Stoned - AAARGH

Author
Discussion

Nacnud

Original Poster:

2,190 posts

275 months

Thursday 27th June 2002
quotequote all
I don't believe it !!!!!!!!

They have just put a fresh layer of tar and stones down on the road outside my house. I've now got a cracked headlamp, chips right accross the windscreen and a small crack in the winscreen right in my line-of-sight ! AAAAAARGHHHHH

Obviously somebody has been ignoring the 20mph limit!

Only good things are that the bonnet seems to be relatively OK, it was my daily drive and not my pride and joy, and best of all it was on the forecourt of the garage just up the road where it was in for an MoT.

I'm just about to go and talk to the garage. Any advice ?

CarZee

13,382 posts

273 months

Thursday 27th June 2002
quotequote all
Photograph everything, take no shit from anyone. Blame the council or highways agency as applicable.

Nacnud

Original Poster:

2,190 posts

275 months

Thursday 27th June 2002
quotequote all
I forgot about the camera - off to do it right now...
Cheers

anonymous-user

60 months

Thursday 27th June 2002
quotequote all
yeah what Carzee said! theres only one way to et things done and thats to shout, shout, and shout again!. Go to the local rag and see if they want the story, they normally like having a pop at the council!

CarZee

13,382 posts

273 months

Thursday 27th June 2002
quotequote all
I didn't actually mention shouting - it'as very satisfying but my experience bears it out as a poor way of getting anywhere - don't piss them off until you've got what you want or are left with no alternative.

actech

693 posts

273 months

Thursday 27th June 2002
quotequote all
What the others said and avoid using your insurance company, try settling privately or else you'll get shafted with a large premium next year.

Nacnud

Original Poster:

2,190 posts

275 months

Thursday 27th June 2002
quotequote all
There's a new complication.....

Just been to the garage and a LOT of their cars have been stoned. At least four cracked windscreens and a few bad bonnets / wings. This isn't even counting the large number of pitted windscreens.

Plus - It's not just on cars that were along the front, it's their second rank of cars as well ! Garage is worried their insurance will think they are taking the piss.

The cause of this mayhem is four axle mud-hauling lorries which are working near here. Some are doing WAY over 20mph; there is lethal cloud of stone flying up in their wake. One went past while I was up at the garage and it wasn't at all funny.

I'm going to try the council next, but is the council just going to pass the buck onto the contractors ? What a mess......

mondeoman

11,430 posts

272 months

Thursday 27th June 2002
quotequote all
get a video cam quick and film the buggers and get plod down to do a quick speed measurement, then send copies of all the evidence to the contractor with a demand for payment and the threat of legal action if no response.......

I reckon you've got a case of driving without due care and attention easy here.......

yertis

18,559 posts

272 months

Thursday 27th June 2002
quotequote all
I don't think the insurance will think they're taking the piss. I once worked near a boat yard (a proper big old victorian dry dock style one) and on one occasion they were spraying a lightship with red oxide primer. Overspray blew over about 60 cars in the car park - they (their insurance) had pay for every one to be cleaned or resprayed as appropriate.

Nacnud

Original Poster:

2,190 posts

275 months

Thursday 27th June 2002
quotequote all
RESULT ! Mondeoman - I owe you

Been out with the digital camera in video mode taking movies at the garage. Some lorries fair tanking it relative to most cars, but it's all a bit subjective. Then I thought of following a lorry in the car and videoing it going past the garage !

The first fg lorry was going so fast I only just managed to catch it up on the straight. 60mph past the busy crossroads with the pub on it, 55mph past the garage and 55mph past the houses on the downhill stretch including badly pebbledashing a kid on a pushbike

Considering it's supposed to be 20mph at the moment I reckon they ain't got a leg to stand on.

The Garage is currently holding off further action pending advice from the local Plod. The truck belongs to 'Penny'; I'm tempted to give them a call first thing tomorrow and give them some grief. Is this a good idea ?

stedale

1,124 posts

271 months

Thursday 27th June 2002
quotequote all
Just a thought, couldn't this vid be a little self incriminating - perverse as life is! You could try videoing the trucks passing between two fixed points of measurable distance e.g. lampposts whilst timing them. Is there a timer on the camera?

