Brazilians +government very upset..
Brazilians +government very upset..
Author
Discussion

pesty

Original Poster:

42,655 posts

286 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all

The absolute tragedy that happened in this country in which a young Brazilian was killed has been discused on here as we have all seen so I dont want to go over that again.

Brazilians are very upset and have protested. The government wants answers fair enough but.

Am I the only person who thought hold on Brazil? isnt this the place were shop keepers arm themselves with guns and torches and go hunting street children with the Police turning a blind eye? Forceing children to hide in sewers?
4-5 children are murdered in RIO alone every day

Isnt this the place where daily shotouts in the favellas between police and drug gangs routinly end in innocent bystanders getting killed?

Arnt amnesty internation always going on about police torturing people?

Am I the only person who's thinking hang on aminute old chap youve got a bit of a nerve?

Or have I got Brazil all wrong?

wolves_wanderer

12,956 posts

267 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
I can understand why they are upset but to have them coming over here with an "investigation team" headed by their grandstanding "Justice minister" sticks in the throat slightly. I wonder if the BBC will ask them how many murders they investigate with such verve in Brazil?

MILF

1,209 posts

275 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
Nope, self same Brazil, brilliant at football, but mass starvation (50,000 a year die of malnutrition).

Shanty towns constructed next to multi million dollar apartments.

Policy of termination of street children as its bad for tourism & business.

Think Im also correct in that there are Elections due anytime soon, surely the 2 issues couldnt be related. Could they ?

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

263 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
Ahr, but don’t you understand this is Britain, we are accountable to everyone else in the World for all of their ps and for our own.

It doesn’t matter how bad things are in any other country, if something bad happens here we must pay.

IIRC we have one of the worst Human Rights records in the world if you look at the number of decisions that have gone against us. How’d that happen? Answers on a post card please

mechsympathy

58,672 posts

285 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
There was a Brazilian journalilst on the beeb this morning pointing out the irony. He was saying that Brazilian plod are sent over to learn about Scotland Yard's methods and policing with restraint, unfortunately some of the bad habits in Brazil appear to have rubbed off over here.

r988

7,495 posts

259 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
They just want their moment in the sun (or out of it since they are coming from Brazil ) after all how often does Brazil get mentioned in the news hardly at all so they need to make themselves feel important. Typical political posturing.

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

274 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
r988 said:
after all how often does Brazil get mentioned in the news

Pretty much everyday I would have thought, if you're Brazilian.

r988

7,495 posts

259 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
Einion Yrth said:

r988 said:
after all how often does Brazil get mentioned in the news


Pretty much everyday I would have thought, if you're Brazilian.


Nah they don't have news in Brazil, too busy parading about on the beach...

muley

1,453 posts

311 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
r988 said:
They just want their moment in the sun (or out of it since they are coming from Brazil ) after all how often does Brazil get mentioned in the news hardly at all so they need to make themselves feel important. Typical political posturing.


To be honest, it is our press here that is creating the exposure. It is a tragic situation, but I am not sure the police are handling it properly by adopting a hard line attitude. If/when an innocent Brit is slaughtered in Rio by their police, I expect we'd all be brassed off.

I have spent some time in Brazil and can underline some of the points made - it is a lawless place - no question..

chim_knee

12,689 posts

287 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
That's understandable - makes it look longer, so I've heard.

iaint

10,040 posts

268 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
los angeles said:


muley said:
I have spent some time in Brazil and can underline some of the points made - it is a lawless place - no question..


Perhaps that's why the unfortunate man decided to live here - more fool him - eh?

Keep your eye on the ball, chaps: the guy who executed an innocent civilian. Our hits squads are trained by the Israelis these days. In Palestine soldiers think nothing of using a school kid as target practice. To say that is not to condone suicide bombers there or here, only to illustrate a point about schools of training.

Know your inside history and think politically. Junk the spin and prevarication of our police spokesmen. Many of our "trained firearm officers" are lately from Northern Ireland where they worked undercover for the Boys In Blue in that god forsaken land. As I said before, they are chosen as hit men because aggression comes easily; extreme patriotism is branded into their brains as motivation; they don't hesitate to pull the trigger, nor will they indulge in remorse afterwards.




>> Edited by los angeles on Friday 19th August 13:45



Considering the amount of your posts that are well considered and timely you don't half spout some crap from time to time to balance is all up eh?

>> Edited by iaint on Friday 19th August 13:59

IvIark

1,238 posts

267 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
los angeles said:

Perhaps that's why the unfortunate man decided to live here - more fool him - eh?



What, has he lived in LA too?

MILF

1,209 posts

275 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
los angeles.

Whilst some contributors on Pistonheads hardly let facts get in the way of a good argument, must take issue with your recent posting.

"Our hit squads trained by the Israelis". Any proof ?

"In Palestine soldiers (presumably Israeli ?) think nothing of using school kid as target practice" Any proof ?

"Trained firearm officers are lately from Northern Ireland". Any proof ?

Would advise at this time that part of my job entails defending the various Constabularies throughout the Country in relation to Civil claims as lodged against them (including Armed Response Units) & certainly your comments were news to me.

