530 auto fuel consumption ?

530 auto fuel consumption ?

Author
Discussion

dcb

Original Poster:

5,894 posts

271 months

Tuesday 6th January 2004
quotequote all

I've owned a three year old 530 Auto for a couple of months now and I've done the first set of fuel consumption figures.

Very disappointing. 23 mpg average over a couple of thousand miles.

I never use the A/C, the cruise is on a lot, I never go over 4000 rpm, so can anyone explain / contradict the mpg I'm seeing ?

sohlman

590 posts

260 months

Tuesday 6th January 2004
quotequote all
I don't know how heavy your right foot is, but it does not sound like it should be that bad. We have averaged 29MPG in our 528 manual. I would get the car checked out as you should be getting high twenties to low thirties, especially if you are driving it carefully. I get 23MPG out of my 19 year old 635.

dcb

Original Poster:

5,894 posts

271 months

Tuesday 6th January 2004
quotequote all
sohlman said:
I don't know how heavy your right foot is, but it does not sound like it should be that bad. We have averaged 29MPG in our 528 manual.


The BMW service book has 18.2 mpg for the urban cycle for my car, and 35.7 mpg for the extra urban.

A simple bit of maths suggests that to get that combination to reach 23 mpg, I must be doing 72.6 % of my driving in town.

Possible, but unlikely.

ScoobyZoom

6,578 posts

254 months

Tuesday 6th January 2004
quotequote all
Thats wrong. Should be more like 30mpg if you do a little bit f town and more like 40mpg if your mainly on the motorway.

late 20's if mostly round town

dcb

Original Poster:

5,894 posts

271 months

Wednesday 7th January 2004
quotequote all
ScoobyZoom said:
Thats wrong. Should be more like 30mpg if you do a little bit f town and more like 40mpg if your mainly on the motorway.

late 20's if mostly round town


It's a bit odd how you claim better numbers than the BMW service book.

We aren't mixing up petrol & diesel are we ?

Mine's petrol.

ScoobyZoom

6,578 posts

254 months

Wednesday 7th January 2004
quotequote all
im going home...

could of sworn it said 530d...

sorry



530 PETROL should average mid to late twenties though..

early twentys round town. i had one about 12 months ago but due to my lead clad driving shoes i got not more than 18-20

JamesK

2,124 posts

285 months

Wednesday 7th January 2004
quotequote all
I think you all expect too much and the quoted figures are at best optimum and at worst just unachievable in the real world. A V8 auto is going to be pretty awful on fuel, worse than a 4 or 6 cylinder of similar capacity iirc. It will use more oil as well. I have a 540 auto and even on quite a long run I never get near 30mpg. More to the point I wouldn't have it any other way I mean that engine!!!

Marshy

2,748 posts

290 months

Wednesday 7th January 2004
quotequote all
I got 28 mpg out of my E34 540i - and I think that's heavier than the E39. It *can* be done, as long as you're not in any sort of hurry...

Which is normally what knackers things for me.

dcb

Original Poster:

5,894 posts

271 months

Wednesday 7th January 2004
quotequote all
JamesK said:

I think you all expect too much and the quoted figures are at best optimum and at worst just unachievable in the real world.


My experience of other cars is that manufacturer's numbers are very achievable.

JamesK said:

A V8 auto is going to be pretty awful on fuel, worse than a 4 or 6 cylinder of similar capacity iirc. It will use more oil as well.


True. For the record, the BMW 530 is a inline six cylinder engine.

I wouldn't expect any V8 to get any better than 25 mpg. My previous car, a Jaguar XJ8, with a 3.2 V8, only claimed 23 mpg, and I got 19 mpg.

JamesK said:

I have a 540 auto and even on quite a long run I never get near 30mpg. More to the point I wouldn't have it any other way I mean that engine!!!


I wouldn't expect a 540 auto to do more than about 22-25 mpg.

However, the six cylinder 530 I've got isn't doing too well so far.
One of the reasons I bought it was the reduced fuel consumption over the Jaguar, which it is doing, but only just.

I've due for a 200 mile round trip at the weekend. I'll report back.

JamesK

2,124 posts

285 months

Thursday 8th January 2004
quotequote all
Ahhh apologies dcb - I assumed your 530 was a V8

Ultimasimon

9,643 posts

264 months

Friday 9th January 2004
quotequote all
My 730i (V8) only averages 19.6 according to the OBC. My last 7 series was a 6-pot, and the fuel consumption was considerably better, ranging between 19~29 on a run. I can't get anywhere near that with the V8.

Marshy

2,748 posts

290 months

Friday 9th January 2004
quotequote all
I had a 730i V8 too - and in my opinion it was rather under-engined, certainly causing my fuel consumption to suffer - used to average just over 18mpg.

Ultimasimon

9,643 posts

264 months

Friday 9th January 2004
quotequote all
Marshy said:
I had a 730i V8 too - and in my opinion it was rather under-engined, certainly causing my fuel consumption to suffer - used to average just over 18mpg.


Yes, they are. Next time around I will go for 740i. It's my 3rd 7 Series, and for what you pay I am totally impressed. The V8 does sound better and I think it is much smoother, but defo lacks grunt Somewhat suprised that it changes up @6250rpm when in sport mode That's a lot of mass recipricating there at that speed

Marshy

2,748 posts

290 months

Friday 9th January 2004
quotequote all
I was dead chuffed with my E38 7 too. Loved the look of the thing, loved in the interior too - bloody good place to be when munching the miles.

The older 540i I have now is a bit less refined due to various suspension knocks and seat creaks, but has _so_ _much_ _more_ grunt that it more than compensates.

And the steering's just as vague...

dcb

Original Poster:

5,894 posts

271 months

Sunday 11th January 2004
quotequote all
dcb said:

I've due for a 200 mile round trip at the weekend. I'll report back.


Over the trip, 27.1 mpg average.

Might get to 30 mpg if I try hard.

Interestingly, I tried out the sport modes on the auto gearbox for the first time.

Gave it a full-bore takeoff from a standing start and the traction control light came on & stayed on.

Looks like I've broken it.

Barry the BMW will be going in for some repair work to get the Traction Control fixed ;-<

mustard

6,992 posts

251 months

Sunday 11th January 2004
quotequote all
ScoobyZoom said:
im going home...

could of sworn it said 530d...

sorry



530 PETROL should average mid to late twenties though..

early twentys round town. i had one about 12 months ago but due to my lead clad driving shoes i got not more than 18-20



1-1 Scoobs!

dcb

Original Poster:

5,894 posts

271 months

Saturday 6th March 2004
quotequote all
dcb said:

Might get to 30 mpg if I try hard.


Duly, I tried hard, and got to 30.7 mpg for a 180 mile trip [A12 again].

Good for a 150 plus mph wagon. I won't be trying that hard again. 25 mpg does me.

dcb said:

Barry the BMW will be going in for some repair work to get the Traction Control fixed ;-<


70 quid trousered by the BMW dealers.

dcb

Original Poster:

5,894 posts

271 months

Saturday 20th March 2004
quotequote all
dcb said:

Duly, I tried hard, and got to 30.7 mpg for a 180 mile trip [A12 again].


Same trip, but got caught behind a load of folks that don't seem to know that we drive on the LEFT on UK motorways, and fuel consumption reached 32 mpg.

Getting better all the time.

Maybe next time if I slipstream a lorry, 35 mpg is possible.

gshughes

1,289 posts

261 months

Wednesday 14th April 2004
quotequote all
dcb said:

I never use the A/C


You should use it. Lack of use is what eventually knackers A/C. Either the seals dry out, crack and leak, or the pump goes because it hasn't had any fluid and oil through it, and it seizes through lack of lubrication. Some go as far as to say it should stay on all the time, although I reckon every few days should do ok. The cost in slightly increased fuel consumption should be offset by lower maintenance charges (especially in a BMW)

>> Edited by gshughes on Wednesday 14th April 13:47

danhay

7,460 posts

262 months

Wednesday 14th April 2004
quotequote all
I had a 530i V8 and I struggled to get 20mpg on average when being lightfooted. The best I ever managed was 25mpg.

Traded it for a Porsche 928 in the end!