where next from my M135 - audi S4 or Bmw 440i

[sunshinewelly]

I currently have a 3 door M135 and am getting to the age where i want something a bit more comfier with 4 doors. I want something that is quick and comfortable.

i have not ruled out a new car on a pcp deal but usually buy a nearly new car ie 2 years old.

so far i like the look of the BWM 440i grand coupe and the S4.

has anyone compared the same.

i did read a review which compared the 440 with the S5 and the s5 seemed to be the better pick.

[marcosgt]

I hate the A5, so I'd pick the BMW

Oh wait, that was just a review.

Still think I'd favour the BMW, just because it's RWD.

In my limited experience, Audis tend to be a bit anodyne, even the faster ones (OK, not driven an RS anything, but the Ss are quick, but a bit sterile).

I guess the question is whether you like your current car? If not, then maybe the Audi would be a better option for you.

M

Edited by marcosgt on Tuesday 17th July 13:16

[Harryturbs]

Go and drive both and see what you think! The interior on the Audi is loads better than the BMW

[va1o]

I replaced my 3dr M135i with an Audi TT, so even less practical

I haven't really missed not having 6-cylinders as much as I thought I would. Quite enjoying having a lighter car and much better economy

In your position I'd probably be looking at the S5 Sportback along with the BMW 440i GC. Mercedes AMG C43 could be worth a try too. I think the S4 is bland so wouldn't bother with them myself.