Freelander Td4

Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

61 months

Thursday 7th January 2021
quotequote all
What are the common problems of these and is there a more reliable model or even make? Cheers

camel_landy

5,081 posts

190 months

Thursday 7th January 2021
quotequote all
Assuming you're referring to the original Freelander, rather than Freelander 2...

Main issues are around the following:

  • IRD & Viscous Coupling, which can lead to excessive tyre wear. Hit Google for the full details.
  • Centre prop bearing failure (grumbling at approx 30-40mph).
  • Rear diff mount.
As for the engine, it's fairly solid (BMW lump) but it does need servicing by someone who knows them. Problems can be caused by the crank breather getting blocked.

They're great motors, though getting on a bit now and the TD4 Auto is by far the best.

HTH

M

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

61 months

Thursday 7th January 2021
quotequote all
And how would a Freelander compare to a Discovery TD5 from a reliability point of view?

camel_landy

5,081 posts

190 months

Thursday 7th January 2021
quotequote all
mgsontour said:
And how would a Freelander compare to a Discovery TD5 from a reliability point of view?
They are completely different cars and given that both will be at least 15yrs old, reliability will be very much dictated by how well they've been looked after.

M

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

61 months

Thursday 7th January 2021
quotequote all
camel_landy said:
They are completely different cars and given that both will be at least 15yrs old, reliability will be very much dictated by how well they've been looked after.

M
Fair play, cheers

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

197 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
mgsontour said:
And how would a Freelander compare to a Discovery TD5 from a reliability point of view?
As Camel says, quite different vehicles in term of design and construction.

Both can be good but expect niggles. As a rule Land Rovers are pretty dependable, i.e. they will keep going. But will always have a few issues. Good parts supply, prices and knowledge in the motoring world are big plus points however.

As of for other brands, much the same really. I know certain marques have reps of better or worse reliability. But it is much of a muchness in my experience. 2 friends have got shot of Nissan X-Trails in the past 12 months due to issue. One replaced with a Toyota Rav4 that has just needed a lot spending on it to get it through an MoT.

My Mum is on her 2nd Freelander. Current one is a Td4, past one was a 1.8 petrol (which was also awesome, but sadly written off in a crash).

2 cousins also have Freelanders, both Td4's. One is on 196,000 miles and still going strong.

Best friend runs a Disco Td5 and there are 2 on the farm. Watch for rust on the rear chassis by the fuel tank.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

61 months

Friday 8th January 2021
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
As Camel says, quite different vehicles in term of design and construction.

Both can be good but expect niggles. As a rule Land Rovers are pretty dependable, i.e. they will keep going. But will always have a few issues. Good parts supply, prices and knowledge in the motoring world are big plus points however.

As of for other brands, much the same really. I know certain marques have reps of better or worse reliability. But it is much of a muchness in my experience. 2 friends have got shot of Nissan X-Trails in the past 12 months due to issue. One replaced with a Toyota Rav4 that has just needed a lot spending on it to get it through an MoT.

My Mum is on her 2nd Freelander. Current one is a Td4, past one was a 1.8 petrol (which was also awesome, but sadly written off in a crash).

2 cousins also have Freelanders, both Td4's. One is on 196,000 miles and still going strong.

Best friend runs a Disco Td5 and there are 2 on the farm. Watch for rust on the rear chassis by the fuel tank.
Thanks and points well received, just seen one on Autotrader and looks and sounds good but the MOT history takes some reading and looks a one to avoid in my eyes