Stelvio to Tonale?

Author
Discussion

username_checksout

Original Poster:

110 posts

7 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
Has anybody made the above switch? I currently drive a well-specced Stelvio Speciale with the 280bhp engine and nearly all the options apart from the sound system upgrade.

It's a great car and a lovely place to pass the miles but I've always thought it was a bit gawky looking from certain angles. I love the look of the Tonale and am pondering whether to get the Veloce mild-hybrid model.

I wondered if anybody has any experience with both. Failing that, I'd love to hear thoughts from Tonale owners. I've seen two out in the wild, and I thought catching a glimpse of another Stelvio was rare.

WindyCommon

3,491 posts

246 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
Stelvio to Tonale is a great bike ride - highly recommended ;>

username_checksout

Original Poster:

110 posts

7 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
WindyCommon said:
Stelvio to Tonale is a great bike ride - highly recommended ;>
Thoughts on that welcome too.

chopper602

2,252 posts

230 months

Thursday 15th August
quotequote all
Mrs. Chopper is pondering exactly the same switch. Test driving at the weekend, I prefer the plug-in hybrid but we'll have to see what the price is likely to be. The biggest disappointment with the Stelvio is the mpg, so this *has* to be an improvement

bennno

12,716 posts

276 months

Thursday 15th August
quotequote all

I can’t get my head past a car called toe nail.

r159

2,326 posts

81 months

Thursday 15th August
quotequote all
username_checksout said:
Has anybody made the above switch? I currently drive a well-specced Stelvio Speciale with the 280bhp engine and nearly all the options apart from the sound system upgrade.

It's a great car and a lovely place to pass the miles but I've always thought it was a bit gawky looking from certain angles. I love the look of the Tonale and am pondering whether to get the Veloce mild-hybrid model.

I wondered if anybody has any experience with both. Failing that, I'd love to hear thoughts from Tonale owners. I've seen two out in the wild, and I thought catching a glimpse of another Stelvio was rare.
When I bought my Stelvio (after having a Giulia) I asked the salesman about a Tonale, he said I wouldn’t like it, so I didn’t bother even sitting in one.

A month later I had one as a courtesy car, he was correct.

username_checksout

Original Poster:

110 posts

7 months

Friday 16th August
quotequote all
r159 said:
When I bought my Stelvio (after having a Giulia) I asked the salesman about a Tonale, he said I wouldn’t like it, so I didn’t bother even sitting in one.

A month later I had one as a courtesy car, he was correct.
Interesting - what didn't you like about it?

I went from a couple of Giulias to a Stelvio as well.

Kawasicki

13,465 posts

242 months

Friday 16th August
quotequote all
I think the Stelvio looks way better than the Tonale

username_checksout

Original Poster:

110 posts

7 months

Friday 16th August
quotequote all
I'm inclined the other way; the front of the Giulia and Stelvio remind me of the Ford Edsel from some angles whereas the gorgeous SZ's genes are abundant in the Tonale.

standards

1,178 posts

225 months

Friday 16th August
quotequote all
My son-in-law and daughter bought a brand new Tonale looked lovely, engine management lights and interior trim issues within weeks. Former still unresolved. They do call it the toe-nail and it seems deservedly so. It is to say the least, a disappointment after their VW Tiguan. She and I are firmly VW fans now.

r159

2,326 posts

81 months

Friday 16th August
quotequote all
username_checksout said:
r159 said:
When I bought my Stelvio (after having a Giulia) I asked the salesman about a Tonale, he said I wouldn’t like it, so I didn’t bother even sitting in one.

A month later I had one as a courtesy car, he was correct.
Interesting - what didn't you like about it?

I went from a couple of Giulias to a Stelvio as well.
I fear change,

chopper602

2,252 posts

230 months

Monday 19th August
quotequote all
We quite enjoyed the car (Tonale PHEV) for a few hours, but ultimately it looks like it's going to be too expensive. The one we had had an average of 58mpg on the dash and we weren't pussying it around

chopper602

2,252 posts

230 months

Sunday 10th November
quotequote all
Latest 0% credit option and a forthcoming ballon payment on the Stelvio means I've re-evaluated the Tonale. Emerald Green Plug-in Hybrid should be on the drive sometime next week . . .

mjlloyd500

126 posts

93 months

Thursday 14th November
quotequote all
OK. I've had 3 stelvios the last one being a 280 bhp veloce on the 72.ive had the tonale veloce 280 bhp plug in hybrid for a year now with all extras on it .I just don't like the gap between the wheels and the wheel arch but apart from that it's very much the same as the stelvios but the mpg is only any good when you use the electric. Boot it and it's as fast as the stelvio but only 30 mpg .

Pereldh

591 posts

119 months

RWD platform to FWD platform... Hideous looks IMHO but thats just me

Presuming Ed

1,493 posts

215 months

Yesterday (14:59)
quotequote all
I had a Tonale as a loan car when my Giulia was in for a service. It was horrid. The interior was cheap feeling, had that horrid plasticky smell. The Tech was awful, far too many bongs from the dash for speed warnings etc. It handled well but the transition from Hybris to ICE was very rough and the small engine really struggled with refinement.

chopper602

2,252 posts

230 months

Yesterday (23:40)
quotequote all
mjlloyd500 said:
. Boot it and it's as fast as the stelvio but only 30 mpg .
Lucky to get anywhere close to 30mpg with the Stelvio though, even when driven 'carefully'