Laser dinghy.. on top of my little Jap car?
Laser dinghy.. on top of my little Jap car?
Author
Discussion

Jackleman

Original Poster:

974 posts

195 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
Looking in to getting a Laser 1 sailing dinghy, but I don't have a tow bar and most of the cheaper boats do not have road trailers included.

Is it possible to car top a Laser on to my Honda Civic? I know the boat would probably support the car but what about the other way around? :-)

Thanks chaps

XJ84

303 posts

185 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
Jackleman said:
Looking in to getting a Laser 1 sailing dinghy, but I don't have a tow bar and most of the cheaper boats do not have road trailers included.

Is it possible to car top a Laser on to my Honda Civic? I know the boat would probably support the car but what about the other way around? :-)

Thanks chaps
I did see a car go past me with an upside-down boat on it's roof a while ago, looked very amusing I must say but I guess that means it's doable...? This was a big 4x4 of some kind though, not a civic. Oh please, if you do it, take a picture or two.....

harryowl

1,114 posts

210 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
Used to take a Topper to Scotland every year on the roof of a volvo 850 every year.

Mrtee

91 posts

222 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
be wary of the weight rating of the roofrack!

I had a Suzuki Baleno Estate with roof-rails, so bought some cross-bars and put the laser on the roof - noticed the roof-rails bending quite a bit, so checked the manual - max 30kg on them frown - the cross-bars Id bought were OK to 100kg.

if the bars you buy can cope with the weight of the boat and trolley, go for it!!!

someone I know put a 420 on the roof of an AstraGTE, and drove it all the way to Keil-week!

windandwave

196 posts

272 months

Tuesday 14th June 2011
quotequote all
I've often seen it done on small cars. Weight won't be a problem (60kg ish?) but windage might be. Make sure you take it easy on exposed stretches where you may get crosswinds. That said, the reduction in fuel economy will mean you won't want to go too fast anyway.

Remember that the bow eye is only for a painter and isn't strong enough to be used as a main tie down point under any real tension. Also be sure to use some pipe lagging or the like on the roofrack to prevent damage to the hull.

F i F

48,647 posts

280 months

Wednesday 15th June 2011
quotequote all
I used to have a laser 1 and personally I wouldn't roof top it.

It is possible in theory but do as I did and get a second hand combi trailer.

If you roof top it, also consider launch and recovery side of things, or are you planning always to borrow someone else's trolley? Or if you have a trolley of your own you have to roof top that as well, just don't imho.


GeraldSmith

6,887 posts

246 months

Wednesday 15th June 2011
quotequote all
I used to carry a laser around on top of a Mk2 Escort without any problems. I could load and unload it on my own, if necessary, the mast went down one side and all the other stuff I needed went in the car. I had a roof rack that was designed for the job, still got it somewhere.

Hard-Drive

4,291 posts

258 months

Wednesday 15th June 2011
quotequote all
Uffa Fox actually ued to car top his Flying Fifteen when he designed it...keel off of course! And Andy Paterson of Bloodaxe used to car top his Cherub to mainland events to save IOW ferry costs.

But TBH don't bother, just tow it. If you want to do it on a budget all sailing clubs tend to have the "dead trailer" pile where you'd be able to pull something out the weeds for a donation to the RNLI and make it half decent with some new bearings and wheels. Take a trip to your local scrappy, you'll often find a car the same as yours with a towbar on it that's yours for £30...

dirkgently

2,160 posts

260 months

Wednesday 15th June 2011
quotequote all
Hard-Drive said:
Uffa Fox actually ued to car top his Flying Fifteen when he designed it...keel off of course! And Andy Paterson of Bloodaxe used to car top his Cherub to mainland events to save IOW ferry costs.
A Cherub weighs f all, but I do know that Olympians of the seventy`s used to car top flying Dutchmen largely for that reason.

Jackleman

Original Poster:

974 posts

195 months

Wednesday 15th June 2011
quotequote all
F i F said:
I used to have a laser 1 and personally I wouldn't roof top it.

It is possible in theory but do as I did and get a second hand combi trailer.

If you roof top it, also consider launch and recovery side of things, or are you planning always to borrow someone else's trolley? Or if you have a trolley of your own you have to roof top that as well, just don't imho.
I only need to roof top it for the initial purchase, once I get it home I am sorted as I live by a muddy creek!

hyperblue

2,907 posts

209 months

Wednesday 15th June 2011
quotequote all
If it's just to collect it, then go for it.

I've seen a Laser on top of a Metro before hehe

SpeedYellow

2,533 posts

256 months

Wednesday 15th June 2011
quotequote all
I was going to say when I was young and raced a lazer I moved it thousands of miles happily on a 1.0 Metro without a single incident.

F i F

48,647 posts

280 months

Thursday 16th June 2011
quotequote all
Jackleman said:
I only need to roof top it for the initial purchase, once I get it home I am sorted as I live by a muddy creek!
Ah OK, that's completely different then, fair enough, go for it, shouldn't be a problem. Just watch roof load specs on your vehicle.

Huntsman

9,299 posts

279 months

Thursday 16th June 2011
quotequote all
When I was a kid we went five up in an Austin Ambassador (I've not contributed to the 'best car your dad had thread') with a laser on the roof and towing an Abbey caravan to Bairritz.

I should think a laser on a modern Civic would be fine.

chrisga

2,128 posts

216 months

Monday 20th June 2011
quotequote all
Yep used to put a laser on the roof of our car, and went on holiday in my mums 1.0 metro with my topper on the roof when i was about 11. She didnt have a clue about sailing so left me to tie it down for the return journey. It didnt fall off - I was well chuffed!

As another poster said remember the painter loop isn't strong enough to use as a tie down, but do make sure you do tie the front of the boat down to your front towing eye or somewhere equally as sturdy as any gust of wind from a passing truck could cause some serious uplift.

mph1977

12,467 posts

197 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
the 1 litre nova that was my first car coped fairly happily with a Laser on the roof or on a road trailer... it also teaches a lot about trailer handling ...

a laser correctly positioned on the roof of a Cavalier/ Vectra makes a very effective sunshade as well as having a minimal effect on fuel consumption - at one one not uncommon to see my Dad's ent behind and my laser on top of Dad's Cavalier/ Vectra

sawman

5,166 posts

259 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
I used to car top my laser on fiat uno and citroen AX, sometimes it would be on the car for a week or so at a time - depending on when my flat mate was home to give me a hand lifting it off.

Just make sure you have a decent set of roof bars - either one from the car manufacturer or a decent Thule or whatever - I had a cheap one from halfords once, which collapsed on the first roundabout after leaving the laser centre in banbury. Lots of rope later and no more than 30mph got me back to norwich with the boat intact - there was a nice ding in the bonnet of my uno!

Rum Runner

2,340 posts

246 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2011
quotequote all
Personally I would use a combi trailer...much better.

chrisga

2,128 posts

216 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2011
quotequote all
Unless you don't have a tow bar on your car. As the OP said in his first post....

Rum Runner

2,340 posts

246 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2011
quotequote all
Put one on..better that then spending money for paint / panel damage.
Also when putting on the roof I have seen it late destroy car window when coming off the beach with gritty sand falling into window seals.
Laser is a good bit bigger and heavier than a topper and they are bad enough.
If you are either small or not to strong getting a laser over head high on the roof of a motor is not that easy.