Please recommend me some waterproof overshoes
Discussion
Having always previously been a fair weather commuter, I'm determined to cycle through winter this year. I commute on a mountain bike with BMX pedals wearing trainers. Having spent some time looking I really can't see any overshoes that would be suitable for trainers - as they all look like I'd wear out the sole very quickly. Obviously if anyone does know of any please let me know.
Therefore it looks like I'm going to have to put my spd pedals on. I've already got some shoes, but can anyone recommend some very very waterproof overshoes for MTB spd shoes - there seems to be such a wide variety, cheaper ones are preferable ovbiously. I'll wear shorts no matter what the weather and I'm only on the bike for 70 mins a day. I have worn Gore-tex trainers in the past but the water just runs don my leg onto the sock, which is nice and absorbant.
All suggestions welcome.
Therefore it looks like I'm going to have to put my spd pedals on. I've already got some shoes, but can anyone recommend some very very waterproof overshoes for MTB spd shoes - there seems to be such a wide variety, cheaper ones are preferable ovbiously. I'll wear shorts no matter what the weather and I'm only on the bike for 70 mins a day. I have worn Gore-tex trainers in the past but the water just runs don my leg onto the sock, which is nice and absorbant.
All suggestions welcome.
IroningMan said:
As okgo says. they don't keep your feet entirely dry - but they do make a huge difference to how cold they get.
That's the biggest issue - cold hands and feet. I resolved the hands issue last year with some nice gloves, I hope to resolve the cold feet issue this year.Sounds like a trip to Evans at lunchtime tomorrow then.
As said, no overshoe is any good at water tightness. For my MTB I have some shimano winter boots, with a neoprene sock sewn in, which seem to keep your feet warm. I fell in a large puddle one day ( half submerged) and the foot that went in got wet, but after 5 minutes was 3 times warmer than the dry foot.
I tried this last winter with a couple of different brands of overshoe.
They were universally crap, and fell apart within weeks. I have 81 sets of traffic lights on my commute, plus use MTB SPDs, so between the aggressive sole profile and the frequency of clipping in and out and putting at least one foot down, they just got shredded on the underside. They also used to let water in through the holes on the bottom, as the MTB shoe doesn't have a flat sole, so there's lots of channels for the water to come up through.
As others have said, they're lovely and warm when wet, but if you can't dry them and your shoes at work, they're f
king horrible to put back on again in the evening!
I graduated from them to a pair of Goretex Northwave Farenheit boots. They were around £120, but they're still as good as new, and I reckon I'd have spent that much on multiple pairs of overshoes by now. I still get the problem of sock osmosis, but I've just bought a set of clip on mudguards for my snotter commuter bike, so hopefully this won't be so much of an issue this winter.
I have also toyed with the idea of cutting the fingers off some heavy duty rubber gloves and taping the arm portion round my leg just above the top of the boot to create little foot ponchos!
They were universally crap, and fell apart within weeks. I have 81 sets of traffic lights on my commute, plus use MTB SPDs, so between the aggressive sole profile and the frequency of clipping in and out and putting at least one foot down, they just got shredded on the underside. They also used to let water in through the holes on the bottom, as the MTB shoe doesn't have a flat sole, so there's lots of channels for the water to come up through.
As others have said, they're lovely and warm when wet, but if you can't dry them and your shoes at work, they're f
king horrible to put back on again in the evening!I graduated from them to a pair of Goretex Northwave Farenheit boots. They were around £120, but they're still as good as new, and I reckon I'd have spent that much on multiple pairs of overshoes by now. I still get the problem of sock osmosis, but I've just bought a set of clip on mudguards for my snotter commuter bike, so hopefully this won't be so much of an issue this winter.
I have also toyed with the idea of cutting the fingers off some heavy duty rubber gloves and taping the arm portion round my leg just above the top of the boot to create little foot ponchos!
When it comes to waterproof clothes for cycling I've found the only material that works is Goretex. For the summer I've got a pair of Goretex overshoes: http://www.tgstore.eu/race-power-overshoes-p-3303....
For the winter I have Shimano RW80's which I paid £99 for new a few years ago: http://www.bikeradar.com/gear/category/clothing/sh...
When it's cold and wet in the winter I use a combination of the above. Warm and dry feet.
When it's proper cold (below freezing) I'll pop some fleece lined on top of the shimanos: http://www.tgstore.eu/oxygen-thermo-overshoes-p-35...
You could always try Sealskinz waterproof socks.
For the winter I have Shimano RW80's which I paid £99 for new a few years ago: http://www.bikeradar.com/gear/category/clothing/sh...
When it's cold and wet in the winter I use a combination of the above. Warm and dry feet.
When it's proper cold (below freezing) I'll pop some fleece lined on top of the shimanos: http://www.tgstore.eu/oxygen-thermo-overshoes-p-35...
You could always try Sealskinz waterproof socks.
Slightly connected, but I've been looking for ages for some trainers that can fit under the overshoes.
The biggest problem is that most trainer soles are just too wide, especially around the heel. I have bought cheapish trainers with narrow soles, but they also happen to be too thin and so there's no padding between my feet and the pedals.
The overshoes I have are actually quite large, and I'm not going to go down the route of SPDs for commuting.
The biggest problem is that most trainer soles are just too wide, especially around the heel. I have bought cheapish trainers with narrow soles, but they also happen to be too thin and so there's no padding between my feet and the pedals.
The overshoes I have are actually quite large, and I'm not going to go down the route of SPDs for commuting.
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Pro-Tarmac-H2O-Road-Bike...
all winter and no wet feet.
(I do tape between the shoe inner and sole with duct tape to stop water getting in via the screw holes.)
all winter and no wet feet.
(I do tape between the shoe inner and sole with duct tape to stop water getting in via the screw holes.)
Simond S said:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Pro-Tarmac-H2O-Road-Bike...
all winter and no wet feet.
(I do tape between the shoe inner and sole with duct tape to stop water getting in via the screw holes.)
These are OK with flat soled road shoes, but not with MTB shoes. all winter and no wet feet.
(I do tape between the shoe inner and sole with duct tape to stop water getting in via the screw holes.)
For years i've worn a pair of hein gericke over shoes (motorbike shop) and i've not once got a wet foot. Even after riding through huge unavoidable puddles. Their website is down so I can't provide a link. They look ugly, and are wrapped around leg and foot and secured with velcro. I think they are gortex! Under a pair of water proof trousers they don't look too bad.
They must be getting on for being 10 years old so they are very durable. The sole of your footwear is exposed so all you need is something with a decent sole. I tend to always wear fabric running trainers (my everyday trainers) and they are totally dry to wear again later.
I wouldn't consider buying a pair of cycling overshoes, no matter how nice they look.
I must stress that these are not a fashion item
They must be getting on for being 10 years old so they are very durable. The sole of your footwear is exposed so all you need is something with a decent sole. I tend to always wear fabric running trainers (my everyday trainers) and they are totally dry to wear again later.
I wouldn't consider buying a pair of cycling overshoes, no matter how nice they look.
I must stress that these are not a fashion item
By complete coincidence this week's marketing e-mail from Planet-X includes details of these:
Overshoe Offers
Overshoe Offers
Gassing Station | Pedal Powered | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff