Coldwater - ITV drama
Author
Discussion

quigonjay

Original Poster:

1,138 posts

238 months

Monday 15th September
quotequote all
https://imdb.com/title/tt32778097/

John moves his family to a rural town, befriends the enigmatic neighbor next door Tommy who is hiding dark secrets. John's fascination with Tommy grows as wife Fiona becomes suspicious, leading to dangerous unraveling of hidden truths and repressed anger.

Some quite negative reviews so far on IMDB mostly concentrated around it being a familiar story that has been done before. Whilst that might be true I quite enjoyed it, thought it was well produced with some good performances 7/10

cuprabob

17,103 posts

231 months

Tuesday 16th September
quotequote all
I'm 4 episodes in and although I'm enjoying it, Ewen Bremner's performance is carrying it.

It kind of reminds me of the BBC Drama "Guilt" with it's dry humour.


119

14,045 posts

53 months

Tuesday 16th September
quotequote all
We did a couple last night and it is quite good, although as the reviews have said, it is all sort of familiar story lines.

mind you, I am sure there is a big twist coming at some point though!

Gary29

4,614 posts

116 months

Tuesday 16th September
quotequote all
We're 3/4 of the way through now. Was hoping for a bit of wife swap action, or seeing Eve Myles in that hot tub, but nothing in that regard just yet.

Andrew Lincoln's character is really annoying, in fact they're all annoying, I don't care what happens to any of them, and it's starting to feel a bit long winded for no reason.

I can take it or leave it at this point, 6/10 so far, but I don't see it improving without a big twist.

HTP99

24,221 posts

157 months

Tuesday 16th September
quotequote all
Finished episode 2 last night, frankly it's all a bit weird, however I want to known how it pans out, but I feel it could easily be one of those series you start, then life takes over and 6 weeks later you've forgotten about it and then realise by accident you've not finished it but aren't that bothered.

TX1

2,708 posts

200 months

Tuesday 16th September
quotequote all
Watched a couple of episodes and enjoying it so far however not sure Andrew Lincoln is the right person for the part, he does not come across as the weak type of guy.

Hants PHer

6,292 posts

128 months

Tuesday 16th September
quotequote all
I got about 40 minutes in to episode 1 before concluding that it was carp and not worth continuing with.

I think if you're going to do a drama like this one, you need to at least make some of the characters likeable. If the viewer simply thinks "Well, they're all weirdos and I dislike all of them - including the kids!" then there's no reason to keep watching. 2/10.

DSLiverpool

15,705 posts

219 months

Tuesday 16th September
quotequote all
Hants PHer said:
I got about 40 minutes in to episode 1 before concluding that it was carp and not worth continuing with.

I think if you're going to do a drama like this one, you need to at least make some of the characters likeable. If the viewer simply thinks "Well, they're all weirdos and I dislike all of them - including the kids!" then there's no reason to keep watching. 2/10.
Agree, the lead husband is beyond realistic in his sthouse actions.

Terminator X

18,250 posts

221 months

Tuesday 16th September
quotequote all
Bit odd. Not sure that humour and "horror" mix well here.

TX.

Speed 3

5,144 posts

136 months

Tuesday 16th September
quotequote all
DSLiverpool said:
Hants PHer said:
I got about 40 minutes in to episode 1 before concluding that it was carp and not worth continuing with.

I think if you're going to do a drama like this one, you need to at least make some of the characters likeable. If the viewer simply thinks "Well, they're all weirdos and I dislike all of them - including the kids!" then there's no reason to keep watching. 2/10.
Agree, the lead husband is beyond realistic in his sthouse actions.
We only lasted 20.

119

14,045 posts

53 months

Thursday 18th September
quotequote all
Ok so so finished this last night with the last two episodes and...

What totally unbelievable garbage hehe




Shooter McGavin

8,340 posts

161 months

Friday 19th September
quotequote all
We watched it and loved it.

Not my usual thing I would admit. There is an element of black comedy about it. It is supposed to be completely implausible. Andrew Lincoln's irritating weakling character is supposed to annoy you. I thought Ewen Bremner played a psychopath particularly well. It's totally set up for Series 2 now

Don Veloci

2,100 posts

298 months

Friday 19th September
quotequote all
Completely daft hehe

Entirely geared to a second series. Eve Myles been the true psycho and Ewen Bremner being the puppet psycho who will implausibly avoid capture for series 2. Andrew Lincoln to be groomed by Eve possibly.

lornemalvo

3,434 posts

85 months

I get the feeling they left it open for another series. I hope not.

HTP99

24,221 posts

157 months

I've given up on this, we were looking last night at what we had recorded to watch and I just said I couldn't be bothered with it anymore.