Question for junior doctors
Author
Discussion

snobetter

Original Poster:

1,362 posts

175 months

Thursday 6th October 2016
quotequote all
I was told, and I find it hard to believe so probably not true, that a reason for the contract change being pushed through was that if one doc did x amount hours overtime they, and all others on their rota, got the whole month at double pay?
I appreciate this sounds far fetched, but the person who told me is in a job that should know this kind of thing.

TooLateForAName

4,924 posts

213 months

Thursday 6th October 2016
quotequote all
not true.

In fact when my OH was a junior she was actually paid less for the (stupidly excessive) overtime than she was for normal time.

Bertrum

485 posts

252 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
OP that makes no sense, they should be over the moon with that!

The new contract means they no longer get paid overtime on a Saturday and up to 10pm? I think on a weekday.

They get an increase in base pay to compensate.

Argument is it's unsafe, reality is they will be paid slightly less (all things considered) which is really what they are upset about and technically could be asked to work slightly longer hours (unlikely).

The real issue is getting consultants to work weekends, as if you get sick on a Week day you will be seen by an 'expert'. Get sick in the night and on a weekend you will not.

Changing the latter is the real challenge and unlikely.

snobetter

Original Poster:

1,362 posts

175 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
Bertrum said:
OP that makes no sense, they should be over the moon with that!

The new contract means they no longer get paid overtime on a Saturday and up to 10pm? I think on a weekday.

They get an increase in base pay to compensate.

Argument is it's unsafe, reality is they will be paid slightly less (all things considered) which is really what they are upset about and technically could be asked to work slightly longer hours (unlikely).

The real issue is getting consultants to work weekends, as if you get sick on a Week day you will be seen by an 'expert'. Get sick in the night and on a weekend you will not.

Changing the latter is the real challenge and unlikely.
The argument was that what I stated above is what they get now.

As for consultants, I'd bet a lot of money on their contracts being changed in the same way soon, and being fiercely opposed again.



N Dentressangle

3,453 posts

251 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
Bertrum said:
if you get sick on a Week day you will be seen by an 'expert'. Get sick in the night and on a weekend you will not.
Not really.

Whenever they come in, pretty much all acute admissions will be clerked first by a 'junior', then seen by a consultant on their ward round. Consultants do ward rounds at the weekend and are on call overnight, so patients admitted at the weekend would normally be seen by a consultant within 16-24 hours of admission at the latest, exactly the same as if they were admitted on a weekday.

There is also always (24/7) a resident speciality registrar, who can be called upon for another opinion.

If a patient is not stable, or the junior is worried there is always an appropriate consultant available to see them, 24/7, every day of the year.

I know many people do not seem to believe the above, but it's what happens.


snobetter

Original Poster:

1,362 posts

175 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
N Dentressangle said:
Bertrum said:
if you get sick on a Week day you will be seen by an 'expert'. Get sick in the night and on a weekend you will not.
Not really.

Whenever they come in, pretty much all acute admissions will be clerked first by a 'junior', then seen by a consultant on their ward round. Consultants do ward rounds at the weekend and are on call overnight, so patients admitted at the weekend would normally be seen by a consultant within 16-24 hours of admission at the latest, exactly the same as if they were admitted on a weekday.

There is also always (24/7) a resident speciality registrar, who can be called upon for another opinion.

If a patient is not stable, or the junior is worried there is always an appropriate consultant available to see them, 24/7, every day of the year.

I know many people do not seem to believe the above, but it's what happens.
Agree with all that.

The stats given for "more chance of dying at the weekend" have been shown to be at best deeply flawed.

Bertrum

485 posts

252 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
snobetter said:
N Dentressangle said:
Bertrum said:
if you get sick on a Week day you will be seen by an 'expert'. Get sick in the night and on a weekend you will not.
Not really.

Whenever they come in, pretty much all acute admissions will be clerked first by a 'junior', then seen by a consultant on their ward round. Consultants do ward rounds at the weekend and are on call overnight, so patients admitted at the weekend would normally be seen by a consultant within 16-24 hours of admission at the latest, exactly the same as if they were admitted on a weekday.

There is also always (24/7) a resident speciality registrar, who can be called upon for another opinion.

If a patient is not stable, or the junior is worried there is always an appropriate consultant available to see them, 24/7, every day of the year.

I know many people do not seem to believe the above, but it's what happens.
Agree with all that.

The stats given for "more chance of dying at the weekend" have been shown to be at best deeply flawed.
Did I say you were 'more likely to die'? No. Did I say that it was a substandard service? No.

I could have phrased it better, but don't miss quote me.

I believe you are actually most likely to die on a Wednesday as that is when the majority of operations take place. But again, i'd check that.





Edited by Bertrum on Friday 7th October 15:21

snobetter

Original Poster:

1,362 posts

175 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
Bertrum said:
snobetter said:
N Dentressangle said:
Bertrum said:
if you get sick on a Week day you will be seen by an 'expert'. Get sick in the night and on a weekend you will not.
Not really.

Whenever they come in, pretty much all acute admissions will be clerked first by a 'junior', then seen by a consultant on their ward round. Consultants do ward rounds at the weekend and are on call overnight, so patients admitted at the weekend would normally be seen by a consultant within 16-24 hours of admission at the latest, exactly the same as if they were admitted on a weekday.

There is also always (24/7) a resident speciality registrar, who can be called upon for another opinion.

If a patient is not stable, or the junior is worried there is always an appropriate consultant available to see them, 24/7, every day of the year.

I know many people do not seem to believe the above, but it's what happens.
Agree with all that.

The stats given for "more chance of dying at the weekend" have been shown to be at best deeply flawed.
Did I say you were 'more likely to die'? No. Did I say that it was a substandard service? No.

I could have phrased it better, but don't miss quote me.

I believe you are actually most likely to die on a Wednesday as that is when the majority of operations take place. But again, i'd check that.





Edited by Bertrum on Friday 7th October 15:21
Sorry, I was agreeing with everything you said, and adding more to back your point up...?

paulmakin

739 posts

170 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
it's wednesday when 1 week outcomes are used for reporting; all specialities, not just surgical.

paul

Edited by paulmakin on Friday 7th October 21:19