which dinghy ?
Author
Discussion

Chimune

Original Poster:

4,237 posts

252 months

Monday 30th May 2011
quotequote all
Hi - i want to get back into dinghy sailing after 15/20 years. However, i cant decide what boat to get. I learnt in a Mirror and have owned an Enterprise plus an International 14 in the past. My local resevior is Derwent in Northumberland.

My problem is that i am not sure i will get any regular crew, so need something that 1 can launch and sail solo, 70% of the time. I want to be able to fit an adult crew in too for the other 30%.

I seem to remember that a wooden Enterprise was too heavy to pull up a lauch ramp by myself. The Mirror was a bit too small, and International 14s were too big !

I am trying to limit my budget to about £800, dont mind some DIY / Wood. I am thinking that perhaps a Laser is my best bet if i can find one for that kind of ££.

Any suggestions ?

happygoron

475 posts

218 months

Monday 30th May 2011
quotequote all
Laser, without question. Should easilly pick up a half tidy one for 800 and I expect they have a pretty decent laser fleet in derwent too. My rule of thumb is buy a bat which has an active fleet where you sail. Makes ownership 10x more fun, even if you're not a racer.

Chimune

Original Poster:

4,237 posts

252 months

Monday 30th May 2011
quotequote all
Thanks happygoron - i suspected a Laser would be the answer - there are several types however. What is the difference between them all: fun, pico, stratos ? Which is the fastest ?

croyde

26,288 posts

259 months

Monday 30th May 2011
quotequote all
Definitely a Laser. Great fun.


Fittster

20,120 posts

242 months

Monday 30th May 2011
quotequote all
I can't see how a laser is going to work if 30% of sailing is to be done with crew.

croyde

26,288 posts

259 months

Monday 30th May 2011
quotequote all
They will just have to be a passenger. That's why my daughter doesn't like coming with me anymore as she gets very bored. laugh

croyde

26,288 posts

259 months

Monday 30th May 2011
quotequote all
Maybe the OP would consider the Dart 16 Cat as they can be sailed with crew or solo.

Fittster

20,120 posts

242 months

Monday 30th May 2011
quotequote all
croyde said:
Maybe the OP would consider the Dart 16 Cat as they can be sailed with crew or solo.
Good call.

Searider

1,002 posts

284 months

Monday 30th May 2011
quotequote all
Need to get down to the sailing club and see what is sailed there - and get the same.
See what's for sale on the noticeboard.

Needs to be a Laser at least. A Pico is too small.


Rum Runner

2,340 posts

246 months

Monday 30th May 2011
quotequote all
Dart 16
Fast, easy to singlehand ..max fun for easly bored people especially with a wire.

Chimune

Original Poster:

4,237 posts

252 months

Tuesday 31st May 2011
quotequote all
Hmmm - Dart16 sounds fun. I did see this: Hobie 17 - but dont think i have ever seen a cat on Derwent. They do have a handicap fleet so perhaps it wouldnt be a problem.

They list their fleets on the web site, GP14, Laser Flyin15,Ent etc - all the usual stuff. The RS200s look fab but well out of my price range.

How big are Laser 2s ?

Are cats still hard to tack in btw? My only experience with them has been on the med - gybing them was the only option as they seem to refuse to go through the wind.

Actually - as an update, i was out with quite a few people over the bh weekend and turns out that a few of them can either sail or would be interested in starting . My 30% might increase to 50% !

Edited by Chimune on Tuesday 31st May 09:08

hyperblue

2,907 posts

209 months

Tuesday 31st May 2011
quotequote all
They are slower to tack than a monohull, but once get the technique right you won't have a problem.

You'll need a fairly big lake for a Dart 16, does your club have any?

happygoron

475 posts

218 months

Tuesday 31st May 2011
quotequote all
It's not unusual for inland clubs to not allow cats, so check. With regards to a 2 man boat that can be single manned you may get away with a laser 2 without a jib on your own.

996c2

470 posts

194 months

Tuesday 31st May 2011
quotequote all
I recently did my RYA level 2 in a Bosun dinghy that can be sailed single handed or accommodate 3-4 adults.

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

290 months

Tuesday 31st May 2011
quotequote all
He can't manage to launch and recover an Enterprise single handed, he#s never going to manage a Bosun!

What about a Firefly? They were originally designed for the olympics as a single hander, but are nearly always sailed with a crew. Lovely 'proper' dinghy.

If you fancy a handful, try a Fireball.

Cats tend to be a bit 'point and blip' but are wonderful fun, especially if you get it up on one hull - which always looks spectacular, but is slower.

Laser 2 is an option, but would it come in to budget?

Mrtee

91 posts

222 months

Tuesday 31st May 2011
quotequote all
if you like RS200's, but find them expensive - and want a fun cheap dinghy, look into a National 12.

they are very similar to an RS200, if your not a featherweight, its easy to sail single-handed, its light for pulling up a slip (I sail with my young daughters who are unable to help pulling it up the slip) - it weights under 100kgs

for £800 you should be able to get a good wooden mid-eighties N12 in very good condition and with decent kit on it.

I bought mine last year as something to introduce the kids to what a modern dinghy is like, couldnt (wouldnt!!) afford an RS, so went for the nearest thing in my price range - mine cost £800 and is a twice ex-british championship winning boat, with new sails and is in stunning condition.



if your sailing inland, then there are plenty of N12 designs that are perfect - Im on the sea, so needed a design that would cope with waves (it does JUST!) and also a fair bit of weight in the boat.

dont discount them cos they arent fashionable - they are fun and cheap.

sawman

5,166 posts

259 months

Tuesday 31st May 2011
quotequote all
I just picked up a miracle dinghy off fleabay, a bargain at less than £300, spent 20 quid on tin of varnish etc, and she's all ship shape. I then had to invest another few quid (ok slightly more than a few quid!) on new pulleys and stuff to get all the controls working properly. I've just joined Derwent and had a great blast in the pursuit race yesterday. Legs a bit achy today!! But I am impressed with the miracle it sails really well and would be fine single handed.

There are plenty of lasers as derwent, there are also some topaz's but Im not sure you would get one for 800, there is at least one RS vareo, but again you are not likely to get one for 800

Chimune

Original Poster:

4,237 posts

252 months

Friday 3rd June 2011
quotequote all
Cheers for the advice everyone. I am due up at the club on sunday to have a chat with the racing sec, so will see what the craik is. Let you know what i decide on !

sawman

5,166 posts

259 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
Chimune said:
Cheers for the advice everyone. I am due up at the club on sunday to have a chat with the racing sec, so will see what the craik is. Let you know what i decide on !
If the weathers ok I'll be down with the kids in the miracle

Chimune

Original Poster:

4,237 posts

252 months

Sunday 5th June 2011
quotequote all
Saw you out on the water sawman - membership sec said there was only 2 in the fleet and you were out there ! Looked like a pleasant afternoon tbh - after the rain went.

Anyway - turns out there is an open day on the 25th which may be offering memberhsip discount, plus the chance to talk to some other owners.

Fleet update from 15 years ago: enterprise fleet has disintegrated !. He showed me a Topaz which look interesting but perhaps a bit basic. Saw a very nice looking RS Vareo a guy purchased for £2k. No room for crew though....

Other good news is that you can sail just about anything there !!