Defender advice required

Defender advice required

Author
Discussion

tonymor

Original Poster:

1,494 posts

179 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
My daughter has long thought of buying a defender not so new , governed by price. Anyone got a good , bad and ugly report/ guidance on what’s what with these ?

David Beer

3,982 posts

274 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
I had a 2004 90 Xs, Bought in 2009 never went wrong and lost me 4 k until I sold it last year. I still have a defender but it’s not quite normal, it’s a rare SVX convertible, now that has by latest indications more than doubled in value !. Again never gone wrong.

fredd1e

783 posts

227 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
Each model variant has its own idiosyncrasies and they all tend to share some common ones
Common: Chassis rust, bulkhead corrosion. Alloy over steel eletrolytic corrossion of the alloy (doors etc) . Argicultural steering handling though some see that as a plus.
Of the issues known to affect the TDCI range I would say there were a few reports of unexpected grenading engines , The heater resistor pack fails leaving you with only max fan speed and its usually corroded in and a pig to swap. The earlier TD5 engined defenders had thier own engine issues such as heads moving on the block due to poor locator dowels, oil pump failures though most that are still running would hopefully had fixes by now (post 2002 Td5 supposedly better sorted) . Earlier again TDi engined defenders had fans (for the engines fix in a field basics?) though Imo slower and more agricultural than later TD5s or TDCis ... I think to have to really really want a defender and then love its features to use one as a daily . Buying one as a fashion statement would be a hard to live with lifestyle choice. I owned my TDCi 110CSW for 2 years during which the heater pack resistor failed 3 times , 1st two picked by the supplying dealer after that it was declared out of warrenty cover even though it was under LR extended warrenty cover. Engaging Low range was symphony of grinding gears regardless of technique used . Lots of people love them obviously , I think in the end I preferred my old disco 11 for its better useablity, though these have no coolness factor these days .

tonymor

Original Poster:

1,494 posts

179 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
Actually my mistake I meant to post freelander.
Same question to ask though.

A500leroy

5,581 posts

125 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
advice? Having owned 2, DONT DO IT, if there is a day in the week that ends with y, something will be broken.

anonymous-user

61 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
A500leroy said:
advice? Having owned 2, DONT DO IT, if there is a day in the week that ends with y, something will be broken.
Mine’s been absolutely fine since before last Christmas at least. Can’t remember the last thing to truly go wrong with it.