CarTeck vs Garador/hormann sectional doors
CarTeck vs Garador/hormann sectional doors
Author
Discussion

JackReacher

Original Poster:

2,271 posts

243 months

Saturday 10th February 2024
quotequote all
Does anyone have experience of CarTeck garage doors? Garador/Hormann seem the most common recommendation on here for sectional doors, but 2 out of 3 of the local installers I have enquired with said that Carteck offered similar quality at a slightly lower cost. They also sell garador/hormann so install both.

Are carteck as good? Or do they get better margins with carteck?

JackReacher

Original Poster:

2,271 posts

243 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
Bump, anyone with experience of Carteck?

bennno

15,189 posts

297 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
No, Garador or is the cheaper version of hormann

Edited by bennno on Monday 12th February 06:21

PhilboSE

6,047 posts

254 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
Yup got 3 custom sized CarTeck doors in my garage.
They’re great. The fitter recommended Hormann openers though.

Can provide pics if you want.

Gren

2,030 posts

280 months

Monday 12th February 2024
quotequote all
Had one in for a couple of years now - Teckentrup branded. Seems to be the same as Carteck. Got a LiftMaster motor attached to it.

We had 3 local companies come to quote for the job. All did all the usual brands and all recommended the Teckentrup. Plenty of options around colours, windows etc

Not had a problem with ours at all. No maintenance needed so far although I'll need to grease them up this spring as they are getting a little squeaky at the hinges.

Edited by Gren on Monday 12th February 07:46

JackReacher

Original Poster:

2,271 posts

243 months

Monday 12th February 2024
quotequote all
PhilboSE said:
Yup got 3 custom sized CarTeck doors in my garage.
They’re great. The fitter recommended Hormann openers though.

Can provide pics if you want.
Thanks, pics would be welcome if easy to provide. Any particular reason they recommended hormann motors?

JackReacher

Original Poster:

2,271 posts

243 months

Monday 12th February 2024
quotequote all
Gren said:
Had one in for a couple of years now - Teckentrup branded. Seems to be the same as Carteck. Got a LiftMaster motor attached to it.

We had 3 local companies come to quote for the job. All did all the usual brands and all recommended the Teckentrup. Plenty of options around colours, windows etc

Not had a problem with ours at all. No maintenance needed so far although I'll need to grease them up this spring as they are getting a little squeaky at the hinges.

Edited by Gren on Monday 12th February 07:46
Thanks, I think teckentrup and carteck are the same company, much like hormann/garador. Good to know they have been trouble free!

Se7enheaven

2,066 posts

192 months

Monday 12th February 2024
quotequote all
Have a Hormann sectional single garage door. Been installed for about 6 years with no issues ( touch wood ). Very good quality.

PhilboSE

6,047 posts

254 months

Monday 12th February 2024
quotequote all
JackReacher said:
PhilboSE said:
Yup got 3 custom sized CarTeck doors in my garage.
They’re great. The fitter recommended Hormann openers though.

Can provide pics if you want.
Thanks, pics would be welcome if easy to provide. Any particular reason they recommended hormann motors?
I’ll upload pics later.

The fitter just said he thought the Hormann openers were a bit more reliable. I also wanted quite a lot of control options: keypad, remotes, internal buttons and app and not sure if that made a difference.

JackReacher

Original Poster:

2,271 posts

243 months

Tuesday 13th February 2024
quotequote all
PhilboSE said:
I’ll upload pics later.

The fitter just said he thought the Hormann openers were a bit more reliable. I also wanted quite a lot of control options: keypad, remotes, internal buttons and app and not sure if that made a difference.
Good point, I need to think about control methods I want. What benefits does an app bring? Hadn't even considered that.

Glassman

24,889 posts

243 months

Tuesday 13th February 2024
quotequote all
Se7enheaven said:
Have a Hormann sectional single garage door. Been installed for about 6 years with no issues ( touch wood ). Very good quality.
Same.

PhilboSE

6,047 posts

254 months

Tuesday 13th February 2024
quotequote all
Pic as promised.



