TDi 130 Turbo Trouble when chipped

TDi 130 Turbo Trouble when chipped

Author
Discussion

Don Veloci

Original Poster:

1,985 posts

286 months

Tuesday 19th April 2005
quotequote all
Top of my wish list at the moment is chipping my Golf 130 TDi.

One of the tuners I was talking to reckoned that some Golf 130s' blew their turbo when chipped/remapped.
Never Audi/Skoda/Seat 130 motors, just the Golf (Surely they're all the same?).

He reckoned my late model (53 plate) would be unlikely to be affected.

Anybody confirm or deny this?

TDI_MAN

16 posts

234 months

Tuesday 19th April 2005
quotequote all
The 130PD engine is the same throughout all the VAG range with just ancillary parts changing between models and marques.

Mine has been serially reprogrammed to a supposed 163Hp for over 13,000 miles now and has been totally trouble free. I suppose it also depeneds on whether you go for a generic chip or a custom one.

A custom one will take into account any other engine mods you have done which could all add together and push the turbo a bit too far.

The generic chips alter the fuel mapping but my tuner said that all it does in essence is widen the windows to which the turbo will operate and to what boost level. The VAG safeguard limits are not changed at all so as long as you keep to the 10K service interval you won't have any problems.

Regular oil changes = happy turbo

Don Veloci

Original Poster:

1,985 posts

286 months

Wednesday 20th April 2005
quotequote all
Cheers, I did have a theory that the guy I was talking to was being creative to try to push his particular product which switches between a standard and modified map as you wish, claiming that you can switch to the standard map for warranty work with no problems from vag

edc

9,293 posts

256 months

Wednesday 20th April 2005
quotequote all
Would that be Revo or APR then? Both have lots of happy customers either way.

TDI_MAN

16 posts

234 months

Wednesday 20th April 2005
quotequote all
How about Upsolute?

With a serial re-program VW cannot tell it has been done by diagnostic software and it doesn't affect servicing.

edc

9,293 posts

256 months

Wednesday 20th April 2005
quotequote all
There are all sorts of allegations, truths and untruths that you can indeed see that the ECU has been 'chipped'. Whether they go to the trouble to find out is a different matter. Also been known for people to leave their switches in the car for service ...

Don Veloci

Original Poster:

1,985 posts

286 months

Thursday 21st April 2005
quotequote all
Cheers for the replies guys.

I was talking to Star Performance in Fife. In no way am I criticising the guy. I'm just suprised I'd never heard of potential turbo trouble on the 130 motors so I thought it fair to look into it a little further and ask around.

Certainly I was not put off the idea of chipping the car and may well go with Star.

edc

9,293 posts

256 months

Thursday 21st April 2005
quotequote all
IIRC Star do APR and DMS maps. Well known in the VAG world. I suppose they would be in a beter position than most to judge if they see cars coming in with broken turbos.

NDT

1,762 posts

268 months

Thursday 21st April 2005
quotequote all
TDI_MAN said:
The 130PD engine is the same throughout all the VAG range with just ancillary parts changing between models and marques.

Mine has been serially reprogrammed to a supposed 163Hp for over 13,000 miles now and has been totally trouble free. I suppose it also depeneds on whether you go for a generic chip or a custom one.

A custom one will take into account any other engine mods you have done which could all add together and push the turbo a bit too far.

The generic chips alter the fuel mapping but my tuner said that all it does in essence is widen the windows to which the turbo will operate and to what boost level. The VAG safeguard limits are not changed at all so as long as you keep to the 10K service interval you won't have any problems.

Regular oil changes = happy turbo


depends what is causing failure - is the turbo stalling?
The calibration will differ between cars in different inertia classes, and calibration 'feel' will be different between the brands.

TDI_MAN

16 posts

234 months

Thursday 21st April 2005
quotequote all
The Turbo in a 130PD hits peak torque at 1900rpm. Up until that threshold is reached the vanes are contracted to funnel all exhaust gasses through as tight a hole as possible (Hence faster turbine speed).
No chip can change that.

It's only after this magical rpm that the vanes start to open up to regulate the boost pressure. Here is where chipping can alter when/how far they open therby giving more boost over a wider range than normal.

I've never heard of a turbo diesel turbo stalling. Petrol yes but diesel no.

NDT

1,762 posts

268 months

Thursday 21st April 2005
quotequote all
TDI_MAN said:
The Turbo in a 130PD hits peak torque at 1900rpm. Up until that threshold is reached the vanes are contracted to funnel all exhaust gasses through as tight a hole as possible (Hence faster turbine speed).
No chip can change that.

It's only after this magical rpm that the vanes start to open up to regulate the boost pressure. Here is where chipping can alter when/how far they open therby giving more boost over a wider range than normal. .

The variable geometry of the turbo might be under ECU control as well, I would have thought?

TDI_MAN said:
I've never heard of a turbo diesel turbo stalling. Petrol yes but diesel no.

Neither have I, just speculating!
DOn't know what the pressure ratio of a typical diesel turbo compressor is.

jvaughan

6,025 posts

288 months

Tuesday 26th April 2005
quotequote all
10,000 miles and mine is still going strong

Andy Mac

73,668 posts

260 months

Wednesday 27th April 2005
quotequote all
Had no problem with mine. It was a 130 redeye and pulled like a train after the chip was fitted. Traction control was working overtime into 4th gear! Its well worth it.