Radiator Shroud… pro and cons?

Radiator Shroud… pro and cons?

Author
Discussion

LLantrisant

Original Poster:

1,002 posts

171 months

Wednesday 20th September 2023
quotequote all
where to Start....the fans are mounted on the shroud....therefore the fans are mounted with a certain distance to the radiator.

1. why the fans were not mounted directly on the rad or at least closer?
2. the shrouds cover at least 30% of the backsdie of the radiator...why this?
3. does no.2 not negatively effect the airflow through the radiator and as consequence reduce the cooling effect?
4.anybody fitted the fans without shroud?


DCerebrate

361 posts

122 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
I don’t have all the answers but - my car has a shroud and has no cooling issues. My set-up is aftermarket but the main points to take care of are 1. any cooling issue, consider whether the radiator might need replaced / recored 2. Replace the expansion tank cap 3. Both fans kicking in. I have a single large Revotec fan against a shroud - it is very powerful and does the job well.

gruffalo

7,803 posts

238 months

Saturday 23rd September 2023
quotequote all
LLantrisant said:
where to Start....the fans are mounted on the shroud....therefore the fans are mounted with a certain distance to the radiator.

1. why the fans were not mounted directly on the rad or at least closer?
2. the shrouds cover at least 30% of the backsdie of the radiator...why this?
3. does no.2 not negatively effect the airflow through the radiator and as consequence reduce the cooling effect?
4.anybody fitted the fans without shroud?
Are you having over heating problems?

If so maybe a blocked rad or another issue.

The standard cooling set up is more than sufficient even on super hot climates.

I have sat in traffic in 40+ Celsius for hours with the air con on and not issues at all. Bloody awful traffic jam but it was a good proving ground, the Mustang a few cars in front of me ended up being pushed to the side in clouds of steam.


LLantrisant

Original Poster:

1,002 posts

171 months

Saturday 23rd September 2023
quotequote all
gruffalo said:
Are you having over heating problems?

If so maybe a blocked rad or another issue.

The standard cooling set up is more than sufficient even on super hot climates.

I have sat in traffic in 40+ Celsius for hours with the air con on and not issues at all. Bloody awful traffic jam but it was a good proving ground, the Mustang a few cars in front of me ended up being pushed to the side in clouds of steam.
no overheating issues..but the temperature is always on the limit. (speaking from the gauge...i know...its not that accurate....and i already have re-reouted the capillary away from the hot areas where it was mounted b4)... when its around 35degrees outside...maybe i should better check the temperature from the electric-sensor given to the ECU....also i´m not used to have cars with a completely covered radiator-backside..... from my simple way of thinking: the better flow, the more cold.

gruffalo

7,803 posts

238 months

Monday 25th September 2023
quotequote all
LLantrisant said:
gruffalo said:
Are you having over heating problems?

If so maybe a blocked rad or another issue.

The standard cooling set up is more than sufficient even on super hot climates.

I have sat in traffic in 40+ Celsius for hours with the air con on and not issues at all. Bloody awful traffic jam but it was a good proving ground, the Mustang a few cars in front of me ended up being pushed to the side in clouds of steam.
no overheating issues..but the temperature is always on the limit. (speaking from the gauge...i know...its not that accurate....and i already have re-reouted the capillary away from the hot areas where it was mounted b4)... when its around 35degrees outside...maybe i should better check the temperature from the electric-sensor given to the ECU....also i´m not used to have cars with a completely covered radiator-backside..... from my simple way of thinking: the better flow, the more cold.
Your idea of checking on the ECU is a good one. I got so fed up with not knowing the truth about both oil pressure and water temp that I fitted the SPA Digital dual gauge and know I know what is really going on in real time.

I think all of my cars have a cowling round the radiator Volvo, Merc and Pug all ace covers to maximise the draw of the fan and ensure the fan pulls air through the radiator rather than from around it.


BIG DUNC

1,918 posts

235 months

Monday 25th September 2023
quotequote all
As per the last post, the shroud makes the fan(s) far more efficient.
You could argue that efficiency is not so important if the coolant is not hot enough for the fan to kick in.
This does appear to be how most "modern" cars are, so maybe TVR were ahead of their time?

Byker28i

71,830 posts

229 months

Tuesday 26th September 2023
quotequote all
Spotted this from the guy selling bits
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/325479503981?hash=item4...
He has fans etc as well.

Mr Cerbera

5,116 posts

242 months

Friday 29th September 2023
quotequote all
Hi Nicols,

When my Radiator cracked, I bought a RadTec alloy one to replace it.
It came with the shroud welded into it and I've never had overheating probs so it could be the core of your Rad
OR
Air passage to it.
Do you have AirCon ?
If so, perhaps your Condenser is completely blocked and won't allow air passage through to the Rad ?

Also, if you haven't already done it, I would recommend replacing the Thermostat and the pipes with a Silicon set from ACT (other sources available - I just recommend them coz they work, very well). wink

thumbup

MarkwG

5,432 posts

201 months

Saturday 30th September 2023
quotequote all
I'd suggest making sure you have the latest updated Bosch temperature sensor fitted, as a starting point. Mine failed, which meant the secondary fan didn't trigger, leaving the main fan doing all the work. The gauge was always on the high side in stop/start conditions, replaced that & it became more sensible (then did the rad, the lower pipes & the silicon hoses anyway, as the metal & rubber was reaching end of life) & it's always in the safe range now.