No German cheap to maintain executive sedan under 15k?
No German cheap to maintain executive sedan under 15k?
Author
Discussion

raspberry-26

Original Poster:

45 posts

3 months

Need a highway cruiser. Ideally executive sedan that will be 12-15k that I can drive mostly on the motorway and on trips in Europe.

For that money I can get a 2018-2020 ES 300h, a 2020 Mazda 6 or some type of Accord. The thing is I want to own the car for 5-7 years and put ~50k miles on it and I think a German car like a 5 series or A6 will just be too expensive as it will need at least 1 major repair - water pump or gearbox or something in the engine.

Also, due to everything becoming more expensive I think people are keeping their cars for longer and fewer are upgrading when the newer model knocks on the door, thus I am afraid some of the out of warranty German cars sold might have developed an expensive issue before they were listed an issue which the owner deemed too expensive to repair and wanted to give someone else the honour of sorting. This is the reason I prefer Japanese, buy there also is another big issue.

Despite my desire to drive and the excitement of exploring new places like France and Italy I understand that driving in foreign countries leads to a higher risk of getting involved in a crash. Thus I prefer a car that is safe. The issue with Japanese cars is they are usually lighter than their European counterparts and also the fact that I prefer to avoid SUVs (due to worse driving dynamics) makes me want to buy a car that is in the 1.8-2 tonne range, but few of the manufacturers that make cars considered reliable make sedans this heavy. I understand that a lighter car is more maneuverable yet a quarter a ton more in a crash can be beneficial as sometimes the opposite driver might not give me a chance to maneuver.

I am also open to non German European brands but unfortunately the likes of Volvo stopped manufacturing sedans altogether and I avoid electrics like the new EX90 which is more like a crossover as I feel like it I drive an electric every second I will feel like the battery will burst into flames.

paddy1970

1,505 posts

139 months

The Lexus ES 300h is your best overall option.

However, the Volvo S90 (T4 / T5 / D4) and the clone Toyota Camry Hybrid (2019-2021) are worth a look

kambites

71,594 posts

251 months

Isn't this requirement set pretty much the reason Lexus exist?

Yahonza

4,158 posts

60 months

Is it half-term?

Super Sonic

14,646 posts

84 months

You post an awful lot of "what car should I buy" threads, going back to July, haven't you bought one yet?

ZX10R NIN

30,619 posts

155 months

raspberry-26 said:
Need a highway cruiser. Ideally executive sedan that will be 12-15k that I can drive mostly on the motorway and on trips in Europe.

For that money I can get a 2018-2020 ES 300h, a 2020 Mazda 6 or some type of Accord. The thing is I want to own the car for 5-7 years and put ~50k miles on it and I think a German car like a 5 series or A6 will just be too expensive as it will need at least 1 major repair - water pump or gearbox or something in the engine.

Also, due to everything becoming more expensive I think people are keeping their cars for longer and fewer are upgrading when the newer model knocks on the door, thus I am afraid some of the out of warranty German cars sold might have developed an expensive issue before they were listed an issue which the owner deemed too expensive to repair and wanted to give someone else the honour of sorting. This is the reason I prefer Japanese, buy there also is another big issue.

Despite my desire to drive and the excitement of exploring new places like France and Italy I understand that driving in foreign countries leads to a higher risk of getting involved in a crash. Thus I prefer a car that is safe. The issue with Japanese cars is they are usually lighter than their European counterparts and also the fact that I prefer to avoid SUVs (due to worse driving dynamics) makes me want to buy a car that is in the 1.8-2 tonne range, but few of the manufacturers that make cars considered reliable make sedans this heavy. I understand that a lighter car is more maneuverable yet a quarter a ton more in a crash can be beneficial as sometimes the opposite driver might not give me a chance to maneuver.

I am also open to non German European brands but unfortunately the likes of Volvo stopped manufacturing sedans altogether and I avoid electrics like the new EX90 which is more like a crossover as I feel like it I drive an electric every second I will feel like the battery will burst into flames.
You won't get an ES with less than a 110k on the clock & it'll be a CAT car for less than 15k.

Alternates

Kia Stinger:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202609105...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202610247...

Hyundai Genesis:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202604081...

2.0d 508 GT Line:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202601129...

Q70 Sport:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202610096...

CLS350d Premium, they're pretty much bulletproof:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202609246...

220d:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202602210...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202604041...

2.0 BiTDI Insignia:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202601129...

Arteon:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202609296...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202610086...

Mammasaid

5,621 posts

127 months

Tesla Model 3, with the advantage that if it goes up in flames we won't have any more inane threads like these to read.

valiant

14,283 posts

190 months

AI still stuck with Americanisms.

Bad bot.

Maxym

3,059 posts

266 months

AI ramble…

LightweightLouisDanvers

2,993 posts

73 months

"Sedan" a very American term?

Pica-Pica

16,675 posts

114 months

LightweightLouisDanvers said:
"Sedan" a very American term?
Nope: very English, as in a sedan chair. Actually very Latin in the word's origin.

Super Sonic

14,646 posts

84 months

Pica-Pica said:
Nope: very English, as in a sedan chair. Actually very Latin in the word's origin.
Yeah same as hood, trunk or fender, they're all English words.
Come to think of it, aren't most 'American' words actually English?

Monkeylegend

29,500 posts

261 months

Just to say I have had my F10 2015 528I for nearly 6 years and in 40k miles it has needed nothing bar 4 tyres and routine servicing and averages 43 mpg on a longish run.

Also very cheap to insure, £247 this year, and £18.81 a month to tax.

Not all German saloons are unreliable or expensive to maintain. Find a good non-franchise garage and servicing is cheaper than my neighbour is paying for his Dacia Logan smile

Just had a brake fluid change for £67, and the last service was £276 including oil change and plugs.

Wills2

29,775 posts

205 months

Super Sonic said:
Pica-Pica said:
Nope: very English, as in a sedan chair. Actually very Latin in the word's origin.
Yeah same as hood, trunk or fender, they're all English words.
Come to think of it, aren't most 'American' words actually English?
Of course given that they speak English.



blueg33

46,761 posts

254 months

Pica-Pica said:
Nope: very English, as in a sedan chair. Actually very Latin in the word's origin.
Its because you "sid down" in it..........getmecoat

mikeyr

3,404 posts

223 months

Look back at any of your many many many previous posts on the same subject and choose a car from the many many many cars that have been suggested.

raspberry-26

Original Poster:

45 posts

3 months

mikeyr said:
Look back at any of your many many many previous posts on the same subject and choose a car from the many many many cars that have been suggested.
Thanks. Most of the answers recommend German maybe at the end of the day I will get a kia and that will be it.

mikeyr

3,404 posts

223 months

Sounds a good plan.

Super Sonic

14,646 posts

84 months

Wills2 said:
Super Sonic said:
Pica-Pica said:
Nope: very English, as in a sedan chair. Actually very Latin in the word's origin.
Yeah same as hood, trunk or fender, they're all English words.
Come to think of it, aren't most 'American' words actually English?
Of course given that they speak English.
Except they use different words for various things eg parts of cars, hence them being known as 'Americanisms'

Derry Rhumba

360 posts

21 months

"Whatchoo talkin' bout Willis", is also an american term.