Range Rover - 2018/2021 - Diesel 3.0L V6 or 4.4L V8?

Range Rover - 2018/2021 - Diesel 3.0L V6 or 4.4L V8?

Author
Discussion

Phil74891

Original Poster:

1,079 posts

140 months

Wednesday 2nd October
quotequote all
The above are looking to be good value right now, despite the obvious insurance and it won’t work issues.

Would be used for a few long trips and quite a few short ones.

If I did dive in, it would be a long term hold.

So which engine?

My only Land Rover experience is a 2012 Defender 90 and a 1954 Series One, both of which which I’ll be keeping.

Any advice much appreciated.

Phil.

5,138 posts

257 months

Wednesday 2nd October
quotequote all
SDV8 all day long. I’ve owned 3 of them. They are robust, smooth and sufficiently rapid for all types of driving and will deliver 30mpg+ on long journeys.

The SDV8 had an additional dynamic control system on the suspension (can’t remember the LR name for it) that the V6 didn’t, which makes a big difference to how it corners.

There were some problems with the V6 engine but I don’t know if they solved that for later L405 versions.

Best thing to do is search the FFRR forums:

https://www.fullfatrr.com/forum/

Time4another

270 posts

10 months

Wednesday 2nd October
quotequote all
SDV8 all day long

LooneyTunes

7,582 posts

165 months

Thursday 3rd October
quotequote all
5.0 supercharged… or the SDV8.

I’ve driven all of the engines from that era:
Hybrid: fine when electric only, gutless and unrefined the rest of the time.
3.0 v6: it’s OK, but can feel a bit slow.
SDV8: very nice indeed, more responsive than I was expecting.
S/c: just had the edge and, although the MPG isn’t great, seem to hold their value better (offsetting the fuel cost a bit).

All are much better than a Puma or Series, but don’t sell either of those! I sold my Puma when I bought my RR. Cost me 50% more to buy another one a couple of years later…

Wheel Turned Out

1,051 posts

45 months

Thursday 3rd October
quotequote all
For me, JLR 3.0 diesels are to be thoroughly avoided.

If the V8 is in scope, absolutely get it. It's not without its issues, but much more pleasing.

Batfoy

662 posts

13 months

Thursday 3rd October
quotequote all
We have both, 3.0 in the RRS and 4.4 in the FFRR. Weirdly, the RRS feels brisker but the 4.4 absolutely suits the big boy.

megenzo

261 posts

143 months

Thursday 3rd October
quotequote all
As loony says, 4.4 if you are doing some miles (say over 10k pa), below that, 5.0l SC everyday of the week. I'm on a 4.4 but the next one will prob be a keeper into retirement so I may bite the bullet on the current mile costs for the future benefit of the SC