EV sales - according to how many left

EV sales - according to how many left

Author
Discussion

drgoatboy

Original Poster:

1,691 posts

212 months

Monday 23rd September
quotequote all
The initial message was deleted from this topic on 24 September 2024 at 06:14

plfrench

2,728 posts

273 months

Monday 23rd September
quotequote all
Seems a bit on the low side… around 1.2M registered according to the .gov.uk licensing stats

https://www.gov.uk/government/statistical-data-set...

Sheepshanks

34,355 posts

124 months

Monday 23rd September
quotequote all
Maybe it’s a regional thing (I’m in the poor NW) but I’m surprised that Kia Niro, Hyundai Kona, Jaguar iPace and Polestar 2 are in the same ballpark at mid 20’s K.

Mercedes EQC seems relatively high at almost 19K.


No Audis listed?

WonkeyDonkey

2,396 posts

108 months

Monday 23rd September
quotequote all
Surprised there's so little Citroens.

I see quite a few e-c4's near me

Wills2

23,886 posts

180 months

Tuesday 24th September
quotequote all

Shame the OP deleted his post, there were some big holes in the data like 38,000 BMW IX/1/3 cars but it was a start and an interesting discussion point, pop the data back up and we can add to it.


Sheepshanks

34,355 posts

124 months

Tuesday 24th September
quotequote all
Has it been deleted by mods or by the OP? Easy enough to see a cached version but I don't want to put it back if there's some reason not to.

drgoatboy

Original Poster:

1,691 posts

212 months

Tuesday 24th September
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
Has it been deleted by mods or by the OP? Easy enough to see a cached version but I don't want to put it back if there's some reason not to.
I took it down, I knew it was full of holes and I could see which way the discussion was going. If I get a chance I'll fill some of the holes.
The holes were mostly because of the way the data is presented on how many left where electric was mixed in with ice cars.
Plus I forgot about a bunch of stuff with ix

Wills2

23,886 posts

180 months

Tuesday 24th September
quotequote all

I'm intrigued now I'll have a go myself tonight and post mine up for ridicule ahem discussion!




drgoatboy

Original Poster:

1,691 posts

212 months

Tuesday 24th September
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
I'm intrigued now I'll have a go myself tonight and post mine up for ridicule ahem discussion!



Shoot me an email and I'll share the excel

NS66

181 posts

62 months

Thursday
quotequote all
plfrench said:
Seems a bit on the low side… around 1.2M registered according to the .gov.uk licensing stats

https://www.gov.uk/government/statistical-data-set...
Registered doesnt equate to sold :-)
I reckon there will be a load of EV's going on Autotrader registered 30/9/24 - dealers forced to pre reg to reach targets etc.

dhutch

14,999 posts

202 months

Thursday
quotequote all
NS66 said:
Registered doesnt equate to sold :-)
No, but its not an awful figure, as even pre-reg will be sold reasonably soon after, months not years.

dhutch

14,999 posts

202 months

Thursday
quotequote all
drgoatboy said:
I took it down, I knew it was full of holes...
bang it back up and let us add to it!

Sheepshanks

34,355 posts

124 months

Thursday
quotequote all
NS66 said:
Registered doesnt equate to sold :-)
I reckon there will be a load of EV's going on Autotrader registered 30/9/24 - dealers forced to pre reg to reach targets etc.
I want an EV to try, and our use case is perfect to save quite a bit on petrol costs, but I'm just not happy to pay current nearly-new prices. For anyone doing 10K ish per year, the price differential over ICE still doesn't make sense - be cheaper to buy ICE and pay for fuel.

What's a bit weird on Autotrader is some cars have sat there all year (there's even some 23 dated ads) yet others pop up at higher prices and then disappear, so presume sold. Everything seems to £K's above the CAP-HPI retail price too.

I reckon if there was a bit of a drop in nearly-new EV prices they'd all sell fast.

halo34

2,818 posts

204 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
I want an EV to try, and our use case is perfect to save quite a bit on petrol costs, but I'm just not happy to pay current nearly-new prices. For anyone doing 10K ish per year, the price differential over ICE still doesn't make sense - be cheaper to buy ICE and pay for fuel.

