Thinking of a corrado, which engine??

Thinking of a corrado, which engine??

Author
Discussion

vodkakid

Original Poster:

1,076 posts

277 months

Friday 13th January 2006
quotequote all
Been thinking of getting a corrado and wondered what the pros and cons of the engines are? I've heard that g60's can have problems with there chargers....? but dont really know anything else. Any pointers would be great. Cheers AC

hiasakite

2,407 posts

252 months

Friday 13th January 2006
quotequote all
www.the-corrado.net is a good place to start- plus there are buying guides available there too..

So long as the G60 has its charger serviced every 60K and isn't shagged to start with, its pretty reliable in standard tune.

The G60 is very easily uprated to 180BHP, however go higher (I know of people getting 200+from G60's) reliability starts to become a bit circumspect...

VR6 in standard are 190BHP. They are generally fairly reliable, however they will uise some oil (big engine).

Anywhere between 100-200K they may require a the timing chains to be renewed (the VR6 doesn't have cam-belt, just chains).. VW maintain that the chains should never need replacing however if it sounds abit 'rattly' then the tensioner may be on the way out ..

To tune a VR6 above 200BHP gets v. expensive however- you need to look at fitting shrick maniofolds, exhausts, chipping etc.. power over 230BHP really means turboing or supercharging (which costs 1.5-2K for supercharger kit). Supercharging can get you to 311BHP, turboing- I'm not sure..doesn't tend to be too common in the UK

In terms of drive, the VR6 is propbably the more relaxed cruiser, whereas the G60 is 'fun' as it where..
Both have outstanding handling for a FWD.

hiasakite

2,407 posts

252 months

Friday 13th January 2006
quotequote all
A bit more info-

2.0l 8v- very rare but a bit 'gutless' incomparison ...cheap (for a corrado) insurance though

1.8 16v and 2.0l 16v ..very good and reliable if looked after- obviously slower than VR or G60 but lower insurance groups too (14 for 16v vs 16 for G60 [I think] and 18 for the VR ..suggest you check this- I know the VR figure is right)

eowen

16,699 posts

270 months

Friday 13th January 2006
quotequote all
Vr6 is the only one worth considering.

JonRB

75,615 posts

277 months

Friday 13th January 2006
quotequote all
hiasakite said:
To tune a VR6 above 200BHP gets v. expensive however- you need to look at fitting shrick maniofolds, exhausts, chipping etc.. power over 230BHP really means turboing or supercharging (which costs 1.5-2K for supercharger kit). Supercharging can get you to 311BHP
205bhp is easily attainable with a simple induction kit, enlarged throttle body and a remap. Possibly a little more if you throw in a sports exhaust as well.

The supercharger conversion doesn't yield anything like 311bhp, I'm afraid. Generally most VR6 owners running superchragers see around 275bhp, although my knowledge of this is a little out of date I will admit.
Last time I looked at supercharging it was £5k+, but obviously prices have fallen.

Don't forget you can fit the variable-length inlet manifold (the VSR / VGI) which gives lots more low-down torque. Was always destined as standard fit but got axed by the beancounters.

JonRB

75,615 posts

277 months

Friday 13th January 2006
quotequote all
eowen said:
VR6 is the only one worth considering.
Not so. The G60 is said by many to have purer handling as the engine is lighter, and £-per-bhp is cheaper to modify too.
And don't forget that there are several 1.8T conversions around and even a couple of R32-engined conversions.

vodkakid

Original Poster:

1,076 posts

277 months

Friday 13th January 2006
quotequote all
Cheers, i was looking more towards a standard engine. I'll check out that other site for a buyers guide!

hiasakite

2,407 posts

252 months

Friday 13th January 2006
quotequote all
JonRB said:
hiasakite said:
To tune a VR6 above 200BHP gets v. expensive however- you need to look at fitting shrick maniofolds, exhausts, chipping etc.. power over 230BHP really means turboing or supercharging (which costs 1.5-2K for supercharger kit). Supercharging can get you to 311BHP
205bhp is easily attainable with a simple induction kit, enlarged throttle body and a remap. Possibly a little more if you throw in a sports exhaust as well.

The supercharger conversion doesn't yield anything like 311bhp, I'm afraid. Generally most VR6 owners running superchragers see around 275bhp, although my knowledge of this is a little out of date I will admit.
Last time I looked at supercharging it was £5k+, but obviously prices have fallen.

Don't forget you can fit the variable-length inlet manifold (the VSR / VGI) which gives lots more low-down torque. Was always destined as standard fit but got axed by the beancounters.


Sorry- as I said supercharging is not a cheap option by any means...to clarify supercharging alone will not get you 300BHP- the 311 BHP example has had just about everything done to it inc Schrick manifold, charger, charge cooler, rebore to 3.1l (I think- or maybe 3.2), waterinjection, remap etc..



As Jon said the Schrick/VSR manifold improves the low end torque considerably- however even that isn't exactly cheap...

The standard Corrado VR engine only really comes on cam from around 3K revs plus..despite being a 2.9 it doesn't feel 'that' quick at low revs.. although the car I would say is quicker than it 'feels' due to the smooth power delivery across the rev range..

