Two French air display jets crash in rehearsal

Two French air display jets crash in rehearsal

Author
Discussion

QuickQuack

Original Poster:

2,433 posts

112 months

Wednesday 26th March
quotequote all
I haven't seen this anywhere else on PH yet.

Tragedy avoided by the sound of it, pilots ejected, found "alive and conscious" but doesn't say much else about their condition. They could be badly injured from the mid-air collision.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/videos/cpv4gxx2dwzo

Even luckier it wasn't during an actual show or over a crowd.

QuickQuack

Original Poster:

2,433 posts

112 months

Wednesday 26th March
quotequote all
Gah, cocked up the title. paperbag If a passing mod could please sort that out, would be much appreciated!.

Scrump

23,213 posts

169 months

Wednesday 26th March
quotequote all
QuickQuack said:
Gah, cocked up the title. paperbag If a passing mod could please sort that out, would be much appreciated!.
thumbup

Eric Mc

123,387 posts

276 months

Wednesday 26th March
quotequote all
They had a similar crash back in 1983.

Are they still using Alpha Jets or have they upgraded now?

Riley Blue

22,084 posts

237 months

Wednesday 26th March
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
They had a similar crash back in 1983.

Are they still using Alpha Jets or have they upgraded now?
Alpha Jets according to the news report.

QuickQuack

Original Poster:

2,433 posts

112 months

Wednesday 26th March
quotequote all
Scrump said:
QuickQuack said:
Gah, cocked up the title. paperbag If a passing mod could please sort that out, would be much appreciated!.
thumbup
Thank you! beer

Apparently one of the 3 was a passenger, and one has multiple injuries but doesn't say which for obvious reasons.

https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20250326-thr...

I didn't realise that one could be a passenger on Patrouille de France flights! Who would that be? A pilot new to the team being trained or a non-pilot? If a non-pilot, what would they be doing there?

Austin Prefect

477 posts

3 months

Wednesday 26th March
quotequote all
QuickQuack said:
Thank you! beer

Apparently one of the 3 was a passenger, and one has multiple injuries but doesn't say which for obvious reasons.

https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20250326-thr...

I didn't realise that one could be a passenger on Patrouille de France flights! Who would that be? A pilot new to the team being trained or a non-pilot? If a non-pilot, what would they be doing there?
Possibly ground crew up for a jolly air experience. Possibly a journalist.

eharding

14,308 posts

295 months

Wednesday 26th March
quotequote all
Riley Blue said:
Eric Mc said:
They had a similar crash back in 1983.

Are they still using Alpha Jets or have they upgraded now?
Alpha Jets according to the news report.
Fitted with upgraded Martin Baker MK10-derived seats from 2009 onwards, significantly more capable than the old Mk4 seats and which might well have been the deciding factor in this case.

I was looking at the patriotic colour scheme on the parachute canopies as they descended - not sure if MB charge extra for that - which reminded out of the blue of a chap I haven't seen for probably 20 years, an Italian publisher who used to be a member of one of the Waltham Yak syndicates - he was always immaculately turned out in the best that Italian tailoring had to offer, and somehow even his flying overalls managed to invariably be free of the tenacious mixture of oil and crap that the Yaks liberally spread everywhere, but anyway we always used to joke that if Egidio ever had to bale out his parachute canopy would be some stunning Caraceni creation in the form of a silk Il Tricolore. Sadly, having just looked him up I realised he had died in a crash just outside of Padua in 2021, which I had somehow overlooked at the time.

Simpo Two

88,204 posts

276 months

Wednesday 26th March
quotequote all
Wow.

Three more for https://martin-baker.com/tie-club/

Given that there was a passenger on board, presumably untrained in the art of sudden exits, are they ejected automatically a second after the pilot goes?

Austin Prefect

477 posts

3 months

Wednesday 26th March
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Wow.