What's a bit weird on Autotrader is some cars have sat there all year (there's even some 23 dated ads) yet others pop up at higher prices and then disappear, so presume sold. Everything seems to £K's above the CAP-HPI retail price too.

I reckon if there was a bit of a drop in nearly-new EV prices they'd all sell fast.
If you scratch around there are deals, that are more realistic new so I guess it might filter down in time.

Hyundai for example - some good broker searching and its a more realistic price than RRP (I say that in the loosest sense).

Sheepshanks

34,355 posts

124 months

Thursday
quotequote all
halo34 said:
If you scratch around there are deals, that are more realistic new so I guess it might filter down in time.

Hyundai for example - some good broker searching and its a more realistic price than RRP (I say that in the loosest sense).
Looking at Kona Ultimate you can easily get 10%+ off list but the list pricing is mad. They're going to have to do something next year when +£40K VED comes in.

Having said that, I wonder how many private buyers there are for new EVs? It seems most are company cars, salary sacrifice, or Motability. Motability is huge for EVs - the deal is amazing. It feels like private buyers must be subsidising Motability deals.

drgoatboy

Original Poster:

1,691 posts

212 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
I want an EV to try, and our use case is perfect to save quite a bit on petrol costs, but I'm just not happy to pay current nearly-new prices. For anyone doing 10K ish per year, the price differential over ICE still doesn't make sense - be cheaper to buy ICE and pay for fuel.

What's a bit weird on Autotrader is some cars have sat there all year (there's even some 23 dated ads) yet others pop up at higher prices and then disappear, so presume sold. Everything seems to £K's above the CAP-HPI retail price too.

I reckon if there was a bit of a drop in nearly-new EV prices they'd all sell fast.
I've noticed similar. However I would ignore nearly new and go 1 year old+ that drop in the first year is huge and the. It seems to level out again. The delta between a 3 year old and a 1 year old enyaq for example is maybe 6k but they loose maybe 15k in year 1.
It's very similar to depreciation of old (but people seem to have forgotten that)

survivalist

5,824 posts

195 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
halo34 said:
If you scratch around there are deals, that are more realistic new so I guess it might filter down in time.

Hyundai for example - some good broker searching and its a more realistic price than RRP (I say that in the loosest sense).
Looking at Kona Ultimate you can easily get 10%+ off list but the list pricing is mad. They're going to have to do something next year when +£40K VED comes in.

Having said that, I wonder how many private buyers there are for new EVs? It seems most are company cars, salary sacrifice, or Motability. Motability is huge for EVs - the deal is amazing. It feels like private buyers must be subsidising Motability deals.
Even with private buyers the majority will be using PCP or leasing. So the discounts will come in the form of manufacturer/dealer contributions and / or unrealistic future values to keep the monthly payments nice and low.

We leased one at the end of March this year - was registered in Dec 2023 and there were a few different colours / spec to choose from.

Same with the Honda deal earlier this year - IIRC 8k deposit contribution and a guaranteed future value similar to what you could buy an ex demo one for at the time.

SteveKTMer

962 posts

36 months

There are some interesting videos on youtube about EV sales and dealers registering then storing cars in order to get the bonus and also reduce the number of fines the manufacturers will have to pay end of the year when the percentage of BEV to ICE is known.

If you look there are a huge number of very low miles cars for sale, 10, 50, 200 miles registered earlier this year. They look like demos, but the mileage is too low. Sort autotrader by EV only, miles under 500 and have a look.

I don't think this situation will last for ever, some EVs are pretty good value at 3 or 4 years old, like the Audi's, but I wouldn't be buying an EV now, I'd give it 12-18 months. I'd lease one if you get a good enough deal or even PCP if you're desperate, but buying a new EV with your own money right now looks a very poor decision.

Sheepshanks

34,355 posts

124 months

What I’m bemused about is the nearly new cars at non-franchise dealers.

Using the Hyundai Kona Ultimate as an example, local Kia dealer has a 500 mile 24 plate car, up for £2K more than the cheapest Hyundai dealer prices, although their cars have a few K miles on them.

I don’t know if the CAP HPI link someone on here sent me is the same as dealers use, but that shows trade value ££23K, retail £28K. Yet they’re asking £33K and, on the phone the sales guy said he was looking up CAP trade price and is £28K - I argued with him, but he insisted that what he was looking at.