Complex wording help

Author
Discussion

Racehorse

Original Poster:

249 posts

22 months

Thursday 30th January
quotequote all
Can anyone help me understand what the following means:

If your employment is terminated at any time by reason of any reconstruction or amalgamation of the Company or any other companies belonging to the company, whether by winding up or otherwise, and you are offered employment with any concern or undertaking involved in or resulting from such reconstruction or amalgamation on terms which (considered in their entirety) are no less favourable to any material extent than the terms of this Agreement, you shall have no claim against the Company or any such undertaking arising out of or connected with such termination


Is this saying if I get worse terms, I cannot make a claim?

timbo999

1,401 posts

267 months

Thursday 30th January
quotequote all
Racehorse said:
terms which (considered in their entirety) are no less favourable to any material extent than the terms of this Agreement
I think this bit is saying you can't claim if the terms are as good as your present terms or better... the key being the highlighted word.

Doofus

29,794 posts

185 months

Thursday 30th January
quotequote all
If they end your job, but they offer you another job with the same or better terms, and you don't accept it, you can't claim against them for terminating your original job.

I'd want an assurance that TUPE would apply.

Racehorse

Original Poster:

249 posts

22 months

Thursday 30th January
quotequote all
Doofus said:
If they end your job, but they offer you another job with the same or better terms, and you don't accept it, you can't claim against them for terminating your original job.

I'd want an assurance that TUPE would apply.
Isn't what is written basically TUPE?

Doofus

29,794 posts

185 months

Thursday 30th January
quotequote all
Racehorse said:
Doofus said:
If they end your job, but they offer you another job with the same or better terms, and you don't accept it, you can't claim against them for terminating your original job.

I'd want an assurance that TUPE would apply.
Isn't what is written basically TUPE?
Not as such. There's no provision for employment rights, just a denial of termination rights.

Racehorse

Original Poster:

249 posts

22 months

Thursday 30th January
quotequote all
Doofus said:
Not as such. There's no provision for employment rights, just a denial of termination rights.
what do you mean employment rights? they are saying if terms are same or better?
Should I ask them for email confirmation then?

I don't think they will change wording of standard template contract

Doofus

29,794 posts

185 months

Thursday 30th January
quotequote all
Racehorse said:
Doofus said:
Not as such. There's no provision for employment rights, just a denial of termination rights.
what do you mean employment rights? they are saying if terms are same or better?
Should I ask them for email confirmation then?

I don't think they will change wording of standard template contract
TUPE (Transfer of Undertakings Protection of Employment) applies when you are moved from one company to another, following acquisition or restructure, for example, but your employement record is continuous.

So if you were at company A for five years, then moved to company B for a year, your period of employment is six years, not one. This is important when it comes to things like redundancy later down the line.

Racehorse

Original Poster:

249 posts

22 months

Thursday 30th January
quotequote all
Doofus said:
Racehorse said:
Doofus said:
Not as such. There's no provision for employment rights, just a denial of termination rights.
what do you mean employment rights? they are saying if terms are same or better?
Should I ask them for email confirmation then?

I don't think they will change wording of standard template contract
TUPE (Transfer of Undertakings Protection of Employment) applies when you are moved from one company to another, following acquisition or restructure, for example, but your employement record is continuous.

So if you were at company A for five years, then moved to company B for a year, your period of employment is six years, not one. This is important when it comes to things like redundancy later down the line.
Thank you, would email reply from them to my question be sufficient?

Doofus

29,794 posts

185 months

Thursday 30th January
quotequote all
Racehorse said:
Thank you, would email reply from them to my question be sufficient?
I think, essentially, they can't opt out of TUPE, but it's better to be clear up front. Asking them the question will show them you're not a dope, but if and when they do move you, you'll have to sign a new contract (because you'll have a new employer), and there should be a TUPE confirmation clause in there.

But getting it in an email now should give you some peace of mind

okgo

40,130 posts

210 months

Thursday 30th January
quotequote all
Does it pay £100k tho?

Racehorse

Original Poster:

249 posts

22 months

Friday 31st January
quotequote all
Doofus said:
I think, essentially, they can't opt out of TUPE, but it's better to be clear up front. Asking them the question will show them you're not a dope, but if and when they do move you, you'll have to sign a new contract (because you'll have a new employer), and there should be a TUPE confirmation clause in there.

But getting it in an email now should give you some peace of mind
Thanks I asked question and was told that is not in reference to TUPE but if a TUPE scenario happened it would be treated like that?

Doofus

29,794 posts

185 months

Friday 31st January
quotequote all
Racehorse said:
Doofus said:
I think, essentially, they can't opt out of TUPE, but it's better to be clear up front. Asking them the question will show them you're not a dope, but if and when they do move you, you'll have to sign a new contract (because you'll have a new employer), and there should be a TUPE confirmation clause in there.

But getting it in an email now should give you some peace of mind
Thanks I asked question and was told that is not in reference to TUPE but if a TUPE scenario happened it would be treated like that?
No, the clause itself isn't in reference to TUPE, but them moving your job would be. I'm not sure their answer is entirely unambiguous, but there's no real point in having a fight over something which may never happen.

The long and short of it is that if they try to move yiur job and you refuse, you'll be treated as if you resigned rather than got made redundant. If, however you agree to the move, the that's when you'll want to ensure TUPE works in your favour.

Chipstick

351 posts

52 months

Friday 31st January
quotequote all
There's still time for a fourth thread this week from the OP around contract wording.

Racehorse

Original Poster:

249 posts

22 months

Friday 31st January
quotequote all
Doofus said:
No, the clause itself isn't in reference to TUPE, but them moving your job would be. I'm not sure their answer is entirely unambiguous, but there's no real point in having a fight over something which may never happen.

The long and short of it is that if they try to move yiur job and you refuse, you'll be treated as if you resigned rather than got made redundant. If, however you agree to the move, the that's when you'll want to ensure TUPE works in your favour.
and TUPE can kick in without it being mentioned in contract?

MustangGT

12,808 posts

292 months

Saturday 1st February
quotequote all
Racehorse said:
and TUPE can kick in without it being mentioned in contract?
Absolutely, it is legislation, I have never seen a reference to TUPE in a job contract.

Doofus

29,794 posts

185 months

Saturday 1st February
quotequote all
MustangGT said:
Racehorse said:
and TUPE can kick in without it being mentioned in contract?
Absolutely, it is legislation, I have never seen a reference to TUPE in a job contract.
In this instance, there's a chance the job the OP is given would be a different one. If it wasthe same, or a similar role, then fair enough. If however, they're saying "In the event of a restructure, if your job is terminated, but we offer you something else...", then I'd want written ackowledgement that they will apply TUPE.