To "V" or "W"
Author
Discussion

seasider

Original Poster:

12,728 posts

278 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
Sorry Paul

What it says in the title really ?

Rears i have TOYO T1-R 245/45/ZR16 94W

I need to replace my front T1-S

Insurance company said:
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Following our recent telephone conversation I can confirm that the modification listed bellow has been approved by our underwriters:
15" V - rated front wheel tyre(s).
This modification has been listed on your policy and will not affect this years premium.

Regards
A fit sounding young lady
Service Advisor
Liverpool Victoria General Insurance
------------------------------------------------------------------


So what are you thoughts on mixing similair tread patterns (Different manufacturer)

Would you risk a "V" Rating ?

T1-R 91 V



SP9000 ZR



FFG How you getting on with the SP9000 Fronts ?

or should i ask the boss


>> Edited by seasider on Tuesday 16th May 11:39

HughesieII

12,790 posts

311 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
I've ordered the Falkens for the front of mine, W rated from austec - expensive as they were £20 a tyre more than from Camskill but easier to get done while the car is being finished off - i'm not a fan of the Toyo's as i find them too grippy to a point then they give up, where as the Falkens are progressive - the rears i buy as good and cheap as possible, mine dont normally last long currently running Kumho 712 Ecsta's and they are 2 or 3 times better than the So2's i had ion the rears before

oggs

8,817 posts

283 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
Del I have Falkens on the fronts and Toyos on the rears.. No probs

HughesieII

12,790 posts

311 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
oggs said:
Del I have Falkens on the fronts and Toyos on the rears.. No probs


how you liking the Falkens ??

Del, dont forget to let the insurance company know if you end up fitting the V's !!

seasider

Original Poster:

12,728 posts

278 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
HughesieII said:

Del, dont forget to let the insurance company know if you end up fitting the V's !!
Berk

V8 Archie

4,703 posts

277 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
seasider said:
Would you risk a "V" Rating ?
The way you drive?

Have you managed to locate either of those makes of tyre yet? I'd see what is confirmed as available before you start making decisions. (I spent last week looking for four tyres so I know what I'm on about ).

jeremyc

28,123 posts

313 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
Without wishing to teach anyone to suck eggs, you do know that 'V' speed rating tyres are rated to a maximum speed less than the quote top speed of a Griffith (let alone a modified one), don't you? I can't see how this can be a good idea for such a safety critical component.

As a reminder (full details here):
'V' - 149mph max.
'W' - 168mph max.
'Z' - 150+mph

seasider

Original Poster:

12,728 posts

278 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
V8 Archie said:
seasider said:
Would you risk a "V" Rating ?
The way you drive?


V8 Archie said:
Have you managed to locate either of those makes of tyre yet?


Yes tks

RichardD

3,608 posts

274 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
jeremyc said:
...I can't see how this can be a good idea for such a safety critical component. ...
Unless you do more than 149mph then what is the problem with V tyres? Unless I'm mistaken a speed rating is exactly that speed - not grip... ?

jeremyc

28,123 posts

313 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
RichardD said:
jeremyc said:
...I can't see how this can be a good idea for such a safety critical component. ...
Unless you do more than 149mph then what is the problem with V tyres? Unless I'm mistaken a speed rating is exactly that speed - not grip... ?
The speed rating is a method of identifying tyres of a suitable performance for a given vehicle. It is not simply about maximum speed, but also rates of acceleration, deceleration and lateral forces that are likely to be expected.

Would you buy a crash helmet that could only survive a 2kg impact because you weren't planning on banging your head with any greater force?

Besides, I just know seasider is going to exceed 149mph.

>> Edited by jeremyc on Tuesday 16th May 13:55

seasider

Original Poster:

12,728 posts

278 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
RichardD said:
jeremyc said:
...I can't see how this can be a good idea for such a safety critical component. ...
Unless you do more than 149mph then what is the problem with V tyres? Unless I'm mistaken a speed rating is exactly that speed - not grip... ?


I have been known to Richard (not for extended periods)

I know what your saying Jeremy

Welsh bloke.... The link you sent me are "V" rated as well

Edited for Jeremy's last post

Not that often

>> Edited by seasider on Tuesday 16th May 14:01

RichardD

3,608 posts

274 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
jeremyc said:
...nono: The speed rating is a method of identifying tyres of a suitable performance for a given vehicle. It is not simply about maximum speed, but also rates of acceleration, deceleration and lateral forces that are likely to be expected....

I get your point, but there must be cars that can put huge forces through VR or lower rated tyres than TVR's due to weight and bad balance (FWD diesel shopping trollies inparticular) if cornered hard?

A lorry must put a lot more force through its tyres than a Caterham, but they have a lower "speed rating", but are capable of coping with more force.

Were the Avons on Caterham R300 and R400 better than VR, as these cars had plenty of acceleration / deceleration ?
For standard cars and road driving, I don't see a problem with V's.
Anyway for a modified TVR 500 it does make sense to go with the best available for track / runway urges

Sorry for nitpicking,

zippee

14,125 posts

263 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
Personally I wouldn't, especially given the way you drive Del.
How about a W rated Falken FK452?
Not used them myself but did use the 451s they replaced and liked them a lot.

FlipFlopGriff

7,144 posts

276 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
Del,
The SP9000's are as good as the Toyo as far as I can see. Haven't really been trying too hard though as have been running in again. Got 205/55/ZR15's (SP9000) on the front and Toyo T1R 245/45/ZR16 (W rated) on the rear).
Seem to mix well and no noticable difference in Toyo T1S front and rear (on other wheels). Been round roundabouts pretty quick and it holds really well but the full suspension rebuild and drop links will have assisted.

If the Toyo was available in W rated i'd have stuck with them as the T1S was a fantastic improvement on the Bridgestone, which I can't believe people rave about.
As most will know car is driven daily, rain, shine, snow by both myself and Mrs FFG. Is very good in the wet but still treat with great respect.

Wanted to keep this short but oh well.
FFG

>> Edited by FlipFlopGriff on Tuesday 16th May 17:03

seasider

Original Poster:

12,728 posts

278 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all




Fk it... Might get some R888

davidy

4,492 posts

313 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
A cautionary tail

A few years ago we put my wheels and tyres (TVR Taimar) - then H rated old system up to 135mph, on a friends TVR M Turbo to go on a trackday, seemed fair, we'd both drive his car but on my wheels/tyres.

At the end of the day I was missing whole and partial tread blocks (explain that to the MOT man!), even though it was a slow track and we probably never exceeded 90-100mph.

You are buying part of a package that includes acceleration and braking.

My advise is don't do it.

davidy

V8 Archie

4,703 posts

277 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
Del, YHM if I've got the address right - drop me a line if you haven't.

ads

1,369 posts

286 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
I have got SP9000's all round on mine and I think they are fantastic. I had Bridgestone S02's before and they are a vast improvement over them! I would not go the V rated route myself.

bluebottle

3,498 posts

269 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
seasider said:




Fk it... Might get some R888


Stuck triple 8's on my old rims for track days which are very good but i wouldnt want to run the on wet open roads so went for different rims for daily use, as previous experience of mixed makes/treads/tyre compound have not been good

tweety

829 posts

288 months

Tuesday 16th May 2006
quotequote all
Also the car would fail the MOT, and possibly roadside check?, if the tyres were rated lower than the cars top speed.

Al.