Which BMW for £8K to £9K?

Which BMW for £8K to £9K?

Author
Discussion

gregd

Original Poster:

1,695 posts

224 months

Wednesday 31st July
quotequote all
My youngest son is looking to trade in his first car (2016 Mini Cooper) and is set on a BMW. He's favouring a 3 Series.. probably a manual 320i but he is open to other suggestions!

He only does around 6K miles a year (Uni plus part time job), doesn't need much boot space but ideally needs some semblance of rear seats.
I've only ever had an F32 335i coupe years ago so I'm no expert when it comes to BMW.

What would you guys be looking at in this price range? As a yardstick he's seen the following and is keen to get down there and check it out..

https://www.aspirecars.co.uk/used-cars/bmw-3-serie...

How does this look? I've told him maybe try and look for something slightly newer and be less worried if it's higher mileage. 330e's are starting to come under £10K now but the health of the battery would worry me somewhat. There's also some leggy (over 100k miles) but nicely specced circa 2018 320i's and 320d's coming close to being within budget as well as the odd 420.

Any thoughts you have would be great.


Triumph Man

8,852 posts

173 months

Wednesday 31st July
quotequote all
If he's at all into cars tell him to get something slightly older with the correct number of cylinders.

Pablo16v

2,195 posts

202 months

Wednesday 31st July
quotequote all
What about going back in time a bit to something like an E46 330ci ?

danb79

9,375 posts

77 months

Wednesday 31st July
quotequote all
gregd said:
My youngest son is looking to trade in his first car (2016 Mini Cooper) and is set on a BMW. He's favouring a 3 Series.. probably a manual 320i but he is open to other suggestions!

He only does around 6K miles a year (Uni plus part time job), doesn't need much boot space but ideally needs some semblance of rear seats.
I've only ever had an F32 335i coupe years ago so I'm no expert when it comes to BMW.

What would you guys be looking at in this price range? As a yardstick he's seen the following and is keen to get down there and check it out..

https://www.aspirecars.co.uk/used-cars/bmw-3-serie...

How does this look? I've told him maybe try and look for something slightly newer and be less worried if it's higher mileage. 330e's are starting to come under £10K now but the health of the battery would worry me somewhat. There's also some leggy (over 100k miles) but nicely specced circa 2018 320i's and 320d's coming close to being within budget as well as the odd 420.

Any thoughts you have would be great.

Is he interested in an older BMW (E46, E39, E9x range)?

Plenty of them about with the 3.0 straight 6 petrol engine. This is what you'll get advised to do on here

But if they're restrictive due to insurance then for me, an F30 320i or 328i would be the one to go for

M Sport with the M Sport suspension, ideally RWD over xDrive (less to go wrong and better suspension) HK stereo, pro nav and ideally the M Sport Brembo brakes and it's hell of a car

Will just have to understand that they'll be higher miles. So buy a well looked after, documented example with plenty of serfice history etc

That goes for the aforementioned cars too. Buy on condition / paperwork to prove that it's been taken care of etc

s m

23,491 posts

208 months

Wednesday 31st July
quotequote all
125i Coupe

junglie

1,957 posts

222 months

Wednesday 31st July
quotequote all
Triumph Man said:
If he's at all into cars tell him to get something slightly older with the correct number of cylinders.
The correct answer!

6 cylinders just far more pleasant than 4 and synonymous with BMW.

E46 great but getting on (mine was brilliant and faultless mind you).

Someone has already posted a 125i coupe which is a good call.

Go for a post 2009 with the updated day nav. £300 gets it mapped back to 130i power.

gregd

Original Poster:

1,695 posts

224 months

Wednesday 31st July
quotequote all
Many thanks folks, some super helpful suggestions here

Mr E

22,041 posts

264 months

Wednesday 31st July
quotequote all
I’ve looked at ~2013 640d grand coupe’s for 9k. I’m tempted.

Fox-

13,320 posts

251 months

Wednesday 31st July
quotequote all
I'd rather keep the 2016 Mini than have a 320i of this generation, which will likely not be particularly great.

twokcc

858 posts

182 months

Thursday 1st August
quotequote all
s m said:
125i Coupe
This, don't rust , e90 interior in front, don't have turbos and lots of emission gear to go wrong with CIC sat nav reasonably uptodate media kit got brilliant 6 cylinder engine. A more modern E46 coupe.
May need a water pump at some stage but cheap car to run and will get near 40mpg on decent run

Mr Squarekins

1,149 posts

67 months

Thursday 1st August
quotequote all
A late 3 litre Z3 with a nice spec would be my choice. Roof down fun for young person.

