Intercom headsets

Author
Discussion

Speed addicted

Original Poster:

5,689 posts

233 months

Wednesday 9th March 2022
quotequote all
I'm looking for a new headset as my interphone F5MC is dying after about 7 years of use.

I've narrowed it down to (probably) three units.
Sena 10s, the 5s would do but battery life is a bit short.
Cardo freecom 4, I might stretch to the packtalk bold (at a mere £50 over budget) if it's amazing.
Interphone tour, great battery life and looks pretty simple. Some reviews say it's a bit quiet.

Looking to spend around £150ish, it's mainly for listening to music and nav directions on the bike with occasional bike to bike intercom use.
I'm more interested in being able to hear my classic rock than clever systems I'll never use, the models I've narrowed it down to are mainly because they've got long battery lives and apparently decent speakers.

Any opinions on these or others to add into the mix?
I'm not up for using a phone and earbuds, much prefer helmet speakers so I can still use ear plugs too.



Jazoli

9,199 posts

256 months

Wednesday 9th March 2022
quotequote all
I've got a Freecom 4 with JBL speakers and it works really well, to be honest I never found it quite loud enough until I changed helmets, now it's more than adequate at motorway+ speeds.

SteveKTMer

980 posts

37 months

Wednesday 9th March 2022
quotequote all
I use a Cardo Packtalk Bold with JBL 40mm speakers in a Shoei NXR helmet and I appreciate it's more than £150, but it really is worth the extra money. I tried a number of intercoms years ago and none of them were loud enough or the battery died after a few hours, there was always something wrong.

But the Packtalk bold works well with a group of friends, the battery usually lasts all day (9am to 5pm type day) or on my own I play loud music all day and it only starts to run out on a long day from maybe 9am to 6pm. It's loud and very clear.

Ride magazine has a review of budget intercoms this month.


wa16

2,240 posts

227 months

Wednesday 9th March 2022
quotequote all
midland bt x1 pros, sena 5s and cardio spirit are their top three

i find the sena integrated in my shoei in audible at motorway speeds - negates listening to music on a boring journey, in town its loud enough

Rushjob

1,954 posts

264 months

Wednesday 9th March 2022
quotequote all
Jazoli said:
I've got a Freecom 4 with JBL speakers and it works really well, to be honest I never found it quite loud enough until I changed helmets, now it's more than adequate at motorway+ speeds.
Another here, brilliant bit of kit!
Edited to add, I couldn't believe how good the battery life is on it, 10 hour day with the volume wound up and still going strong

Edited by Rushjob on Wednesday 9th March 17:11

Speed addicted

Original Poster:

5,689 posts

233 months

Wednesday 9th March 2022
quotequote all
Cardo seems fairly popular, how do you feel about the controls?

I saw one review where they spoke a lot about trouble with voice commands. I’m more likely to use buttons if that’s available, what do you use most?

off_again

12,815 posts

240 months

Wednesday 9th March 2022
quotequote all
Sena user for a few years and just recently upgraded to the 50S. The updated 50 range have upped the sound quality a lot and a big improvement over previous and older versions. I have ridden a lot with friends with Sena systems also and we havent really had an issue, bar a few initial peering fumbles.

Rick448

1,697 posts

230 months

Wednesday 9th March 2022
quotequote all
SteveKTMer said:
I use a Cardo Packtalk Bold with JBL 40mm speakers in a Shoei NXR helmet and I appreciate it's more than £150, but it really is worth the extra money. I tried a number of intercoms years ago and none of them were loud enough or the battery died after a few hours, there was always something wrong.

But the Packtalk bold works well with a group of friends, the battery usually lasts all day (9am to 5pm type day) or on my own I play loud music all day and it only starts to run out on a long day from maybe 9am to 6pm. It's loud and very clear.

Ride magazine has a review of budget intercoms this month.
Same here.

