To x drive or not

To x drive or not

Author
Discussion

stevemcs

Original Poster:

8,932 posts

99 months

Saturday 2nd December 2023
quotequote all
I’m currently looking at F31’s ideally those that are 3.0. I’ll be changing to all season tyres but how much of a difference doe x drive make. It will get used for towing and I really don’t care about the suspension being softer or it not being quite as good to drive.

ucb

1,029 posts

218 months

Saturday 2nd December 2023
quotequote all
If you don't care about the disadvantages then why ask the question??

A friend has a 330d X drive. He's manically obsessed about balancing tyre wear, changing all 4 tyres at the same time, differential stress due to uneven tyre wear. You could do this or I suspect, just get one and drive it and have a life.
I imagine the xdrive will be a boon when towing regardless of the tyres



Edited by ucb on Saturday 2nd December 10:34

d_a_n1979

9,418 posts

78 months

Saturday 2nd December 2023
quotequote all
I think for towing or living out in the sticks etc; xDrive makes a lot of sense

I really liked the 330D xDrive we test drove; yes I'd have changed the springs for something firmer, but that's my preference etc

Other than that; they're an excellent car

However the RWD suits me to a tee as I don't tow or anything like that

Court_S

13,813 posts

183 months

Saturday 2nd December 2023
quotequote all
They do grip loads better, especially the diesels where you have loads of torque.

I like the grip but hate the suspension set up.

Pica-Pica

14,353 posts

90 months

Saturday 2nd December 2023
quotequote all
Court_S said:
They do grip loads better, especially the diesels where you have loads of torque.

I like the grip but hate the suspension set up.
F30 LCI 335d x drive here. Great low down torque, great grip on the wet. We dont get much ice or snow - a bit frosty this week, but summer tyres all-round are fine for me. I have run-flats and the SE (standard) suspension. I am fine with that, but it depends how good your roads are, I guess).

stevemcs

Original Poster:

8,932 posts

99 months

Saturday 2nd December 2023
quotequote all
Pica-Pica said:
F30 LCI 335d x drive here. Great low down torque, great grip on the wet. We dont get much ice or snow - a bit frosty this week, but summer tyres all-round are fine for me. I have run-flats and the SE (standard) suspension. I am fine with that, but it depends how good your roads are, I guess).
Roads around here are fine, I’d stick all seasons on anyway. There was a 330d non x drive that appeared, great spec ( merino leather, pan roof etc) but it’s gone now. Preference was always for x drive as I preferred the softer suspension and think it will be better for towing, it also allows a little extra to be towed.

Mr Tidy

23,891 posts

133 months

Saturday 2nd December 2023
quotequote all
The right tyres work fine with 2WD.

But the right tyres and X-Drive sounds like the way to go for towing.

flight147z

1,044 posts

135 months

Saturday 2nd December 2023
quotequote all
I've currently got a 435d which only comes in xdrive

If I was looking at a 430d I'd go with xdrive. For that type of car and a diesel engine it just fits better. Previous car was an e86 and obviously with that RWD makes more sense

flight147z

1,044 posts

135 months

Saturday 2nd December 2023
quotequote all
I also have no issues with the stock ("soft") suspension coming from a rock solid z4... I prefer the suspension on my 4 for everyday driving

Aluminati

2,720 posts

64 months

Saturday 2nd December 2023
quotequote all
330d X Drive here.

Stays on summer tyres and hasn’t failed me. The suspension suits British roads perfectly. Obvs the driving gods will know better. rolleyes


Court_S

13,813 posts

183 months

Sunday 3rd December 2023
quotequote all
Aluminati said:
330d X Drive here.

Stays on summer tyres and hasn’t failed me. The suspension suits British roads perfectly. Obvs the driving gods will know better. rolleyes

You know, it is possible for people to like different things? Crazy concept, I know.

sortedcossie

654 posts

134 months

Monday 4th December 2023
quotequote all
Another F31 335d here on runflats and LCI SE suspension.

We have a couple of awkward angle, uphill give ways on blind bends by us. Our E91 330d always triggers the traction control in evenly mildly damp weather, no matter how light on the throttle just due to odd nature of the junction. 335d just pulls away up it with no fuss. Noted that's a specific couple of junctions, but it is very sure footed in general.

NorthDave

2,395 posts

238 months

Monday 4th December 2023
quotequote all
I've had a 340i as a 2 wheel drive and various (330d, 335d) diesels on x drive. I missed the x drive on the 340, it was difficult to get the power down sometimes. I ran all of them on winter tyres in the alps and had no problem with any on the snow although the x drive was better. I never had a problem with the suspension on any of them and dont recall if feeling different between x drive and non x drive.

Make of that what you will.

911Spanker

1,709 posts

22 months

Monday 4th December 2023
quotequote all
I have driven quite a few xDrive cars but would always go RWD - it's the key reason for buying a BMW.

Aluminati

2,720 posts

64 months

Tuesday 5th December 2023
quotequote all
Court_S said:
You know, it is possible for people to like different things? Crazy concept, I know.
Of course. But I’m not a driving god. Just someone that has a run of the mill 3 series that delivers as it came from the factory. Which is what the op was wondering, yes ?