Jamescrs

4,763 posts

70 months

Thursday 1st August
quotequote all
It would have to be a 6 cylinder engine for me, probably an E90.
I’ve owned a 320i myself previously and wouldn’t recommend it.

danb79

9,375 posts

77 months

Thursday 1st August
quotequote all
Mr E said:
I’ve looked at ~2013 640d grand coupe’s for 9k. I’m tempted.
Hell of a lot of car for not a lot of £££

Hammy98

847 posts

97 months

Thursday 1st August
quotequote all
Can you still get a 130i hatch for this budget? They're lovely... failing that then 125i coupe as mentioned.

oldaudi

1,383 posts

163 months

Thursday 1st August
quotequote all
E63 650i V8

danb79

9,375 posts

77 months

Thursday 1st August
quotequote all
Hammy98 said:
Can you still get a 130i hatch for this budget? They're lovely... failing that then 125i coupe as mentioned.
Easily... A good car with £££ to spare for insurance and maybe some maintenance / simple mods etc

E63eeeeee...

4,422 posts

54 months

Thursday 1st August
quotequote all
danb79 said:
Mr E said:
I’ve looked at ~2013 640d grand coupe’s for 9k. I’m tempted.
Hell of a lot of car for not a lot of £££
Very true, although not perhaps best suited for low mileage and short journeys, and not exactly cheap to run once in the six figure mileage zone. Electrics, glow plugs, sensors, suspension, pulleys, sooted-up intake, lots of bits are approaching end of life. All good fun and fixable but not exactly cheap or convenient. If my 640d had been my only car I'd have hated it. I'd personally be going 6-cyl petrol in a 1 or 3 series to suit taste. And get a decent diagnostic setup and a smoke tester because you'll need them.

danb79

9,375 posts

77 months

Thursday 1st August
quotequote all
E63eeeeee... said:
danb79 said:
Mr E said:
I’ve looked at ~2013 640d grand coupe’s for 9k. I’m tempted.
Hell of a lot of car for not a lot of £££
Very true, although not perhaps best suited for low mileage and short journeys, and not exactly cheap to run once in the six figure mileage zone. Electrics, glow plugs, sensors, suspension, pulleys, sooted-up intake, lots of bits are approaching end of life. All good fun and fixable but not exactly cheap or convenient. If my 640d had been my only car I'd have hated it. I'd personally be going 6-cyl petrol in a 1 or 3 series to suit taste. And get a decent diagnostic setup and a smoke tester because you'll need them.
Agree

This is why I mentioned the E46s or E39s further up

M54 3.0 straight 6, easy engine to look after and maintain and a superb engine to boot. Find a decent example with that budget and it'll be heck of a car

Mr E

22,041 posts

264 months

Thursday 1st August
quotequote all
E63eeeeee... said:
Very true, although not perhaps best suited for low mileage and short journeys, and not exactly cheap to run once in the six figure mileage zone. Electrics, glow plugs, sensors, suspension, pulleys, sooted-up intake, lots of bits are approaching end of life. All good fun and fixable but not exactly cheap or convenient. If my 640d had been my only car I'd have hated it. I'd personally be going 6-cyl petrol in a 1 or 3 series to suit taste. And get a decent diagnostic setup and a smoke tester because you'll need them.
Noted.

rottenegg

713 posts

68 months

Friday 2nd August
quotequote all
A Mini to a 3 series can be quite a boring downgrade imo in terms of driving dynamics.

The heavy, stodgy feel of a German barge vs a nimble hatch is something older folk appreciate more than young whipper snapper yoooooouths, but then again, it just depends on what he wants from a car?

The F series 3ers are brilliant waft along in comfort machines, especially a nice 6 pot diesel with the super awesome ZF8 auto smile Plenty of torque, and with the Harman Kardon audio option, your youngest will be super chilled and enjoying some thumping tunes.

How old is he? A base spec 2.0i might not float his boat. He will at minimum be requiring an M Sport flavour whether derv or petrol, otherwise it feel like a boring slug compared to the Mini.