Doofus

27,956 posts

179 months

Wednesday 9th March 2022
quotequote all
This is odd. I'm not a biker but I was Googling this stuff earlier.

What I want is a Bluetooth headseat with a 3.5mm input. BT for phone, and 3.5mm for PMR.

Does this exist?

shirt

23,254 posts

207 months

Thursday 10th March 2022
quotequote all
SteveKTMer said:
I use a Cardo Packtalk Bold with JBL 40mm speakers in a Shoei NXR helmet and I appreciate it's more than £150, but it really is worth the extra money. I tried a number of intercoms years ago and none of them were loud enough or the battery died after a few hours, there was always something wrong.

But the Packtalk bold works well with a group of friends, the battery usually lasts all day (9am to 5pm type day) or on my own I play loud music all day and it only starts to run out on a long day from maybe 9am to 6pm. It's loud and very clear.

Ride magazine has a review of budget intercoms this month.
i have the packtalk slim and can't hear much at all with the speakers, using an arai profile v.

my new rx7 seems quieter so will be swapping it over soon. i struggle to get earbuds to stay in when i put my helmet on, even my custom fit ones, so hoping its an improvement

black-k1

12,137 posts

235 months

Thursday 10th March 2022
quotequote all
shirt said:
SteveKTMer said:
I use a Cardo Packtalk Bold with JBL 40mm speakers in a Shoei NXR helmet and I appreciate it's more than £150, but it really is worth the extra money. I tried a number of intercoms years ago and none of them were loud enough or the battery died after a few hours, there was always something wrong.

But the Packtalk bold works well with a group of friends, the battery usually lasts all day (9am to 5pm type day) or on my own I play loud music all day and it only starts to run out on a long day from maybe 9am to 6pm. It's loud and very clear.

Ride magazine has a review of budget intercoms this month.
i have the packtalk slim and can't hear much at all with the speakers, using an arai profile v.

my new rx7 seems quieter so will be swapping it over soon. i struggle to get earbuds to stay in when i put my helmet on, even my custom fit ones, so hoping its an improvement
PackTalk Bold with JBL speakers here with a Schuberth C4. The sound quality is good enough to hold converstations (other riders or phone) or listen to music/sat. nag. at motorway speeds.

It is vitally important that the speakers of any intercom align directly with your ears. Even just a few mm out of alignment will result in a dramatic reduction in sound level and quality. My speakers are velcro backed and getting the alignment just right took quite a lot of helemt on, listen carefully while pushing the helemt forward, backward, up and down to work out which direction the speaker needed to move then removing helmet and carefully relocating the speakers before repeating th process. Sat on the couch at home doing this gives also the rest of the family an evenings free entertainment! biggrin

SBDJ

1,325 posts

210 months

Thursday 10th March 2022
quotequote all
I use a Packtalk Slim but with already fairly naff hearing meaning I couldn't hear much at any real speed, I use mine with a set of UE SoundEar Pro instead of the supplied JBL speakers. It's a bit of a faff, but worth it for me.

SteveKTMer

980 posts

37 months

Thursday 10th March 2022
quotequote all
SBDJ said:
I use a Packtalk Slim but with already fairly naff hearing meaning I couldn't hear much at any real speed, I use mine with a set of UE SoundEar Pro instead of the supplied JBL speakers. It's a bit of a faff, but worth it for me.
That's a great idea, I'd not thought of doing that. I use earplugs so the Cardo is on near full volume all the time, but your idea would mean lower volume level with better music quality probably and my GoPro mic wouldn't then pick up the music from the Cardo or me constantly saying hey cardo, music off ! smile

SteveKTMer

980 posts

37 months

Thursday 10th March 2022
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
PackTalk Bold with JBL speakers here with a Schuberth C4. The sound quality is good enough to hold converstations (other riders or phone) or listen to music/sat. nag. at motorway speeds.
Providing nobody sings... redface

Speed addicted

Original Poster:

5,689 posts

233 months

Thursday 10th March 2022
quotequote all
SteveKTMer said:
black-k1 said:
PackTalk Bold with JBL speakers here with a Schuberth C4. The sound quality is good enough to hold converstations (other riders or phone) or listen to music/sat. nag. at motorway speeds.
Providing nobody sings... redface
Surely that's when you just listen to music?

The main difference between the pactalk bold and freecom 4+ seems to be the mesh communication, since I don't know 15 people with cardo headsets and can't imagine wanting to have a full on group chat while riding a motorbike I'm more interested in the freecom.
Now to add difficulty there appears to be a new version out (Freecom 4X) with some more features for much the same price as the pactalk, which is probably also due an update!


black-k1

12,137 posts

235 months

Thursday 10th March 2022
quotequote all
Speed addicted said:
SteveKTMer said:
black-k1 said:
PackTalk Bold with JBL speakers here with a Schuberth C4. The sound quality is good enough to hold converstations (other riders or phone) or listen to music/sat. nag. at motorway speeds.
Providing nobody sings... redface
Surely that's when you just listen to music?

The main difference between the pactalk bold and freecom 4+ seems to be the mesh communication, since I don't know 15 people with cardo headsets and can't imagine wanting to have a full on group chat while riding a motorbike I'm more interested in the freecom.
Now to add difficulty there appears to be a new version out (Freecom 4X) with some more features for much the same price as the pactalk, which is probably also due an update!
You don't need to know/ride with 15 people to benefit from the mesh rather than the direct connect. Even with as few as 3 riders using the direct connect set up, it is not uncommon for one rider to "drop off" the group. Infact, on of the things that the childish among the Old Gits used to enjoy doing on a run was seeing if they could push far enough ahead of the group to get the intercom to report "Rider B Disconnected". biggrin

shirt

23,254 posts

207 months

Thursday 10th March 2022
quotequote all
SteveKTMer said:
SBDJ said:
I use a Packtalk Slim but with already fairly naff hearing meaning I couldn't hear much at any real speed, I use mine with a set of UE SoundEar Pro instead of the supplied JBL speakers. It's a bit of a faff, but worth it for me.
That's a great idea, I'd not thought of doing that. I use earplugs so the Cardo is on near full volume all the time, but your idea would mean lower volume level with better music quality probably and my GoPro mic wouldn't then pick up the music from the Cardo or me constantly saying hey cardo, music off ! smile
Makes for an expensive set up but I think this is also what I’ll end up doing.

Speed addicted

Original Poster:

5,689 posts

233 months

Thursday 10th March 2022
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
You don't need to know/ride with 15 people to benefit from the mesh rather than the direct connect. Even with as few as 3 riders using the direct connect set up, it is not uncommon for one rider to "drop off" the group. Infact, on of the things that the childish among the Old Gits used to enjoy doing on a run was seeing if they could push far enough ahead of the group to get the intercom to report "Rider B Disconnected". biggrin
Ah hadn't really thought of that. I take it you can still do a direct bluetooth connection with riders that have other makes?

black-k1

12,137 posts

235 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
Speed addicted said:
black-k1 said:
You don't need to know/ride with 15 people to benefit from the mesh rather than the direct connect. Even with as few as 3 riders using the direct connect set up, it is not uncommon for one rider to "drop off" the group. Infact, on of the things that the childish among the Old Gits used to enjoy doing on a run was seeing if they could push far enough ahead of the group to get the intercom to report "Rider B Disconnected". biggrin
Ah hadn't really thought of that. I take it you can still do a direct bluetooth connection with riders that have other makes?
Yes, they still have the same direct connect blue tooth channels as well as being able to mesh to other PackTalks

Speed addicted

Original Poster:

5,689 posts

233 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
Thanks for the help, I’ll buy a packtalk bold shortly!
Then wait for hassle from the wife because I’m working away from home and packages keep appearing…