Best Supergroup

[oddman]

Planet Rock listeners were asked to vote for the individual musicians they would like to make up the ideal supergroup.

Result

Robert Plant
Jimmy Page
John Paul Jones
John Bonham

Nice to have one's prejudices confirmed

[MKGriff]

Cheryl Tweedy
Lemar
Will Young
GGGGareth GGGates
Darius

Hat, coat, emmigrated

[gtr-gaz]

oddman said:

Planet Rock listeners were asked to vote for the individual musicians they would like to make up the ideal supergroup. Result Robert Plant Jimmy Page John Paul Jones John Bonham Nice to have one's prejudices confirmed

That would be my choice too, although it might be a toss up on vocals, between Plant and Ian Anderson of "Yes"
Oh...and Rick Wakeman on keyboards of course!!

[catso]

oddman said:

Planet Rock listeners were asked to vote for the individual musicians they would like to make up the ideal supergroup. Result Robert Plant Jimmy Page John Paul Jones John Bonham Nice to have one's prejudices confirmed

[chris watton]

The Goombay Dance Band, pure class!

[Vitesse39]

oddman said:

Planet Rock listeners were asked to vote for the individual musicians they would like to make up the ideal supergroup. Result Robert Plant Jimmy Page John Paul Jones John Bonham

I would deffinitely agree with that choice but I would also have to add a second band constructed from
Mike Portnoy
John Petruci
John Myung
James Labrie
Jordan Rudess

[Kinky]

www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?f=141&h=0&t=192470

[Lord Elmo]

Abba.

[andy mac]

The big goof himself, freddy, would absolutely kick anyones arse, (not to mentions a few other things), in a singing contest!! best supergroup?

I vote for Freddy
Brian may
John Deacon
And Roger 'car freak' Taylor!!

[Lois]

Ben Moody
Fred Durst
Kurk Cobain
Alice Cooper

now that would be one heck of a supergroup!

[driftwood]

Can't argue with Led Zepplin....but if this was Aussie land the 'Little River Band'(original) would be up amonst the top, but there again I'm biased.

[neil.b]

anonymous said:

[redacted]

Don't know who the first one it but the other 3 are singers/vocalists.

It would be like a very angry barbershop quartet.

[2 Smokin Barrels]

gtr-gaz said:

Oh...and Rick Wakeman on keyboards of course!!

..watching telly one night, and Rick Wakeman makes an appearance. G/F says: "Rick Wakeman, wasn't he in Emerson Lake & Palmer?"

...I nearly choked on me jalfrezi!

[DanBoy]

Thomas Lang (drums)
Tom Morello (guitar)
Flea (bass)
Brandon Boyd (vocals)


I have no idea how that would sound but it seems like a good idea right now!

[grahamdance]

David Gilmore
Roger Walters
Syd Barrett
Richard Wright
Nick Mason






Oh, no, wait, thats already the best supergroup

[Jon C]

gtr-gaz said:

That would be my choice too, although it might be a toss up on vocals, between Plant and Ian Anderson of "Yes" Oh...and Rick Wakeman on keyboards of course!!

Jon Anderson was the Vocalist in Yes, Ian Anderson was in Jethro Tull.

I am always surprised that Peter Gabriel never crops up in these sort of surveys. He has the most astounding vocal range. Brian Wilson is also often overlooked, I consider Brian Wilson to be one of the five true genius' of music.

[focusonme]

Vitesse39 said:

I would deffinitely agree with that choice but I would also have to add a second band constructed from Mike Portnoy John Petruci John Myung James Labrie Jordan Rudess

Wow. We must be the only PHers to whom those names have real meaning.

(To be honest, they've gone a bit downhill since Metropolis Pt 2, anyway).

[The Wiz]

Zep - great band ... though I prefer Purple myself ...

My Supergroup:

Lead Vocals - David Coverdale
Guitar - Tommy Bolin
Guitar - Jimmy Page
Bass - Billy Sheenan
Keyboards - Rick Wakeman
Drums - Ian Paice

Would never work ... but it would be fun watching them try ...

[Kentish]

Does anyone know what this thread is about?

[Vitesse39]

focusonme said:

Vitesse39 said: I would deffinitely agree with that choice but I would also have to add a second band constructed from Mike Portnoy John Petruci John Myung James Labrie Jordan Rudess Wow. We must be the only PHers to whom those names have real meaning. (To be honest, they've gone a bit downhill since Metropolis Pt 2, anyway).

Hmmm... I wasn't to sure about 'Awake' when it came out but I'm convinced now. first half of '6 degrees of inner turbulance' is a stormer

Will you be going to see them in Oct is it?

There are a couple of others of us as well, some other drummers as you might expect

>> Edited by Vitesse39 on Thursday 11th August 08:52