ASDA Tyre Safety Advice Website Any Thoughts?

ASDA Tyre Safety Advice Website Any Thoughts?

Author
Discussion

tobytronicstereophonic

Original Poster:

56 posts

76 months

Monday 16th January 2023
quotequote all
https://www.asdatyres.co.uk/blog/right-car-tyre-si...

The Asda Tyre Expert blog's advice on tyre safety has a tale with this premise: You buy a set of brand new quality (presumably Continental) tyres. You damage one of those tyres and the Devil entices you to buy a cheaper tyre that differs 'slightly' in spec from the remaining three. The whole page - there is more - is a lame attempt to write a technical article.

This, and a whole lot more, may "Seriously" Happen to You:

"Ultimately, if you use mismatched tyres, you’ll seriously put your vehicle at risk of damaged wheel bearings. There’s even an increased chance of destroying the clutch. This will not only risk your driver safety – and that of your fellow motorists – it will also hurt your bank balance. Nobody wants to have to pay for parts and repairs, right?"

Whilst fact checking, I came across the following page for A-Level and University students:

https://revisionscience.com/a2-level-level-revisio...

A tyre that's underinflated heats the air to such a degree that it explodes?

Really, is this what we are teaching our kids :-)


BananaFama

4,788 posts

93 months

Monday 16th January 2023
quotequote all
I haven't read the link but damaging clutch and wheel bearings ,complete drivel .

Dingu

4,885 posts

44 months

Monday 16th January 2023
quotequote all
Anyone taking motoring advice from ASDA probably gets what they deserve.

MissChief

7,490 posts

182 months

Monday 16th January 2023
quotequote all
BananaFama said:
I haven't read the link but damaging clutch and wheel bearings ,complete drivel .
Volvo v70 AWD models actually suffered damaged differentials if you put different tread depth tyres on, as you might with a punctured tyre that's not repairable and the others have 4-5mm left so you buy a single new tyre with 8-9mm. They fixed it eventually but they never tested them with uneven tyres.

Edited by MissChief on Monday 16th January 23:46

swisstoni

19,737 posts

293 months

Tuesday 17th January 2023
quotequote all
I don’t have a problem with people being told that mismatched tyres can cause issues.

Looks like in this case they have targeted penny-pinchers by going down the ‘could hit you in the pocket’ route.

Krikkit

27,387 posts

195 months

Tuesday 17th January 2023
quotequote all
MissChief said:
BananaFama said:
I haven't read the link but damaging clutch and wheel bearings ,complete drivel .
Volvo v70 AWD models actually suffered damaged differentials if you put different tread depth tyres on, as you might with a punctured tyre that's not repairable and the others have 4-5mm left so you buy a single new tyre with 8-9mm. They fixed it eventually but they never tested them with uneven tyres.
Not just them, common with quite a few cars with similar types of 4WD, e.g. BMW X3, Freelander etc

wyson

3,402 posts

118 months

Tuesday 17th January 2023
quotequote all
Under inflated tyres are a cause of blowouts on the motorway. The flexing creates heat and also puts magnitudes more stress in all the internal belts. The air in a tyre is a structural element. Take that away and the tyre can fail.

The first article is also talking about mismatched tyre sizes eg. fitting a single 205/60 r15 tyre on a car with 195/65 r15 on the other three wheels, not fitting a slightly different tyre of the same size.

stevieturbo

17,745 posts

261 months

Tuesday 17th January 2023
quotequote all
tobytronicstereophonic said:
https://www.asdatyres.co.uk/blog/right-car-tyre-si...

The Asda Tyre Expert blog's advice on tyre safety has a tale with this premise: You buy a set of brand new quality (presumably Continental) tyres. You damage one of those tyres and the Devil entices you to buy a cheaper tyre that differs 'slightly' in spec from the remaining three. The whole page - there is more - is a lame attempt to write a technical article.

This, and a whole lot more, may "Seriously" Happen to You:

"Ultimately, if you use mismatched tyres, you’ll seriously put your vehicle at risk of damaged wheel bearings. There’s even an increased chance of destroying the clutch. This will not only risk your driver safety – and that of your fellow motorists – it will also hurt your bank balance. Nobody wants to have to pay for parts and repairs, right?"

Whilst fact checking, I came across the following page for A-Level and University students:

https://revisionscience.com/a2-level-level-revisio...

A tyre that's underinflated heats the air to such a degree that it explodes?

Really, is this what we are teaching our kids :-)
It is among the many lines of bullst tyre sellers tell potential customers, to sell them anything on their shelves. It's not new, and it's not right.
But it is rampant.