Interest enuff for an Aero-Pistonhead forum?
Interest enuff for an Aero-Pistonhead forum?
Author
Discussion

father ted

Original Poster:

3,069 posts

276 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
There seems to be quite a few threads involving aviation on this forum.......do you think there's enough interest to warrant it's own PH forum?

i'd be 'for' it.....although there are many other websites that cater for this particular variety of Piston-Hedonism..... would it be nice to have a like-minded discussion meeting point on our favourite website?

but,as usual, i could be talking complete cobblers ,of course!

wahddya reckon Ted & fellow aviation appreciators?

Apache

39,731 posts

313 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
I'm in, no doubt eric'll be along in a minute

Extra 300 Driver

5,282 posts

275 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
Sounds great, but I fear that I will get even less work done.

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

273 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
Can we include spaceflight?

waynester

6,525 posts

279 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
Yup......me too

alexkp

16,484 posts

273 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
I think this is a good idea!

I would make it an Aerospace forum thoough.

father ted

Original Poster:

3,069 posts

276 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
Apache said:
I'm in, no doubt eric'll be along in a minute


Eric is definitely off-line at moment

would have put my money on him being the first to reply

Apache

39,731 posts

313 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
father ted said:

Apache said:
I'm in, no doubt eric'll be along in a minute



Eric is definitely off-line at moment

would have put my money on him being the first to reply



ah, abducted by aliens again

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

273 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
Apache said:

father ted said:


Apache said:
I'm in, no doubt eric'll be along in a minute




Eric is definitely off-line at moment

would have put my money on him being the first to reply




ah, abducted by aliens again

He'll be exploring the secret soundstage they used to fake the Apollo landings

Trooper2

6,676 posts

260 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
Yeah, we should bring that one in for a landing.




Dare we name it after Eric? What do you think, PetrolTed?

Eric Mc

125,609 posts

294 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
Have to do some work sometimes.

I have no straight answer. I sometimes think hiving a topic off to a "specialist" forum means that it gets less hits and consequently less debate.

yertis

19,711 posts

295 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
Trooper2 said:
Dare we name it after Eric? What do you think, PetrolTed?


You mean like "Ask Jeeves"?

"For all your questions regarding aviation, space travel or tax legislation, Ask Eric..."

Trooper2

6,676 posts

260 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
yertis said:

Trooper2 said:
Dare we name it after Eric? What do you think, PetrolTed?



You mean like "Ask Jeeves"?

"For all your questions regarding aviation, space travel or tax legislation, Ask Eric..."



You know he would reside there.

gopher

5,160 posts

288 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
I certainly think there are enough aerospace topics in the P & P to warrent a forum of its own, but as Eric says having a forum may dilute the discussion.

I know I would be spending a fair bit of time in there

Cheers

Paul

tinman0

18,231 posts

269 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
In a word, no.

Its a car forum and should stay focused to its subject. If it goes into non motoring related things it opens up a can of worms and the problem becomes - where do you stop?

By creating more and more sections of the forum you also run into the tumbleweed effect that I've seen on many forums. You open a specific section and nothing is happening and you'll see the virtual tumbleweed blowing past.

If a forum then has too many tumbleweed sections it brings the rest of the forum down because people perceive that there isn't much activity going on.

You can see the tumbleweed effect in areas already on PH like the MG section. PH isn't generally the haunt of MG owners so it doesn't get used. Because it doesn't get used - no one wants to really post to it in the first place.

I really need to get out more....

wedg1e

27,035 posts

294 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2005
quotequote all
Trouble is, if you had such a forum, you'd spend years trying to convince people that it existed. You'd have to take photos with special cameras, in the right lighting... thousands of people would have to tell lies etc etc...

simpo two

92,708 posts

294 months

Thursday 23rd June 2005
quotequote all
tinman0 said:
Its a car forum and should stay focused to its subject. If it goes into non motoring related things it opens up a can of worms and the problem becomes - where do you stop?

If all forums are used, why stop? Grow organically to suit demand.
There are already several non-car forums that are well-used, eg Business, Computing and Photography. I frequent the latter most as there are only so many questions you can ask about a TVR Griffith before it gets boring.

I'd also like to suggest a Homes/DIY forum.

Leadfoot

1,918 posts

310 months

Thursday 23rd June 2005
quotequote all
No.

I go to pprune for that, but happily contribute to aviation related stuff on here if I can help.