One for the Unifi Experts - upgrading

[Magnum 475]

The time has come to replace my aging Unifi USG & Linux-based controller. Openreach have finally brought FTTP to our village, and I want fast broadband!

My USG has a max throughput of 80Mbs, less with the security I’ve got configured. So, time for a UDM Pro, or even a Pro Max for the RAID 1 array. This means migrating off the Linux controller, and having the UDM Pro as the controller…

There’s a process described here that looks promising:

https://techbits.io/migrate-unifi-cloudkey-usg-udm...

Has anyone tried this, and if so, did it work??

[CharlesElliott]

I followed something like that and it worked fine.

Bear in mind you will need a fibre modem in bridge mode to connect to the WAN port on the UDM Pro.

[Magnum 475]

Excellent, thanks

The bridge mode is what I plan to do. Current system uses a VDSL modem to the WAN port on the USG.

[megaphone]

Why a UDM-Pro? Why not one of the newer devices like a Cloud Gateway Max? This is just for a home? Save yourself some money.

Edited by megaphone on Tuesday 1st April 07:59

[Magnum 475]

The UDM Pro also has RAID 1 Protect storage, and my cameras and Synology NAS are all well past their sell-by dates.

I also want to add the CyberSecure protection add-on, and that can really eat memory. So a device with plenty of RAM makes sense.

[964Cup]

Why stay with Unifi? We switched to Cisco Meraki; better radios, better management. IMO, YMMV etc.

[Magnum 475]

That would mean changing everything - switches, access points, the lot! I’ve got a good Ubiquity setup, just need to modernise the firewall….

[weeboot]

Magnum 475 said:

The UDM Pro also has RAID 1 Protect storage, and my cameras and Synology NAS are all well past their sell-by dates.

I also want to add the CyberSecure protection add-on, and that can really eat memory. So a device with plenty of RAM makes sense.

Are you sure about the RAID1 for Protect? You'd need an NVR as well to achieve that.
Perhaps check your requirements if the UDM Pro is your decision. I say this with a UDM Pro in my rack with a single 3Tb drive in it.

[sjg]

I did a pretty straightforward backup/restore when I moved from a USG and Linux controller to a UCG Ultra. Worked fine. On FTTP you just run Ethernet from the ONT box to the WAN port and put in your pppoe credentials.

[Magnum 475]

weeboot said:

Are you sure about the RAID1 for Protect? You'd need an NVR as well to achieve that.
Perhaps check your requirements if the UDM Pro is your decision. I say this with a UDM Pro in my rack with a single 3Tb drive in it.

The UDM ProMax is a new-ish release with RAID 1. But sadly not with the PoE from the UDM Pro SE.

[Baldchap]

weeboot said:

Magnum 475 said:

The UDM Pro also has RAID 1 Protect storage, and my cameras and Synology NAS are all well past their sell-by dates.

I also want to add the CyberSecure protection add-on, and that can really eat memory. So a device with plenty of RAM makes sense.

Are you sure about the RAID1 for Protect? You'd need an NVR as well to achieve that.
Perhaps check your requirements if the UDM Pro is your decision. I say this with a UDM Pro in my rack with a single 3Tb drive in it.

Not much RAID happening there!

Just checked my NVR Pro and that is configured RAID5, despite me not remembering doing it.

Edited by Baldchap on Wednesday 2nd April 08:01

[HantsRat]

964Cup said:

Why stay with Unifi? We switched to Cisco Meraki; better radios, better management. IMO, YMMV etc.

For home use? Meraki required a paid subscription!

[Magnum 475]

Baldchap said:

Not much RAID happening there!

Just checked my NVR Pro and that is configured RAID5, despite me not remembering doing it.

Edited by Baldchap on Wednesday 2nd April 08:01

Yup - the Pro Max is the RAID 1 version. And is probably what I’ll be getting.

[Murph7355]

sjg said:

I did a pretty straightforward backup/restore when I moved from a USG and Linux controller to a UCG Ultra. Worked fine. On FTTP you just run Ethernet from the ONT box to the WAN port and put in your pppoe credentials.

This. Did the same a few weeks ago when I finally tired of my USG glitching (I think PSU related, but the UCG wasn't expensive).

I wouldn't bother with Ubiquiti storage. Don't see the advantage. Unless you're going to invest in their cameras etc and use it for that.

[colin79666]

Why not just swap out the USG for a Cloud Gateway Ultra? Perfectly good unless you go over gigabit speed. Bit of a bargain under £100.

[Timothy Bucktu]

HantsRat said:

964Cup said:

Why stay with Unifi? We switched to Cisco Meraki; better radios, better management. IMO, YMMV etc.

For home use? Meraki required a paid subscription!

I'm glad you asked that, because I was sat here wondering WTF??