Steve.

JMorgan

36,010 posts

290 months

Thursday 27th June 2002
quotequote all
quote:

Just a thought, couldn't this vid be a little self incriminating - perverse as life is! You could try videoing the trucks passing between two fixed points of measurable distance e.g. lampposts whilst timing them. Is there a timer on the camera?

Steve.


Say an unknown source poped it through the letter box, unless parts of the car in shot?

mondeoman

11,430 posts

272 months

Friday 28th June 2002
quotequote all
quote:

Just a thought, couldn't this vid be a little self incriminating - perverse as life is! You could try videoing the trucks passing between two fixed points of measurable distance e.g. lampposts whilst timing them. Is there a timer on the camera?

Steve.



Thats easy to resolve - speed may be subjective, but film a car going through at the right speed, then compare that with the wagons, going past two reference points - easy comparison, no self-incrimination. If you do it from inside your car, you can easily show the two reference points and the camera timer will give you elapsed time. Film the lorry from the side of the road between the same two points, and even allowing for parallax errors you'll have sufficient evidence to get em nailed. Save the other video footage from yesterday just in case...

Dont let them get away with it.

Nacnud

Original Poster:

2,190 posts

275 months

Friday 28th June 2002
quotequote all
I'm not sure I was breaking any laws. I have a vague recollection that triangular roadsigns are not mandatory, only round ones are mandatory.

We've got triangular roadsigns with a picture of a car throwing stones from the wheels. Underneath the triangle is a black and white rectangular 20mph sign.

I've been thinking about this as I suspect Pennies will drag it out in defense of their lorries.

If I'm right then all the lorry drivers can be done for is driving like complete fwits.

mondeoman

11,430 posts

272 months

Friday 28th June 2002
quotequote all
Criminal damage then, driving without due care and attention...

Triangular signs are advisory, but plod/magistrates would probably take a dim view of anyone breaching the advisorys to such an extent that they cause damage to other people/property. The footage of the lorry and the kid on the bike (?) would go down rather well IMHO.

Have you spoken to local plod yet??

Nacnud

Original Poster:

2,190 posts

275 months

Friday 28th June 2002
quotequote all
Not yet - I'm waiting to see what the plod's advice to the garage is before I decide who to jump on and how hard.

Nacnud

Original Poster:

2,190 posts

275 months

Friday 28th June 2002
quotequote all
OK - Now I've got a problem.

I've talked to the Plant Manager at Penny and he has checked the tachographs from the lorry I videoed.

He claims that the lorry was stationary at the time I stated, in fact it stopped five minutes earlier. I already checked the camera and it's three minutes slow. If the tachograph was ten or more minutes adrift then this would be possible as I took the video as it arrived as its destination.

Here's the biggie. He says the tachograph shows the lorry was travelling at 40mph and peaked at 45mph !!!! When I was following this lorry my speedo never dropped below 55mph !!!!!!!

Thirdly - they say that their speed is irrelevant and I can only pursue this through the council.

Finally - he says their insurance company will believe their tachgraph to my verbal / video evidence. Lots of experience of this, etc. etc.

I expected them to make all the points except the speed shown by the tachograph. How can such a huge discrepency arise.

One possibility is that they might have pulled a tacho from a different lorry as they were not all driving like loonies. It would explain both the speed and time discrepencies.

Any other possibilities ?

Neil Menzies

5,167 posts

290 months

Friday 28th June 2002
quotequote all
quote:

Any other possibilities ?


Yes - they're lying through their teeth to avoid responsibility.

Nacnud

Original Poster:

2,190 posts

275 months

Friday 28th June 2002
quotequote all
Just been mowing the lawn to cool down a little and that thought just occurred to me as well. I think I've made a basic mistake - I believed what they said

They offered to let me go in and inspect the tachograph for myself. I think I'll see if that offer is still open and then ask if it will also be OK to take copies so I can show them to someone who knows what they are looking at. I won't have a clue !

JMorgan

36,010 posts

290 months

Friday 28th June 2002
quotequote all
Tacho's need to be calibrated. There should be a calibration sticker and a seal, can't remember where that is though. Probably different between makes in location.