GTV V6 spark plugs ripoff?
Author
Discussion

johnnystealth

Original Poster:

87 posts

233 months

Saturday 22nd July 2006
quotequote all
I recently bought a very gorgeous pearlescent GTV 3.0. I knew it needed a clutch when I bought it and got money off accordingly; it was given to a recommended independant guy who did a good job and saved me £170 on the dealer quote, using an OE clutch I supplied. Same week, I get a misfire, take it back to the same place and he traces it to naff plugs, now I know these are a tenner each but I thought £220 a bit steep (all in, with VAT) to change the plugs, especially as he said they traced the misfire very quickly? Are they really that hard to change?

John

_Batty_

12,268 posts

270 months

Saturday 22nd July 2006
quotequote all
johnnystealth said:
I recently bought a very gorgeous pearlescent GTV 3.0. I knew it needed a clutch when I bought it and got money off accordingly; it was given to a recommended independant guy who did a good job and saved me £170 on the dealer quote, using an OE clutch I supplied. Same week, I get a misfire, take it back to the same place and he traces it to naff plugs, now I know these are a tenner each but I thought £220 a bit steep (all in, with VAT) to change the plugs, especially as he said they traced the misfire very quickly? Are they really that hard to change?

John

inlet manifold has to be removed, so yes, they are a pain.
main dealers charge £70+ an hour labour as well, so you have to kinda expect it im afraid.
use an independant if you can, much cheaper.

johnnystealth

Original Poster:

87 posts

233 months

Sunday 23rd July 2006
quotequote all
Yeah this was an independant and i do trust the place, he works on Lotus Ferrari etc. seems to knoe his stuff. I hate main dealers never use them. Cheers for clearing that up I guess if its inlet manifolds off thats fair enough.

John

pdV6

16,442 posts

281 months

Monday 24th July 2006
quotequote all
Plugs for the V6 are quite pricey. OE ones are NGK PFR6B, double platimum jobs and come in at around £30 each and you need 6 of them, so that's £180 in parts before labour.

Saying that, the specialist I use charged me just over £60 for a set of plugs, so I'm guessing there are cheaper equivalents available.

jamieboy

5,921 posts

249 months

Monday 24th July 2006
quotequote all
pdV6 said:
OE ones are NGK PFR6B, double platimum jobs and come in at around £30 each and you need 6 of them, so that's £180 in parts before labour.


I was quoted about the same, and found this website:

www.sparkplugs.co.uk/pages/pricing/applications/ngk_petrol_car_applications.asp

If you put in your car details, it comes back with the PFR6B at 6.90 each. I can't vouch for them because I haven't tried them, but it's a massive saving if they're legit.

johnnystealth

Original Poster:

87 posts

233 months

Tuesday 25th July 2006
quotequote all
Well my man charged me just over £60 for the plugs so I guess these arent original.... Any disadvantage to using non-OE plugs that anyone knows of?

pdV6

16,442 posts

281 months

Tuesday 25th July 2006
quotequote all
johnnystealth said:
Well my man charged me just over £60 for the plugs so I guess these arent original.... Any disadvantage to using non-OE plugs that anyone knows of?

So he's basically charged you £160 labour? Seems a bit on the steep side, but that would depend on his hourly rate.

jamieboy

5,921 posts

249 months

Tuesday 25th July 2006
quotequote all
johnnystealth said:
Well my man charged me just over £60 for the plugs so I guess these arent original

They might be the proper ones - that site I linked to claims they sell the proper NGK ones for £6.90. Add the VAT, and that's not far off what you've been charged.

alhuyshe

40 posts

237 months

Tuesday 25th July 2006
quotequote all
I don't know about more modern Alfas, (my last was a 75) but back in the 60/70/80's, they used Gold Lodge plugs as standard. I knew many people who tried using cheaper ones, and without exception they ended up with holes in the piston crowns.

Make sure 1) your plug has the right heat range, and 2) that it's a multi electrode type. Singles just won't do it.

Having said that, Alfa engines aren't what they used to be, and nearly everyone does multi electrode plugs these days. But I think you'll find plugs are cheaper to fit than pistons......

johnnystealth

Original Poster:

87 posts

233 months

Friday 28th July 2006
quotequote all
alhuyshe said:
I don't know about more modern Alfas, (my last was a 75) but back in the 60/70/80's, they used Gold Lodge plugs as standard. I knew many people who tried using cheaper ones, and without exception they ended up with holes in the piston crowns.

Make sure 1) your plug has the right heat range, and 2) that it's a multi electrode type. Singles just won't do it.

Having said that, Alfa engines aren't what they used to be, and nearly everyone does multi electrode plugs these days. But I think you'll find plugs are cheaper to fit than pistons......


Yeah I remember Alfasuds needed the Lodges... A main dealer once put other ones in mine as well

Andrew Noakes

914 posts

260 months

Friday 28th July 2006
quotequote all
johnnystealth said:
Well my man charged me just over £60 for the plugs so I guess these arent original.... Any disadvantage to using non-OE plugs that anyone knows of?


Probably won't last as long. The reason Alfa used expensive multi-electrode plugs was so you didn't have to get the manifolds off every 10,000 miles.

pdV6

16,442 posts

281 months

Friday 28th July 2006
quotequote all
If the OE £30 plugs can be had for <£10 e@, then I don't see what the problem is?

MJK 24

5,670 posts

256 months

Saturday 29th July 2006
quotequote all
alhuyshe said:
I don't know about more modern Alfas, (my last was a 75) but back in the 60/70/80's, they used Gold Lodge plugs as standard. I knew many people who tried using cheaper ones, and without exception they ended up with holes in the piston crowns.

Make sure 1) your plug has the right heat range, and 2) that it's a multi electrode type. Singles just won't do it.

Having said that, Alfa engines aren't what they used to be, and nearly everyone does multi electrode plugs these days. But I think you'll find plugs are cheaper to fit than pistons......


Golden Lodge 25HL in my Sud!

All the flat fours run 25HL's. Not sure about the Twin Cam's and V6 but not running the Golden Lodge on the F4 will lead to the troubles you've mentioned...

JamesBondMI5

35 posts

247 months

Saturday 5th August 2006
quotequote all
Yes you need the Platinum plugs - mainly because they are a pain to fit and they are rated at 60,000 miles. It takes about 4 hours to change them.

The Alfa workshop manual lists an alternative copper variety, but they'll need adjusting every 12K miles, so a false economy really.

The best thing to do is to get new ones when you have the cambelt changed as the plugs have to come out anyway. I charge £99 a set for NGK plugs (in Alfa branded packaging) including fitting if you're also having your cambelt changed, otherwise it's another £100.

Mike
Roberts Aerospace & Automotive (Alfa Romeo, Fiat Coupe, and Maserati specialist in Hampshire)
www.cars.robertsaerospace.com

ed.

2,176 posts

258 months

Sunday 6th August 2006
quotequote all
Slightly off topics but I used to own a nissan 200sx which also needed NGK Platinums, many people on the SXOC used www.sparkplugs.co.uk with no problems.