Starter won't crank when hot

Starter won't crank when hot

Author
Discussion

indigochim

Original Poster:

1,840 posts

142 months

Wednesday 18th October 2023
quotequote all
I was hunting for a suitable hot start thread to bump but my issue may be slightly different.

When cold the starter cranks at a decent rate and starts without issue.

After a decent run (even in cold weather) If I stop and try and restart the car The fuel pump primes but then nothing on the starter not even a slow try at starting. I don't have the original immobiliser none was fitted when I bought the car but a Cobra one has been fitted a few years ago. If I cool down the starter by poring water down the inner wing in the general area of the starter then it fires up straight away.

I've read so many comments about issues with the spec of the cables to the starter and the earth are these likely in this instance? I would expect them to slow rather than stop. The starter was off the care earlier in the year while I was having to have the faces of my manifolds resurfaced could it be that the starter to engine facing have oxidised and need cleaning up. I'm going to try and get to it at the weekend but just want to get what tests I can do before just buying a new starter.

Belle427

10,219 posts

245 months

Wednesday 18th October 2023
quotequote all
Get it nice and hot and see if it fails, you can then do a voltage test at the solenoid terminal which will rule out most things.
A good test light is beneficial here.
Chances are the starter is knackered though.

indigochim

Original Poster:

1,840 posts

142 months

Wednesday 18th October 2023
quotequote all
Thanks for the reply. To clarify test the voltage at the small spade connector on the solenoid or the beefier live cable or both?

macdeb

8,644 posts

267 months

Wednesday 18th October 2023
quotequote all
From memory, there is a relay that LR deleted that can be re-installed to prevent this. It was some years ago I fitted one to my Chimaera. Search engine not the best here but someone I'm sure can give details.

anonymous-user

66 months

Wednesday 18th October 2023
quotequote all
I’d start with cables, including the battery clamps themselves, then the earths, then the battery condition. If all those are fine, it’s the starter.

I have a 6.2 L Monaro that has very similar symptoms, turned out to be the positive battery clamp not clamping tightly enough. A hot engine puts more stress on the electrical connections so start there.

Belle427

10,219 posts

245 months

Wednesday 18th October 2023
quotequote all
indigochim said:
Thanks for the reply. To clarify test the voltage at the small spade connector on the solenoid or the beefier live cable or both?
The small solenoid cable, its highly unlikely to be the beefier cable but always worth checking both ends are nice and tight and look ok.

indigochim

Original Poster:

1,840 posts

142 months

Wednesday 18th October 2023
quotequote all
Thanks, I've already checked all the cables where tight inc the ones to the battery (which is reasonable new and in good condition). The spade on the solenoid was slack but not falling off. I nipped that up hoping it was magic fix but I clearly didn't get the engine hot enough to test after that as I let it warm up and cycle through the fans kicking in a couple of times and it started fine but after driving home it failed.

I'll check the voltage there and also the engine earth. I may as well clean up the faces where the starter mates to the gearbox casting as I guess that's how it gets it's earth.

anonymous-user

66 months

Wednesday 18th October 2023
quotequote all
A battery tester is a good investment to check its condition, especially the cranking amp output. Only a few quid on Amazon if you don’t have one.

Belle427

10,219 posts

245 months

Wednesday 18th October 2023
quotequote all
The solenoid cable spade can become loose as you found out, as long as it feels tight when pushed on it should be ok.

Polly Grigora

11,209 posts

121 months

Wednesday 18th October 2023
quotequote all
Out of interest

Why pour water over the area of starter motor? Car can be left parked up and re-checked when stone cold

Without interfering with anything on the vehicle - Starter failing when hot is more often than not proven to be caused by bad commutation or a sticking solenoid plunger

Proving bad commutation is often successfully achieved by hitting the starter motor barrel with a big hammer or length of bar if it's out of reach

or

Test with a voltmeter

indigochim

Original Poster:

1,840 posts

142 months

Thursday 19th October 2023
quotequote all
Polly Grigora said:
Out of interest

Why pour water over the area of starter motor? Car can be left parked up and re-checked when stone cold
I already knew it would restart after I'd left it I wanted to know if it was when the starter itself cooled.

Polly Grigora

11,209 posts

121 months

Thursday 19th October 2023
quotequote all
indigochim said:
Polly Grigora said:
Out of interest

Why pour water over the area of starter motor? Car can be left parked up and re-checked when stone cold
I already knew it would restart after I'd left it I wanted to know if it was when the starter itself cooled.
Ok then