Is this high millage Audi A3 worth buying?

Is this high millage Audi A3 worth buying?

Author
Discussion

Dbz2021

Original Poster:

31 posts

36 months

Sunday 7th November 2021
quotequote all
It's a 2009 Audi A3 1.4 TFSI Sportback S Tronic 5dr Automatic
very high millage 160,000!
but has full service history by Audi and seller claims it's been well looked after only 2 owners with new tyres also timing belt and transmission oil changed recently
they are asking 2k for it.


Edited by Dbz2021 on Sunday 7th November 20:36


Edited by Dbz2021 on Sunday 7th November 20:38

JapanRed

1,570 posts

118 months

Sunday 7th November 2021
quotequote all
Dbz2021 said:
It's a 2009 Audi S3 1.4 TFSI Sportback S Tronic 5dr Automatic
very high millage 160,000!
but has full service history by Audi and seller claims it's been well looked after also timing belt and transmission oil changed recently
they are asking 2k for it.
I didn’t think they did a 1.4 S3 did they?
Happy to be corrected but I’m 99% sure that all S3’s are 2 litre. Have you made a mistake or is the seller pulling wool over your eyes?

Dbz2021

Original Poster:

31 posts

36 months

Sunday 7th November 2021
quotequote all
JapanRed said:
I didn’t think they did a 1.4 S3 did they?
Happy to be corrected but I’m 99% sure that all S3’s are 2 litre. Have you made a mistake or is the seller pulling wool over your eyes?
It is an A3

Dr G

15,405 posts

249 months

Tuesday 9th November 2021
quotequote all
At 2k if you get a year out of it then sell for scrap it would be reasonable value for money. Anything more is a bonus.

Hoofy

77,505 posts

289 months

Tuesday 9th November 2021
quotequote all
Dr G said:
At 2k if you get a year out of it then sell for scrap it would be reasonable value for money. Anything more is a bonus.
That's my thinking. If they were asking £3-4k, I'd run. £2k isn't far off bangernomics pricing and it should last at least a year.

OPer, I'd wonder what state the turbo is in as well as that DSG box. You can at least check the box by going for a drive in moderately fast roads as well as taking it round slow roads with mini roundabouts and T-junctions to see how it behaves when it's having to change gear a lot. If it shudders, jerks (imagine what it feels like if you change a manual gear badly) or looks like it's struggling to find the next gear, then the box is in trouble. An oil change might fix it... but it might not.

Trevor555

4,506 posts

91 months

Tuesday 9th November 2021
quotequote all
Transmission oil changed recently and now for sale.

Gets my alarm bells ringing.

Hoofy

77,505 posts

289 months

Tuesday 9th November 2021
quotequote all
Trevor555 said:
Transmission oil changed recently and now for sale.

Gets my alarm bells ringing.
Oh, I missed that. I suppose it would be interesting to see if the auto box works fine. If it still jerks/clunks then you know it's fked!

Hugo Stiglitz

38,038 posts

218 months

Tuesday 9th November 2021
quotequote all
It's the old 1.4 and a DSG on that mileage OP seriously I know it probably looks quite nice but that 2k will soon be 2k+ with bills with that engine and that gearbox of that era.

Hoofy

77,505 posts

289 months

Tuesday 9th November 2021
quotequote all
Hugo Stiglitz said:
It's the old 1.4 and a DSG on that mileage OP seriously I know it probably looks quite nice but that 2k will soon be 2k+ with bills with that engine and that gearbox of that era.
Interesting - that would then bring it in line with lower mileage examples... except you have a 160k mile car still!

Does sound like a false economy.

Trailhead

2,628 posts

154 months

Tuesday 9th November 2021
quotequote all
The worst that can happen is you lose £2k. So let’s get relative here. Have a good test drive and if the box and turbo feel ok then maybe it’s ok for 6-12 months of motoring?

Dr G

15,405 posts

249 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Trevor555 said:
Transmission oil changed recently and now for sale.

Gets my alarm bells ringing.
Good point. No scheduled oil change on that box, and they're known for eating their clutch packs.

You wonder if someone's already decided it's down to scrap value...

Dbz2021

Original Poster:

31 posts

36 months

Saturday 13th November 2021
quotequote all
I decided not to take sellers 2k offer since it had “oil leak but not excessive” on its past 3 MOTs.
It was an eBay auction and it sold for 2.5k.
my search continues..
I’m after bangernomic (for 4-5 years) in style! under £4k

Edited by Dbz2021 on Saturday 13th November 22:47

Hoofy

77,505 posts

289 months

Sunday 14th November 2021
quotequote all
A £4k budget is not bangernomic territory. Bangernomics to me is when it requires a decent chunk of cash to fix eg £500, you scrap it and buy another.

I can't remember where I read it but someone once said that £4-5k budget is a strange place because cars start to have problems and can cost a couple of £k to fix but they're not so cheap that you'd just scrap them... and they're not so expensive that they're reliable. I suppose this does depend on the car. Maybe a £2k car with a maintenance budget of £2k might work?

Dbz2021

Original Poster:

31 posts

36 months

Sunday 14th November 2021
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
A £4k budget is not bangernomic territory. Bangernomics to me is when it requires a decent chunk of cash to fix eg £500, you scrap it and buy another.

