Life under the waves - C5
Author
Discussion

fourstardan

Original Poster:

6,477 posts

172 months

Monday 20th September 2021
quotequote all
No idea why the Aussies and Yanks want to share our submarine capabilities the one on C5 they are covering is falling to bits by all accounts.

It's a great documentary, there is something about submarines.

Are some of these emergencies really just drills?

jtremlett

1,624 posts

250 months

Monday 20th September 2021
quotequote all
It is very old and about to be decommissioned imminently, so hopefully it doesn't indicate all the rest of the Royal Navy is in a similar state.

anonymous-user

82 months

Monday 20th September 2021
quotequote all
I've not seen this, which specific boat is being featured and is "falling apart"?

FourWheelDrift

92,183 posts

312 months

Monday 20th September 2021
quotequote all
MikeStroud said:
I've not seen this, which specific boat is being featured and is "falling apart"?
32 year old HMS Trenchant. Currently laid up awaiting decommissioning.


HarryW

15,994 posts

297 months

Monday 20th September 2021
quotequote all
Enjoyed that, yes Trenchant was old and overdue the scrap heap, but still very capable on a world ranking. Understand the Astutes are on another level. Anything the Aussies get will have the Astutes as a minimum baseline. The U.K. will already be starting the initial work on the Astute replacements even today.

I dare say the programme filming would have been heavily edited and redacted. Probably not shown 1/10 of it. the narrative it followed and what was shown is more akin to a movie script no doubt too, entertaining nonetheless with the T23 coming over the horizon, whereas she was probably tracking it all along 😂.

anonymous-user

82 months

Monday 20th September 2021
quotequote all
fourstardan said:
No idea why the Aussies and Yanks want to share our submarine capabilities the one on C5 they are covering is falling to bits by all accounts.

...
The Astute class is world beating.

Don't make your judgement on Trenchant alone.

Glade

4,502 posts

251 months

Monday 20th September 2021
quotequote all
Just watched this and thought the same... preparing to go silent, the XO was walking around rattling hand rails, wall panels, equipment hanging on hooks. Lol. "Going to have to stick a wooden wedge in that"

I was thinking bloody hell, I thought they'd be better designed than that... but hearing it's 32 years old and now out of service makes a bit more sense!

belleair302

7,007 posts

235 months

Monday 20th September 2021
quotequote all
There was an article somewhere over the weekend that the Royal Navy has commissioned a design project for new attack submarines for delivery in 2040! Some lead time there.

fourstardan

Original Poster:

6,477 posts

172 months

Tuesday 21st September 2021
quotequote all
Glade said:
Just watched this and thought the same... preparing to go silent, the XO was walking around rattling hand rails, wall panels, equipment hanging on hooks. Lol. "Going to have to stick a wooden wedge in that"

I was thinking bloody hell, I thought they'd be better designed than that... but hearing it's 32 years old and now out of service makes a bit more sense!
It felt like something out of a ww2 U boat film...drills going down the toilet not detectable as well lol.

They are amazing pieces of engineering, I must get down to the submarine museum in Portsmouth.

FourWheelDrift

92,183 posts

312 months

Tuesday 21st September 2021
quotequote all
Having working toilets onboard is a very important part of the self defence of the sub. If they find they are being followed they flush all the toilets and escape, like an squid squirting ink. Especially if the Russians follow them on a Sunday after Steak Saturday.

fourstardan

Original Poster:

6,477 posts

172 months

Tuesday 21st September 2021
quotequote all
FourWheelDrift said:
Having working toilets onboard is a very important part of the self defence of the sub. If they find they are being followed they flush all the toilets and escape, like an squid squirting ink. Especially if the Russians follow them on a Sunday after Steak Saturday.
I felt sorry for the poor sod unblocking it then being charged to steer the bloody thing and then the captain wondering why he'd fked up lol

pquinn

7,167 posts

74 months

Tuesday 21st September 2021
quotequote all
Was quite funny how they completely skipped over why there was an sudden change of captain. Like he never existed.


normalbloke

8,790 posts

247 months

Tuesday 21st September 2021
quotequote all
pquinn said:
Was quite funny how they completely skipped over why there was an sudden change of captain. Like he never existed.
He was sacked for holding a bbq during lockdown for his crew.

Glade

4,502 posts

251 months

Tuesday 21st September 2021
quotequote all
I was expecting the bad air sensor to be caused by a release from the plumbing.

Got the feeling that that was not the first time that stter got blocked.... get the acid out, this one's a big one!!

DJFish

6,014 posts

291 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2021
quotequote all
Anyone else notice the two shoreside contractors on board to fix the loo whilst the sub was supposedly at depth in the North Atlantic?

DJFish

6,014 posts

291 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2021
quotequote all
normalbloke said:
pquinn said:
Was quite funny how they completely skipped over why there was an sudden change of captain. Like he never existed.
He was sacked for holding a bbq during lockdown for his crew.
Can’t imagine that’s easy on a sub, it’d be a bugger to light….

Ben Jk

1,714 posts

194 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2021
quotequote all
normalbloke said:
pquinn said:
Was quite funny how they completely skipped over why there was an sudden change of captain. Like he never existed.
He was sacked for holding a bbq during lockdown for his crew.
The first captain on the programme wasn't the one who was sacked.

fourstardan

Original Poster:

6,477 posts

172 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2021
quotequote all
DJFish said:
Anyone else notice the two shoreside contractors on board to fix the loo whilst the sub was supposedly at depth in the North Atlantic?
They got shipped in like the bird on Vigil.....

When finished they just flushed them down the new unblocked bogs.

take-good-care-of-the-forest-dewey

7,808 posts

83 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2021
quotequote all
HarryW said:
Enjoyed that, yes Trenchant was old and overdue the scrap heap, but still very capable on a world ranking. Understand the Astutes are on another level. Anything the Aussies get will have the Astutes as a minimum baseline. The U.K. will already be starting the initial work on the Astute replacements even today.

I dare say the programme filming would have been heavily edited and redacted. Probably not shown 1/10 of it. the narrative it followed and what was shown is more akin to a movie script no doubt too, entertaining nonetheless with the T23 coming over the horizon, whereas she was probably tracking it all along ??.
Astute started life as Batch 2 Trafalgar... Gives you an idea of how long these things can take to design.

Materiel design is a race of who can make the least obsolete bit of kit.

I'd love to have chat with folks in the US who've just designed, built, and flown the F22 replacement demonstrator in a year. That is seriously impressive, even if it's just airframe and FCS.

Ash_

5,965 posts

218 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2021
quotequote all
take-good-care-of-the-forest-dewey said:
Astute started life as Batch 2 Trafalgar... Gives you an idea of how long these things can take to design.

Materiel design is a race of who can make the least obsolete bit of kit.

I'd love to have chat with folks in the US who've just designed, built, and flown the F22 replacement demonstrator in a year. That is seriously impressive, even if it's just airframe and FCS.
Got a link please, my Google-Fu isn't working.