Automatic, Low road noise, not low ground clearance, £12k?
Automatic, Low road noise, not low ground clearance, £12k?
Author
Discussion

burton1986

Original Poster:

4 posts

Tuesday 1st September
quotequote all
- Wife insists on automatic, she is a very new driver
- We do mostly road trips from our place near Reading to the Highlands (Isle of Skye and further north)
- It will be nice to have just a bit of ground clearance. I don't do any off-roading but the roads up north are sometimes pretty bad
- Road noise is very important. On our long trips, it's actually tiring to listen to music all the time. So, we need something pretty hushed
- Has to be decent reliability
- Don't care about sports but it's important that it feels composed in windy mountain roads and have a bit of grunt for the uphill

Initially, I was looking at a T-Roc but hearing that it's an "over-stressed Golf on stilts" and that the gearbox is "jerky at urban speeds" - but not sure what this means and if it's even objectively true.

So, started looking into XC40 but:
- Volvo reliability and, since it's a "premium" car, parts cost is going to be tragic?
- Reading the forum here, I am seeing 30MPG? I am not penny-wise about every drop of fuel but I was hoping to get high 40's at 70 MPH?

The more I read, the more I am confused - Help! smile

bennno

15,230 posts

298 months

Tuesday 1st September
quotequote all

Mercedes estate

DKL

4,965 posts

251 months

Tuesday 1st September
quotequote all
All road versions of a4/a6, skoda octavia, maybe superb and the e class. Slightly raised ride height and some body "protection".
Could be ideal
https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202608245...

or

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202605232...

or
https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202607244...

ZX10R NIN

30,533 posts

154 months

Tuesday 1st September
quotequote all
burton1986 said:
- Wife insists on automatic, she is a very new driver
- We do mostly road trips from our place near Reading to the Highlands (Isle of Skye and further north)
- It will be nice to have just a bit of ground clearance. I don't do any off-roading but the roads up north are sometimes pretty bad
- Road noise is very important. On our long trips, it's actually tiring to listen to music all the time. So, we need something pretty hushed
- Has to be decent reliability
- Don't care about sports but it's important that it feels composed in windy mountain roads and have a bit of grunt for the uphill

Initially, I was looking at a T-Roc but hearing that it's an "over-stressed Golf on stilts" and that the gearbox is "jerky at urban speeds" - but not sure what this means and if it's even objectively true.

So, started looking into XC40 but:
- Volvo reliability and, since it's a "premium" car, parts cost is going to be tragic?
- Reading the forum here, I am seeing 30MPG? I am not penny-wise about every drop of fuel but I was hoping to get high 40's at 70 MPH?

The more I read, the more I am confused - Help! smile
The DS7 is a very good option, they've got a conventional auto so no dual clutch jerkiness (although it's not every car) & they drive well:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202602250...

You can get the same drivetrain as the above but because of the badge you can also get the hybrid version:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202608265...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202609015...

Kia Xceed:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202607164...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202608145...

1.6 Captur ETech:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202604291...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202608285...

Alan_B

54 posts

101 months

Wednesday 2nd September
quotequote all
Just got my mum into an auto TRoc recently, 1.5T petrol.

Great wee car. Well equipped, drives lovely and I cannot see how anyone could say the gearbox is jerky. 7sp DSG, the gear changes are seamless.

She is nearly 70 though so maybe they are a granny car biggrin

loskie

7,084 posts

149 months

Wednesday 2nd September
quotequote all
Any 2wd VAG Group SUV from Arona to Karoq


Dacia Duster 2WD?


Toyota Corrola Trek if you can find one.

vikingaero

13,181 posts

198 months

Wednesday 2nd September
quotequote all
I'll hate myself for saying it but would you consider a Citroen C5 Aircross?

Auto, quiet, SUV and height clearance, the comfiest seats in the entire universe, only downside is slightly larger size.

JimmyConwayNW

3,625 posts

154 months

Wednesday 2nd September
quotequote all
Ford Puma

loskie

7,084 posts

149 months

Wednesday 2nd September
quotequote all
I have had a few rental Pumas. Initially liked them. That wore off.

Some cars that have surprised me are new Renault models

burton1986

Original Poster:

4 posts

Wednesday 2nd September
quotequote all
"Toyota Corrola Trek"
- That's the ideal car but the ones I've found were like 20k... Maybe if I expanded to 100k miles (which might just be fine, considering the simplicity of the moving parts and Toyota being Toyota)...

loskie

7,084 posts

149 months

Thursday 3rd September
quotequote all
Jeez is that the price of them. You could have got them for not much more when new.
They "should" be in your price range now but used car prices are still mental.

I think they were a bit of a sales flop.

But probably a very good car.

_Rodders_

3,940 posts

48 months

Thursday 3rd September
quotequote all
loskie said:
Any 2wd VAG Group SUV from Arona to Karoq


Dacia Duster 2WD?


Toyota Corrola Trek if you can find one.
Duster would fail the low road noise, they're not well insulated.

_Rodders_

3,940 posts

48 months

Thursday 3rd September
quotequote all
What about something like a Lexus RX450H.


sawman

5,167 posts

259 months

Thursday 3rd September
quotequote all
vikingaero said:
I'll hate myself for saying it but would you consider a Citroen C5 Aircross?

Auto, quiet, SUV and height clearance, the comfiest seats in the entire universe, only downside is slightly larger size.
This is a good call, a pal just picked one of these up for about 10k, so even ticks the budget box

occasionalranter

450 posts

75 months

Thursday 3rd September
quotequote all
MK2 or current Tiguan. More refined than smaller VW suvs and than Skoda and seat equivalents.

Ideal for those very long journeys would be a MK2 sel with ergo comfort seats and either 2.0tdi or 1.5tsi. we have one in the family since new 7 years ago, has just been handed down to one of our children.

Paddymcc

1,297 posts

220 months

Thursday 3rd September
quotequote all
MG ZS hybrid new for about 16k. You should get a used 2025 model in your price range

Test Drove one a few months back for my father that was 10months old and had covered 30k miles. There wasn't a squeak or rattle from it. Brilliant LED headlights and was pretty comfortable too.

The guy that owned it was commuting back and forth to Dublin on a daily basis.

They also come with a 7yr warranty and will easily do 50mpg.

Honestly couldnt fault it and wanted to hate it and steer him towards a Toyota yaris cross.

SAS Tom

3,754 posts

203 months

Thursday 3rd September
quotequote all
Lexus RX or NX

Rough101

3,052 posts

104 months

Thursday 3rd September
quotequote all
The XC40 T3 we had used less fuel than the diesel Evoque it replaced, will do 40’s on a run no problem and averaged about 38 IIRC.

DD3566

131 posts

103 months

Thursday 3rd September
quotequote all
This seems like a perfect use case for a Volvo XC70:

The 2.4L D5 5 Cylinder Diesel lump is legendary for its reliability, although i've always been tempted by the 3.0L Straight 6 Petrol such as this:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202606153...

CoupeKid

988 posts

94 months

Thursday 3rd September
quotequote all
We've got an XC40.

It's been perfectly reliable for us.

Economy is going to vary with the engine but we've got a T5 and see 42mpg+ on a long trip.

They are pleasantly quiet. I regularly drive around the Surrey section of the M25 which is cement rather than tarmac and it's the quietest modern car I've had on that surface. Not having low profile tyres helps.

The XC40 has been out a while now and has been very popular. They come in a wide variety of engines, trim levels and colours so you should be able to find something suitable.