When the S goes
When the S goes
Author
Discussion

phillpot

Original Poster:

17,509 posts

212 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
Bit quiet at work today so browsing the classifieds, and thinking some way ahead (hopefully), I guess one day my old bones aren't going to like clambering into the S.
So what would replace it ? a Z4, all the bells and whistles but lacking "character" (waits for Normans response).

Or how about one of these, I quite like the looks..... clicky.... No racing car but reasonably nippy, interior looks a bit plasticy but its got a V6! scratchchin

On a scale of 1 to 10 do they have any "street cred" ?




Edited by phillpot on Friday 28th December 10:36

steve j

3,223 posts

257 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
It does seem to tick a lot of the boxes, I like the look of the car too. How about the availability of spares ? I don`t think it will turn heads like an S though. I think a replacement for an S is another S.

phillpot

Original Poster:

17,509 posts

212 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
steve j said:
I think a replacement for an S is another S.
But that doesn't cure the hypothetical problem !

Stone Cold

1,555 posts

202 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
Not my cup of tea personally. Have you considered a Z350/370? A bit different (not pretty granted), not too many about, I reckon it would turn heads and possibly a bit more character than a Z4

greymrj

3,329 posts

233 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
Hey Mike, less of the negativity nono! I am past 65 and my 'old' bones still manage the TVR fine....work on keeping the old body fitting the TVR rather than finding a new car to fit the old body! (Seem to remember Top Gear didnt rate the Crossbow very highly?) Why not a Jag X type, most of them are driven by people who are past it! Or does that comment earn me a redcard

steve j

3,223 posts

257 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
phillpot said:
But that doesn't cure the hypothetical problem !
Maybe it`s a problem to difficult to cure, I`m not sure what else can give you the same buzz as an S, we all know what a fantastic little car it is.

mycroft

1,545 posts

276 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
Like Adrian i would consider the Z350 , i think they share a lot with the crossbow , fairly sure its the same power plant and Nissan running gear .
Always liked the look of the crossbow though .
Dale
PS Happy new year everybody smile

clive f

7,259 posts

262 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
as already said, the 350z or maybe a jag xkr, a lot of car for the money?

I`ve always fancied the masserati 3200, but worried about maintainance costs, but a nice v8 cloud9

Niiige

640 posts

198 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
This is a great question to pose Mike. Genius !!

To get to the answer I think you need to tell us what the key ingredients of the S are that you'd like to retain in your "easier to live with" replacement.

I'm guessing it is some of the following:-

Engine/exhaust sound
Steering feel
Britishness
Rarity
Speed/handling
Fun factor
Head turning/likeability
Looks/Styling

Here's a few thought starters
Original Mini Cooper (all that Motorsport heritage, great fun, British and appreciating too)
Previous shape XKR - cheap, luxurious and very comfortable and deceptively fast.
Land Rover NAS spec. If you can find one you get the iconic looks with a V8 soundtrack. And it's like a meccano set really !!!
Talbot Sunbeam Lotus. I had a friend who had one. Totally mad car. On a journey from Birmingham to Stratford we never got higher than 3rd gear. Same sort of TVR madness to it !

PS - can you leave me your S in your will (I can't believe no one has asked yet?)


phillpot

Original Poster:

17,509 posts

212 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
Niiige said:
- can you leave me your S in your will (I can't believe no one has asked yet?)
Hang on a minute, I'm talking about getting a little old and crotchety, not popping my clogs !!!!! eek


"Z cars" look an interesting option, think I followed a convertable one recently, very big acensorede to hide pack away hood.

TurboTony

908 posts

200 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
Chrysler Crossfire is a rebodied Mercedes Benz SLK320 and IIRC was not rated very highly for its dynamic ability.

Difficult to replace the S - nothing with the same mixture that could be easier to live with.

Scoobimax

1,892 posts

230 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
Honda S2000 for me if i had to replace the S

glenrobbo

40,477 posts

179 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
yikes Too old for the S? weeping

I think there's a nice clinic in Switzerland that can help.

They give you Cheerios for breakfast.......smile

tvrgit

8,489 posts

281 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
Niiige said:
Here's a few thought starters
Original Mini Cooper (all that Motorsport heritage, great fun, British and appreciating too)
Previous shape XKR - cheap, luxurious and very comfortable and deceptively fast.
Land Rover NAS spec. If you can find one you get the iconic looks with a V8 soundtrack. And it's like a meccano set really !!!
Talbot Sunbeam Lotus.
I am currently contemplating something to replace my Cerbera, which is currently up for sale. All of the above are on the list! Great choices!

My S isn't going quite yet though - but having just completed a petrol cradle replacement and now contemplating a trailing arm refurb, I'm soooo tempted! Roll on summer!

ketvrin

3,504 posts

238 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
I'm surprised no-ones suggested the obvious... An S5... Or as TVR called it , a Tamora...

That would be my choice if I were to "upgrade" from an S (instead of having to be rid of it as in my case cry )

Sounds like you have some fun test drives ahead of you though wink

I would start the research process right away...

K wink

themee

342 posts

188 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
Has to be the Honda S2000 for me too, plus its still an "S"

Niiige

640 posts

198 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
ketvrin said:
I'm surprised no-ones suggested the obvious... An S5... Or as TVR called it , a Tamora...

That would be my choice if I were to "upgrade" from an S (instead of having to be rid of it as in my case cry )

Sounds like you have some fun test drives ahead of you though wink

I would start the research process right away...

K wink
Having to be rid Kevin? I don't want to appear to be an ambulance chaser, but I'm looking at the moment. Do email me direct if you are selling.

N

mycroft

1,545 posts

276 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
TurboTony said:
Chrysler Crossfire is a rebodied Mercedes Benz SLK320 and IIRC was not rated very highly for its dynamic ability.

Difficult to replace the S - nothing with the same mixture that could be easier to live with.
I thought it was Nissan based , no idea were that came from , wrong again . SLK is a nice car too though.
Chap at the golf club just sold his Boxster and bought a 350z soft top , it looks fantastic and you don't see many about , he is very tall and said he couldn't get in the chim he tried .

TurboTony

908 posts

200 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
S2000 is the best of the bunch, but what could you do to make the interior more habitable?

If you want a cruiser, grp with steel chassis and a Ford V6 how about a Scimitar GTC? or a Gte with a Webasto roof. Go for an early se5 and it would be tax free - just thinking of making your pension go further!

Barry S1

1,709 posts

218 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
Description first word Gray
that says it all,
sleep