I await with interest.

iaint

10,040 posts

268 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
los angeles said:

iaint said:
Considering the amount of your posts that are well considered and timely you don't half spout some crap from time to time to balance is all up eh?

And your counter argument is ....?


This is PH, didn't realise I neede one!


los angeles said:
Keep your eye on the ball, chaps: the guy who executed an innocent civilian.

Apart from not making much sense it's the tabloid-style that's really the target of my comment.

Also, your assertion regarding the mental-makeup of the firtearms officers involved and their place of training could do with some qualification... What, you can;t show where and by whom they were trained? Your argument is pointless rhetoric.

ZR1cliff

17,999 posts

279 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
There is a demonstration at 10 Downing Street on monday which is being attended by the victims family,ime going along with a few stellas just incase it turns into a Samba.
On the serious side you cant right a wrong with another wrong and the Execution and why it was allowed needs to be brought out in the open,surely this sort of thing never happens in Britian?,Maybe Blair not being in control of his dick will cost him his job.

jimbeaux

33,791 posts

261 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
iaint said:


los angeles said:



iaint said:
Considering the amount of your posts that are well considered and timely you don't half spout some crap from time to time to balance is all up eh?



And your counter argument is ....?




This is PH, didn't realise I neede one!




los angeles said:
Keep your eye on the ball, chaps: the guy who executed an innocent civilian.



Apart from not making much sense it's the tabloid-style that's really the target of my comment.

Also, your assertion regarding the mental-makeup of the firtearms officers involved and their place of training could do with some qualification... What, you can;t show where and by whom they were trained? Your argument is pointless rhetoric.



Ignore this guy folks, he has proved he exists in a pararrel dimension. I have trained along side 5 sniper teams from the 256 Infantry Brigade that are in the Gulf as we speak. I assist with instructing international police forces who train in Louisiana sponsered by the US State Department(US Antiterrorism Assistance Program). I am aware, first hand of the various training methods. Trust me, LA is talking out of his ass. That ludicrous statement just exposed his bias and ignorance in one fell swoop. DISCLAIMER: I am speaking of US soldiers & Police forces(as I believe you live in the US). If you were referring to UK Police, I retract my statements and apologize as I do not know their methods. If you were referring to the US guys, my statement stands.

>> Edited by jimbeaux on Friday 19th August 14:36

rich1231

17,340 posts

290 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
los angeles said:

muley said:
I have spent some time in Brazil and can underline some of the points made - it is a lawless place - no question..

Perhaps that's why the unfortunate man decided to live here - more fool him - eh?

Keep your eye on the ball, chaps: the guy who executed an innocent civilian. Our hits squads are trained by the Israelis these days. In Palestine soldiers think nothing of using a school kid as target practice. To say that is not to condone suicide bombers there or here, only to illustrate a point about schools of training.

Know your inside history and think politically. Junk the spin and prevarication of our police spokesmen. Many of our "trained firearm officers" are lately from Northern Ireland where they worked undercover for the Boys In Blue in that god forsaken land. As I said before, they are chosen as hit men because aggression comes easily; extreme patriotism is branded into their brains as motivation; they don't hesitate to pull the trigger, nor will they indulge in remorse afterwards.




>> Edited by los angeles on Friday 19th August 13:45


Are you saying that our Police are trained by Israeli's now? Do you mean that as some sort of slur upon the Israeli's?
And I'm sure the Hit squad term is abit innapropriate.

In fact, notice the word fact, it means true as opposed to meandering bile..
Our Police forces have taken advice on tactics to use against Suicide bombers. I dont have a problem with that consdiering they have the most experience. Or would you rather they go ask Ken Dodd for advice?

jimbeaux

33,791 posts

261 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
los angeles said:



jimbeaux said:
Trust me, LA is talking out of his ass. That ludicrous statement just exposed his bias and ignorance in one fell swoop.



Hi Jim. Nice to see you are on form. Actually, I'm quoting from the American Embassy.

The point I'm make is against a shoot to kill policy. The idea that our boys are "in control" at all times merely because they are our boys is hogwash - a good mid-west term.




Hello back Pray tell; you quote the US Embassy on "what" exactly? Are you going to tell me that the US Chief of Mission to the Court of St. James is going to accuse the UK police of being "Indiscriminate Hit Squads"? If so, I have a British car for you that won't break down.



>> Edited by jimbeaux on Friday 19th August 14:43

rich1231

17,340 posts

290 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
los angeles said:

rich1231 said:
And I'm sure the Hit squad term is a bit innapropriate.

Especially if the surveillance unit key man is having a pee.


I know you are a writer are you an expert on missing the point as well?

MILF

1,209 posts

275 months

Friday 19th August 2005
quotequote all
Jimbeaux.

I was just about to vent my spleen on the various crude, naive, ignorant & shameful comments as raised by los angeles, but as you yourself have had experience with firearms et al, it seems more befitting coming from you, as opposed to an office jockey like me.

Have to say though that to refer to the brave Police Officers who volunteer (yes volunteer) to serve in the Armed Response Units of Police Forces (& by inference risk their lives in order to defend Society), as "hit squads" really does demonstrate what an arse of the highest order LA must be (would have been more vociferous, but couldnt see it getting past Ted).