Insurance and car for new driver
Insurance and car for new driver
Author
Discussion

HelenJane

Original Poster:

18 posts

41 months

Monday 9th October 2023
quotequote all
My daughter is 18, only had her licence for less than a year and managed to go into the back of someone! Her car (Corsa) has been written off due to cost of repair v cost of car.
She’s looking for a new car, along with low insurance……much harder because she’s already been in a crash!

I’m not knowledgeable about cars at all. I’m really after any advice as to make, model of car sue could look at and which cars have low insurance. If anyone can help, I’d be very grateful. Thanks in advance

duckson

1,312 posts

209 months

Monday 9th October 2023
quotequote all
Lower the insurance group the cheaper it will be (generally).

When my son was getting a first car 18 months ago the Kia Picanto and Ford KA (both 1 litre engines) we found were the cheapest on quotes (try some quotes via gocompare, comparethemarket etc).

We ended up insuring him with Direct Line using their Driveplus app policy (rather than having an actual Telematics ‘black box’ that most other similar policies will use) to reduce his premium, it worked out about the cheapest and I’d rather go with someone I’d heard of!

GreatGranny

9,519 posts

253 months

Monday 9th October 2023
quotequote all
Budget?

Anything similar to the Corsa will be similar insurance group.

MINI, Polo, Fiesta etc..

If you want to go a group down/smaller then you're looking at the C1, Aygo, Adam

ETA looking at the Atrader Corsa is IG 03E which is the same as the C1 7 Adam.

Up! and Fox are IG 01E

HelenJane

Original Poster:

18 posts

41 months

Monday 9th October 2023
quotequote all
Between £3 - £4k budget.
The insurance seem to be an issue because some won’t touch her

119

18,955 posts

63 months

Monday 9th October 2023
quotequote all
HelenJane said:
Between £3 - £4k budget.
The insurance seem to be an issue because some won’t touch her
Writing her car off within the first year of driving is going to limit her choices somewhat.

The Gauge

7,035 posts

40 months

Monday 9th October 2023
quotequote all
duckson said:


We ended up insuring him with Direct Line using their Driveplus app policy
I notice the Driveplus app records their journey using there phones Location Services. How does that work when they are a passenger in another car, do they have to remember to turn off Location Services?

If they were to then forget to turn to back on and drive their own car and had aa accident, I assume they wouldn't be covered?


Edited by The Gauge on Monday 9th October 19:29

HelenJane

Original Poster:

18 posts

41 months

Monday 9th October 2023
quotequote all
[redacted]

RicksAlfas

14,438 posts

271 months

Wednesday 11th October 2023
quotequote all
The Gauge said:
I notice the Driveplus app records their journey using there phones Location Services. How does that work when they are a passenger in another car, do they have to remember to turn off Location Services?

If they were to then forget to turn to back on and drive their own car and had aa accident, I assume they wouldn't be covered?
Does it not connect with a gadget inside their car? That's how my son's policy works. Quite good really as it means if I borrow his car, my driving isn't monitored!

The Gauge

7,035 posts

40 months

Wednesday 11th October 2023
quotequote all
RicksAlfas said:
The Gauge said:
I notice the Driveplus app records their journey using there phones Location Services. How does that work when they are a passenger in another car, do they have to remember to turn off Location Services?

If they were to then forget to turn to back on and drive their own car and had aa accident, I assume they wouldn't be covered?
Does it not connect with a gadget inside their car? That's how my son's policy works. Quite good really as it means if I borrow his car, my driving isn't monitored!
Ahh, that makes sense. I wondered how it works, thanks.

duckson

1,312 posts

209 months

Thursday 12th October 2023
quotequote all
The Gauge said:
RicksAlfas said:
The Gauge said:
I notice the Driveplus app records their journey using there phones Location Services. How does that work when they are a passenger in another car, do they have to remember to turn off Location Services?

If they were to then forget to turn to back on and drive their own car and had aa accident, I assume they wouldn't be covered?
Does it not connect with a gadget inside their car? That's how my son's policy works. Quite good really as it means if I borrow his car, my driving isn't monitored!
Ahh, that makes sense. I wondered how it works, thanks.
No it doesn’t connect with anything in the car or anything else, it’s the app only.
If you are a passenger in another car and you have your phone with you, you mark the journey as such in the app so it doesn’t count it. You have a while to do this I think, not sure how long.
My son has been using this for over 18 months without an issue, it doesn’t seem overly sensitive and so pretty reasonable with what’s allowed while driving.
Compare that with my mates son who had a ‘black box’ policy and was invited to cancel it within 2 weeks due to what it recorded!
I’ve nothing but praise for the Driveplus from Direct Line.

RicksAlfas

14,438 posts

271 months

Thursday 12th October 2023
quotequote all
duckson said:
No it doesn’t connect with anything in the car or anything else, it’s the app only.
If you are a passenger in another car and you have your phone with you, you mark the journey as such in the app so it doesn’t count it. You have a while to do this I think, not sure how long.
My son has been using this for over 18 months without an issue, it doesn’t seem overly sensitive and so pretty reasonable with what’s allowed while driving.
Compare that with my mates son who had a ‘black box’ policy and was invited to cancel it within 2 weeks due to what it recorded!
I’ve nothing but praise for the Driveplus from Direct Line.
Sounds a good scheme.
I remember a few years ago my car insurance was with Aviva and at renewal time they were promoting an app. The deal was to try it for a couple of weeks and if you scored highly there was a discount on the renewal. I was on holiday in Brittany (no traffic, immaculate roads) and I got 100%! Don't think I would have got that if I'd been home in West Yorkshire... biggrin