

4,833 posts

201 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=ZDstnrgZENE <===== Clk 63 amg Black!

Oh God...I think I sex wee'ed!

Wait for the engine to kick in at about 17 seconds biggrin OMFG!!! Banshee from Hell!!!

Edited by Spiritual_Beggar on Tuesday 3rd February 19:00


Edited by Spiritual_Beggar on Tuesday 3rd February 19:01

posterboy

1,144 posts

200 months

DirtyHarry88

930 posts

195 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
Spiritual_Beggar said:
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=ZDstnrgZENE <===== Clk 63 amg Black!

Oh God...I think I sex wee'ed!

Wait for the engine to kick in at about 17 seconds biggrin
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=nbpbJkEFL34

Fast forward to 1:05, holy st, immense.

Edited by DirtyHarry88 on Tuesday 3rd February 18:54


Edited by DirtyHarry88 on Tuesday 3rd February 18:55

BlueCello

6,225 posts

214 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
V8. Although, 911's at full chat (especially the C4S that I heard a few weeks ago) are cloud9 They make me tingly.

Futuramic

1,763 posts

212 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
I once stood behind a supercharged big block camaro running twin four barrels and a straight exhaust.

It was quiet, until the man behind the wheel hit the starter; with a click and a whine the full fury of hell smashed through the gates of the damned and was present upon earth. Lesser mortals ran for cover, some were crying. I stood firm as the sonic assault battered past each of my ear drums and tore straight into my soul. Every nerve ending lit up with an electric tingle, and I watched in awe as opaque plumes of oil smoke and searing tongues of flame belched from the twin exhaust pipes. The engine died. The spell was broken. The magic remained, however, a simple contact on the starter solenoid would re-awaken it.

So my description is flowery. The V8 most certainly isn't. It is cheap iron for the people, and that's why I love it. 40 years ago V8 power spun the wheels of commerce and family life. Millions of Americans went to work each morning on the magic carpet of torque provided by countless MOPARs and Clevelands.

From rags to Royalty the V8 was good enough for everybody, and out of the reach of nobody. Politicians rage about power to the people. It exists, has eight cylinders and a big carb.

In comparison the Porsche sounds like a cockroach farting.

skylinecrazy

13,986 posts

201 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
V16 BRM.

MGJohn

10,203 posts

190 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
skylinecrazy said:
V16 BRM.
Yes, that was summat else... or, am I thinking of the H-16 ?

Flat six or V8 .... neither ..so didn't vote. To my ears a straight six on sound alone wins hands down.

At Mallory park paddock in the mid 1960s, I made the mistake of standing directly behind Mike Hailwood's 300 Honda Six (in-line) when his works mechanic started it up and blipped it up to about around 20,000 rpm or whatever ~ what a fabulous sound... I could not stay there long, the frequency of the resulting vibrations from those six exhaust megaphones vibrated the bones in my rib cage at a different frequency to the flesh on them... I had to move away though or I think my chest would have seperated...... fantastic sound though.

Rather drive a V8 though .... or, ride one even ... 500cc V8 Grand Prix Moto Guzzi anyone...?
..

Edited by MGJohn on Tuesday 3rd February 19:30

skylinecrazy

13,986 posts

201 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all