Car du Jour
Author
Discussion

Leins

Original Poster:

9,958 posts

164 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
So for the last decade or so there seems to have been one particular car at any time that somehow captured the attention of PHers

It wasn’t necessarily the fastest, or most expensive, or even the most well liked. However, it seemed to me that there was always one that stood out as the most commented on, both positively and negatively

While obviously a slightly objective view, for me the list seemed to go as follows. I’m possibly missing some others inbetween, but the PH massive always seems to get excited with a performance car with daily driving capabilities. And then as soon as that happens will come the negative comments to knock it down, but all the while it’s very much in the PH spotlight for a good period of time

2012 BMW M135i
2014 Mk7 Golf R
2016 Mk3 Focus RS
2020 GR Yaris
2022 M3 Touring

However, since then I ve sort of lost track of what the PH car of the moment is. Is it now the Renault 5 or the new M5 perhaps?

Thought I’d open it up for general opinion


Edited by Leins on Wednesday 16th July 17:50

Leftfootwonder

1,312 posts

74 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
Is the GR Yaris really 5 years old? yikes I can still recall every owner desperately telling anyone who'll listen that they've got a GRY....

2020 would also be the 718 4.0 GTS?
2021 Ferrari Roma
2022 GR86
2023 Ferrari 296
2024 911 S/T/touring
2025...we're all bored of new cars.

Riley Blue

22,355 posts

242 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
Civic Type R must slot in there somewhere, FK2 or FK8 perhaps?

DaveyBoyWonder

3,221 posts

190 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
BMW 320D

Lefty

18,326 posts

218 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
MX5 surely

Portofino

4,788 posts

207 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
Not sure what the latest one is as seems to be a spilt with BEV/ICE but seems the French stuff is being pushed hard but for me money no object & a few years back 911 Dakar, these days the BEV RR appeals for sanctimonious cruising alongside the new Golf Clubsport S for everyday fun.

carinaman

23,304 posts

188 months

Leins

Original Poster:

9,958 posts

164 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
Leftfootwonder said:
Is the GR Yaris really 5 years old? yikes I can still recall every owner desperately telling anyone who'll listen that they've got a GRY....

2020 would also be the 718 4.0 GTS?
2021 Ferrari Roma
2022 GR86
2023 Ferrari 296
2024 911 S/T/touring
2025...we're all bored of new cars.
I think you could be correct! biggrin

Yes the GRY was everywhere, winning best hot hatch ever awards and then being criticised for not being enough fun

The Mk3 Focus RS was the same. Everyone was buying them, they were the best car ever, then tales of dodgy diffs, argument after argument on here, and then… I’ve not heard them being mentioned in years!

Leins

Original Poster:

9,958 posts

164 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
Riley Blue said:
Civic Type R must slot in there somewhere, FK2 or FK8 perhaps?
Good point, I think it does too. The FK2 was the first of the “ugly” ones, and that seemed to generate a lot of debate about 2015

Leins

Original Poster:

9,958 posts

164 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
DaveyBoyWonder said:
BMW 320D
I’ll see your 320d and raise you the 335d, especially in mapped / DXB-form circa 2008

sutts

1,033 posts

164 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
M135i - junior supercar IIRC!

Lefty

18,326 posts

218 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
Leins said:
DaveyBoyWonder said:
BMW 320D
I ll see your 320d and raise you the 335d, especially in mapped / DXB-form circa 2008
fk me, was it that long ago?

LightweightLouisDanvers

2,559 posts

59 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
Seems to be the Dacia Duster now rolleyes

rodericb

7,996 posts

142 months

Wednesday 16th July
quotequote all
Renault 5 is picking up some momentum.

Leins

Original Poster:

9,958 posts

164 months

Thursday 17th July
quotequote all
sutts said:
M135i - junior supercar IIRC!
biggrin Was his name Carl? So much debate over whether it was a real M-car or not too

PRO5T

5,870 posts

41 months

Thursday 17th July
quotequote all
2010 BMW 1M Coupe
2013 Golf R on a cheap lease
2015 Porsche Cayman GT4
2016 BMW M2

Cold

16,062 posts

106 months

Thursday 17th July
quotequote all
Outlier here - none of the cars mentioned so far blow my kilt up at all.

jhonn

1,632 posts

165 months

Thursday 17th July
quotequote all
14, 15 years ago? the Skoda Yeti had a high profile and was widely lauded - I recently watched a Top Gear rerun where they pitched it against a Ferrari 308(?) and Clarkson really bigged it up. It's still a popular, sought after car nowadays.

Nowadays the French manufacturers, particularly Renault with their 4 and 5 seem to be 'hot'.

Mr Tidy

27,086 posts

143 months

Thursday 17th July
quotequote all
The MX5 seems to have been a contender for years!