Ouch - Safety car crashes

Ouch - Safety car crashes

Author
Discussion

Mammasaid

Original Poster:

4,607 posts

109 months

Jasandjules

70,840 posts

241 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
Looks a rear axle issue. Brakes or the actual axle to me as it went a bit "floppy" then lost it...

Sandpit Steve

12,060 posts

86 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
Video here: https://i.imgur.com/EZ8GUMh.mp4

It looks like it unsettles as he hits the brakes, then he pitches it into a spin when he realises he’s not making the corner. He’d have been somewhere close to 300kph at the start of his braking zone, they drive them pretty hard on Thursdays when they do the recce laps.

As it starts to spin, you can see that the rear brakes are glowing but the fronts aren’t, which says to me some sort of front brake failure.



The course cars are very much based on a road car rather than a race car, it’s basically out of the showroom minus the cats and plus a roll cage and all the FIA stuff. It’s not a GT3 car in disguise, and runs fast road tyres that can cope with rain. Brakes and suspension are all standard road car, supposedly for reliability reasons!!

CLK-GTR

1,405 posts

257 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
Oh dear Aston Martin! I think it very unlikely a driver of Maylander's calibre simply lost it there. Looks much more like a mechanical issue.

Muzzer79

11,691 posts

199 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
CLK-GTR said:
Oh dear Aston Martin! I think it very unlikely a driver of Maylander's calibre simply lost it there. Looks much more like a mechanical issue.
That's very presumptive

They push the safety car hard on Thursdays in order to prepare for the race weekend.

This is the first time I can recall the safety car actually making contact with a barrier but it's certainly not the first time the driver of it has lost control.


sandman77

2,769 posts

150 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
CLK-GTR said:
Oh dear Aston Martin! I think it very unlikely a driver of Maylander's calibre simply lost it there. Looks much more like a mechanical issue.
Really? Looks to me like he simply lost it under breaking. Happens to the best on occasion.

PhilAsia

5,453 posts

87 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all

I am inclined to think he hit the brakes...nothing..., hits the handbrake, the rear locks, then one tyre gains more traction as his hand comes back to the wheel, just as control of the rear is lost.

It may be better to wait for an explanation as to the circumstances though - if one is forthcoming.

StevieBee

14,032 posts

267 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
Logan Sargent's first day in his new job didn't go too well, then!

rider73

3,829 posts

89 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
i thought i saw somewhere on twitter confirmed as brake failure?

anonymous-user

66 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
eek Good job they have a backup safety car!

Peterpetrole

653 posts

9 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Looks a rear axle issue. Brakes or the actual axle to me as it went a bit "floppy" then lost it...
I'm going with this, axle ^^^^ looked unstable maybe before even braking. Monza curbs have been flattened this year apparently, was Maylander therefore hammering it harder over the curbs rather than threading it?

Presuming Ed

1,574 posts

220 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
Looks like he's gone for the brakes, realised there is little there and deliberately scandi flicked it into a slide to lose as much speed as possible before exiting fast off. Thats the difference between a them and us.

White-Noise

5,008 posts

260 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
I cant believe the standard brakes would be up to the job!

Silverbullet767

10,959 posts

218 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
Front right brake failure perhaps? Looks to take a dip to the left violently suggesting only that front brake did it's job. At that speed it's only going to end one way.

Glad everyone's ok

Sandpit Steve

12,060 posts

86 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
White-Noise said:
I cant believe the standard brakes would be up to the job!
The Mercedes version of the safety car, the AMG GT Black Series, set the Nurburgring production car lap record when it was first introduced. The AM version isn’t an awful lot slower. Both have carbon ceramic brakes as standard.

If you’re going to use a road car rather than a race car, which you want to because you don’t need all the performance but do need the reliability, there’s not much better out there. The SC needs to be able to start on a button every time, happily sit idling for an hour without cooking anything or anyone, and then launch into half a dozen hot laps at a few seconds’ notice.

White-Noise

5,008 posts

260 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
Sandpit Steve said:
White-Noise said:
I cant believe the standard brakes would be up to the job!
The Mercedes version of the safety car, the AMG GT Black Series, set the Nurburgring production car lap record when it was first introduced. The AM version isn’t an awful lot slower. Both have carbon ceramic brakes as standard.

If you’re going to use a road car rather than a race car, which you want to because you don’t need all the performance but do need the reliability, there’s not much better out there. The SC needs to be able to start on a button every time, happily sit idling for an hour without cooking anything or anyone, and then launch into half a dozen hot laps at a few seconds’ notice.
Ah The carbon brakes makes more sense. I've not owned a car like one of these but I would be interested as to how good the standard non-carbon brakes are.

Megaflow

10,277 posts

237 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
Presuming Ed said:
Looks like he's gone for the brakes, realised there is little there and deliberately scandi flicked it into a slide to lose as much speed as possible before exiting fast off. Thats the difference between a them and us.
Absolutely that ^

CLK-GTR

1,405 posts

257 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
Muzzer79 said:
That's very presumptive

They push the safety car hard on Thursdays in order to prepare for the race weekend.

This is the first time I can recall the safety car actually making contact with a barrier but it's certainly not the first time the driver of it has lost control.
Watch the video closely. The car twitches briefly at the braking zone but does not slow down, then you can see a second later he purposely flicks the wheel to send it into a spin. The image of glowing rear brakes suggests brake failure.

I'd be amazed if that's driver error.



Edited by CLK-GTR on Friday 30th August 14:18

Fessia fancier

1,233 posts

195 months

Friday 30th August 2024
quotequote all
Aramco meets Armco ….