JonRB

75,615 posts

277 months

Friday 13th January 2006
quotequote all
hiasakite said:
As Jon said the Schrick/VSR manifold improves the low end torque considerably- however even that isn't exactly cheap...
Oh, I quite agree. Around £1700 last time I looked, and I fear that may have been ex VAT too.

Having said that, I wish I'd had it done years ago as that would have been an acceptable 10% of the car's value (and I'd have had the use of it for years) rather than the 34% it would be now.

iguana

7,047 posts

265 months

Friday 13th January 2006
quotequote all
JonRB said:

Having said that, I wish I'd had it done years ago as that would have been an acceptable 10% of the car's value (and I'd have had the use of it for years) rather than the 34% it would be now.


A rather generous valuation of yr car there jon 'eh

JonRB

75,615 posts

277 months

Friday 13th January 2006
quotequote all
iguana said:
A rather generous valuation of yr car there jon 'eh
You think £5k is a bit optimistic for a 2-owner 96N VR6 with 111k on the clock? Maybe you're right - I haven't checked the prices lately.

hiasakite

2,407 posts

252 months

Friday 13th January 2006
quotequote all
JonRB said:
iguana said:
A rather generous valuation of yr car there jon 'eh
You think £5k is a bit optimistic for a 2-owner 96N VR6 with 111k on the clock? Maybe you're right - I haven't checked the prices lately.


They've been going up and down like yoyo's over last year and a bit...I'd say that they are at low at the moment...


main driver seems to be how many are for sale at any one time..

Fortjefferson

8,237 posts

227 months

Saturday 14th January 2006
quotequote all
This is a nice one. www.cardomain.com/ride/525442

iguana

7,047 posts

265 months

Saturday 14th January 2006
quotequote all
Jon it was a gag mate, but as youve asked, no I dont see yr car being worth even close to that figure.

Ive known a few average cars similar spec change hands lately at sub £3k, even as low as £2.5k for ok examples with history & 130k.

Other end of scale really really mint lower mile examples at £6k+

Just as an example a mate is watching this car is going on e-bay at the mo, few more miles on than yrs & needs a couple of bits sorting but at present with 23hrs to go its only at £1400 & the reserve is already met, interesting to see what it gets.

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/1995-VOLKSWAGEN-CORRADO-VR6-PU

JonRB

75,615 posts

277 months

Saturday 14th January 2006
quotequote all
iguana said:
Just as an example a mate is watching this car is going on e-bay at the mo, few more miles on than yrs & needs a couple of bits sorting but at present with 23hrs to go its only at £1400 & the reserve is already met, interesting to see what it gets.
Christ on a Bike! And to think I paid £23k for mine when I bought it!!!

Still, having said that, if we say it's worth £3k now then that's still only £2k per year depreciation, which I guess isn't too terrible.

Oh well, if it is worth that little then I guess I may as well keep it.

Shirkin

11,121 posts

255 months

Saturday 14th January 2006
quotequote all
Jon if you ever fancy selling it, give me a shout.

EmmaP

11,758 posts

244 months

Monday 16th January 2006
quotequote all
Shirkin said:
Jon if you ever fancy selling it, give me a shout.


EmmaP

11,758 posts

244 months

Monday 16th January 2006
quotequote all
I would recommend you taking some different engined Corrados out for a test run. That way you will be able to decide which one feels right for you. I'm a big fan of the VR6. That was always the one for me. My friend used to have a 16V and it was a bit gutless in comparison (probably more to do with the fact that it was not the best example out there and had the worst set of tyres and brakes imaginable). I've never experienced a G60. I gave them a wide berth because of the potential supercharger catastrophe. I guess that if you maintain them then you won't have too many worries. Same as most cars really.

JonRB

75,615 posts

277 months

Monday 16th January 2006
quotequote all
EmmaP said:
Shirkin said:
Jon if you ever fancy selling it, give me a shout.
Hey, you never know. It's bound to happen sometime.

SpaceCowboy

563 posts

241 months

Monday 16th January 2006
quotequote all
JonRB said:
hiasakite said:
As Jon said the Schrick/VSR manifold improves the low end torque considerably- however even that isn't exactly cheap...
Oh, I quite agree. Around £1700 last time I looked, and I fear that may have been ex VAT too.


Yo. My Golf VR6 had a brand new Corrado 2.9 block fitted by Stealth Racing 12,000 miles ago. It's also got a Schrick manifold & cams, amongst a few other bits & pieces. I reckon if you shop about, you'd manage to get the manifold cheaper than £1,700. Mine was purchased as part of a group buy through the VR6 Owners Club and cost (I think, need to check receipts) in the region of £1,000.

For what it's worth, around this time last year, whilst still not run in, mine was rolling-roaded at 212bhp. The next step would be to have a 'charger or turbo fitted. The potential for the turbo conversions is amazing. I saw my first one in the flesh in December and it was bouncing off the rollers until a rather large chap sat in the passenger seat. Whilst I'm sure it rocks whilst on the move, it must be a nightmare getting traction from standstill.