My doors are custom sizes (extra wide and a bit taller) and Carteck could make the top segment a little bit smaller than the others so the door finishes are the opening. Other manufacturers would only deal in standard sized segments so the top one was a bit taller than the opening and therefore the panels looked wrong.

I had them mounted behind, not between, the opening so that I have the whole width of the opening to drive through. Definitely worth considering if you have the option (you need a bit of structure behind the opening on the reveal to fix the mechanism onto).


I only went for the app option because it was there and I figured that if I was ever in a car without a remote fob I could still open the doors. In reality I got two remotes with each door so there’s plenty, and I’ve never used the app.

I use the keypad outside and the push button inside a lot though, when I need to open the doors when I’m not in a car or have a remote on me.

JackReacher

Original Poster:

2,271 posts

243 months

Tuesday 13th February 2024
quotequote all
PhilboSE said:
Pic as promised.



My doors are custom sizes (extra wide and a bit taller) and Carteck could make the top segment a little bit smaller than the others so the door finishes are the opening. Other manufacturers would only deal in standard sized segments so the top one was a bit taller than the opening and therefore the panels looked wrong.

I had them mounted behind, not between, the opening so that I have the whole width of the opening to drive through. Definitely worth considering if you have the option (you need a bit of structure behind the opening on the reveal to fix the mechanism onto).


I only went for the app option because it was there and I figured that if I was ever in a car without a remote fob I could still open the doors. In reality I got two remotes with each door so there’s plenty, and I’ve never used the app.

I use the keypad outside and the push button inside a lot though, when I need to open the doors when I’m not in a car or have a remote on me.
Thanks, they look good. Sounds like the customisation available was important. I'm also planning on having them set back to maximise width (assuming the structure is suitable). I don't think I'd use the app, but would want a switch on the inside to open them up.

JackReacher

Original Poster:

2,271 posts

243 months

Monday 26th February 2024
quotequote all
Had quotes for both Carteck and Garadoor. Carteck quote is £2,050 per door, verses £2,700 for Garador for relatively like for like spec sectional door. And since I need 2 doors, the difference is £1.300, which is hard to justify.

8-P

3,225 posts

288 months

Monday 26th February 2024
quotequote all
Why not rollers? I started out wanting sectional but bought these instead

https://www.sws.co.uk/homeowners/roller-garage-doo...

PhilboSE

6,047 posts

254 months

Monday 26th February 2024
quotequote all
Roller doors are a bit more industrial looking and aren’t insulated.

gashart

123 posts

103 months

Monday 26th February 2024
quotequote all
SWS also sell sectional doors through various outlets, very high quality.

They do some roller doors which are classed as "Secure by Design" which is the safest option for security.

8-P

3,225 posts

288 months

Wednesday 28th February 2024
quotequote all
PhilboSE said:
Roller doors are a bit more industrial looking and aren’t insulated.
I thought that initially it I picked a custom colour and think they look smart and decent ones are insulated.Also, when open take up very little ceiling space compared to a sectional which you may or may not care about.

gfreeman

1,768 posts

278 months

Wednesday 28th February 2024
quotequote all
I replaced rollers with Cartech/Teckentrup insulated sectional doors. Got fed up with the dirty great roll at the ceiling, lack of insulation, industrial look and general draughtiness.
Been in since November and all good. One is about 3.2 metres wide and one is 1.250 metres wide.
The doors do open across the ceilings but I have downlights so didn’t worry about bashing the lights. Fitted internally for full width.

Yes it is a problem if you want to work on your car at night with the door open but I don’t fit into that category.

One thing I like is the internal switch is battery operated wireless with a sticky pad so you can put it anywhere without a load of wires to worry about.

The render is new so will tone down a bit to a lighter colour (I hope!).

dbdb

5,152 posts

201 months

Wednesday 28th February 2024
quotequote all
We have a Teckentrup sectional garage door. It was installed about 10 years ago and we have not had trouble with it.

The door opening is quite a bit wider than the largest Hormann door but Teckentrup make much wider sizes and were the only company making a sectional door wide enough at that time. It is very heavily engineered.