I can't remember where I read it but someone once said that £4-5k budget is a strange place because cars start to have problems and can cost a couple of £k to fix but they're not so cheap that you'd just scrap them... and they're not so expensive that they're reliable. I suppose this does depend on the car. Maybe a £2k car with a maintenance budget of £2k might work?
normally maximum of 2k is what I call bangernomic,but as you know used car prices are up significantly since covid..also I need an automatic and I don’t think you could ever buy an auto under 1k anyway.
as for the necessary repair cost and cars starting to have problems,I don’t think it’s always the case.

used car very much depends on luck.
I know 2 people who always buy old used cars from auctions use them few years then sell them,they don’t necessarily need expensive repairs and don’t necessarily fail at certain age.

Hoofy

77,505 posts

289 months

Sunday 14th November 2021
quotequote all
Dbz2021 said:
Hoofy said:
A £4k budget is not bangernomic territory. Bangernomics to me is when it requires a decent chunk of cash to fix eg £500, you scrap it and buy another.

I can't remember where I read it but someone once said that £4-5k budget is a strange place because cars start to have problems and can cost a couple of £k to fix but they're not so cheap that you'd just scrap them... and they're not so expensive that they're reliable. I suppose this does depend on the car. Maybe a £2k car with a maintenance budget of £2k might work?
normally maximum of 2k is what I call bangernomic,but as you know used car prices are up significantly since covid..also I need an automatic and I don’t think you could ever buy an auto under 1k anyway.
as for the necessary repair cost and cars starting to have problems,I don’t think it’s always the case.

used car very much depends on luck.
I know 2 people who always buy old used cars from auctions use them few years then sell them,they don’t necessarily need expensive repairs and don’t necessarily fail at certain age.
Bangernomics is £1k in my mind. Still plenty of cars at that price.

Dbz2021

Original Poster:

31 posts

36 months

Sunday 14th November 2021
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
Dbz2021 said:
Hoofy said:
A £4k budget is not bangernomic territory. Bangernomics to me is when it requires a decent chunk of cash to fix eg £500, you scrap it and buy another.

I can't remember where I read it but someone once said that £4-5k budget is a strange place because cars start to have problems and can cost a couple of £k to fix but they're not so cheap that you'd just scrap them... and they're not so expensive that they're reliable. I suppose this does depend on the car. Maybe a £2k car with a maintenance budget of £2k might work?
normally maximum of 2k is what I call bangernomic,but as you know used car prices are up significantly since covid..also I need an automatic and I don’t think you could ever buy an auto under 1k anyway.
as for the necessary repair cost and cars starting to have problems,I don’t think it’s always the case.

used car very much depends on luck.
I know 2 people who always buy old used cars from auctions use them few years then sell them,they don’t necessarily need expensive repairs and don’t necessarily fail at certain age.
Bangernomics is £1k in my mind. Still plenty of cars at that price.
It depends..I want it to be a decent looking “banger” and automatic.
It seems impossible to find anything like that under £2k at the moment.
so in my case,it’s going to be £2k-£3.5k range

Trailhead

2,628 posts

154 months

Monday 15th November 2021
quotequote all
Dbz2021 said:
Hoofy said:
Dbz2021 said:
Hoofy said:
A £4k budget is not bangernomic territory. Bangernomics to me is when it requires a decent chunk of cash to fix eg £500, you scrap it and buy another.

I can't remember where I read it but someone once said that £4-5k budget is a strange place because cars start to have problems and can cost a couple of £k to fix but they're not so cheap that you'd just scrap them... and they're not so expensive that they're reliable. I suppose this does depend on the car. Maybe a £2k car with a maintenance budget of £2k might work?
normally maximum of 2k is what I call bangernomic,but as you know used car prices are up significantly since covid..also I need an automatic and I don’t think you could ever buy an auto under 1k anyway.
as for the necessary repair cost and cars starting to have problems,I don’t think it’s always the case.

used car very much depends on luck.
I know 2 people who always buy old used cars from auctions use them few years then sell them,they don’t necessarily need expensive repairs and don’t necessarily fail at certain age.
Bangernomics is £1k in my mind. Still plenty of cars at that price.
It depends..I want it to be a decent looking “banger” and automatic.
It seems impossible to find anything like that under £2k at the moment.
so in my case,it’s going to be £2k-£3.5k range
I agree with you. Anything up to around £4K is bangernomics!

Hoofy

77,505 posts

289 months

Monday 15th November 2021
quotequote all
biggrin

£4k feels like treating myself.

Condi

17,985 posts

178 months

Monday 15th November 2021
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
biggrin

£4k feels like treating myself.
Agree. Was more than my first 4 or 5 cars cost! Thought the whole point of bangernomics was you could just buy another one if there was a big bill, £4k is a lot to find on more than one occasion.

Anyway, some interesting or worthwhile stuff below £1k with auto box

Merc SLK with MOT til next June https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202111159...

Merc C Class with MOT til next September https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202111139...

Pug 407 diesel, short MOT though, but good miles https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202110158...

Mondeo Ghia version, MOT til March and parts are dead cheap if needed https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202110309...