Three more for https://martin-baker.com/tie-club/

Given that there was a passenger on board, presumably untrained in the art of sudden exits, are they ejected automatically a second after the pilot goes?
Probably a moment before if they are in the back seat.

Typically they would have some training in ejection. Basically 'if I say eject pull this handle, otherwise whatever you do don't touch it'. But the seats are probably set up so that if the pilot pulls their handle, both seats go, if the passenger only their seat.

Hill92

4,793 posts

201 months

Wednesday 26th March
quotequote all
Austin Prefect said:
Simpo Two said:
Wow.

Three more for https://martin-baker.com/tie-club/

Given that there was a passenger on board, presumably untrained in the art of sudden exits, are they ejected automatically a second after the pilot goes?
Probably a moment before if they are in the back seat.

Typically they would have some training in ejection. Basically 'if I say eject pull this handle, otherwise whatever you do don't touch it'. But the seats are probably set up so that if the pilot pulls their handle, both seats go, if the passenger only their seat.
It depends on the aircraft type.

Some aircraft don't have command ejection at all.

Some have command ejection from the front seater only.

Some have command ejection from the rear seat only. This is the case in RAF Hawks. The Red Arrows lost an engineer in the rear seat in a crash in 2022. The front seat pilot got out just in time but he had means to command the ejection of his passenger.

Some aircraft can be configured for any combination of the above.

Simpo Two

88,204 posts

276 months

Wednesday 26th March
quotequote all
Hill92 said:
Austin Prefect said:
Simpo Two said:
Wow.

Three more for https://martin-baker.com/tie-club/

Given that there was a passenger on board, presumably untrained in the art of sudden exits, are they ejected automatically a second after the pilot goes?
Probably a moment before if they are in the back seat.

Typically they would have some training in ejection. Basically 'if I say eject pull this handle, otherwise whatever you do don't touch it'. But the seats are probably set up so that if the pilot pulls their handle, both seats go, if the passenger only their seat.
It depends on the aircraft type.

Some aircraft don't have command ejection at all.

Some have command ejection from the front seater only.

Some have command ejection from the rear seat only. This is the case in RAF Hawks. The Red Arrows lost an engineer in the rear seat in a crash in 2022. The front seat pilot got out just in time but he had means to command the ejection of his passenger.

Some aircraft can be configured for any combination of the above.
Interesting, thanks. It would seem sensible to set it to whoever's in charge.

aeropilot

37,558 posts

238 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Austin Prefect said:
QuickQuack said:
Thank you! beer

Apparently one of the 3 was a passenger, and one has multiple injuries but doesn't say which for obvious reasons.

https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20250326-thr...

I didn't realise that one could be a passenger on Patrouille de France flights! Who would that be? A pilot new to the team being trained or a non-pilot? If a non-pilot, what would they be doing there?
Possibly ground crew up for a jolly air experience. Possibly a journalist.
Might be a potential new pilot to team as well although maybe a bit late in the pre-season training schedule for that perhaps?
When the Red Arrows lost 4 pilots in the tragic syncro pair training accident way back in 1971, the two pilots in the rear seats of the Gnats were prospective new syncho pair pilots being shown the routine from the air.

Austin Prefect

477 posts

3 months

According to the Pprune forum, French AlphaJets don't have command ejection.

eharding

14,308 posts

295 months

Austin Prefect said:
According to the Pprune forum, French AlphaJets don't have command ejection.
They seem to be fixating on the note in the MB page about the MKF10LN seat that was used : "The twin seater aircraft is not equipped with a seat sequencer" - I might be wrong, but my understanding of an "ejection seat sequencer" is a system integrated with the airframe that constantly updates the seat with various sensor data from the aircraft - airspeed, height, attitude and the rate of change of those three so that in the event of an ejection the seat can adjust the sequence of actions to try and get the best chances of a favourable outcome, rather than it being related to command eject.

For example: https://www.teledynedefenseelectronics.com/what-we....


Edited by eharding on Friday 28th March 21:50