Subaru Impreza P1- purchase query

Subaru Impreza P1- purchase query

Author
Discussion

lewistintin

Original Poster:

243 posts

245 months

Thursday 12th May 2005
quotequote all
Hi,
Thinking of buying a P1 for summer. I will only need it from this month to the end of september. Couple of quick questions though,
1) Are these cars pretty reliable, assuming i get an AA inspection, Im not likely to incur engine failures and alike?

2)Do you think a P1 will hold its money pretty well over this period of time. I was thinking of getting one of the cheapest ones in the country?

3) Do you think this is the car to have, I will be loaned up to the high hilts to have about 13k max to spend on the car, cant afford to loose much money on it? (Insurance etc excluded)

Thanks very much.

Podie

46,645 posts

282 months

Thursday 12th May 2005
quotequote all
Never see a car as an investment... unless you're buying something seriously rare...

LewisTintin

Original Poster:

243 posts

245 months

Thursday 12th May 2005
quotequote all
Its not so much an investment I am after...

Its damage limitation, I reconsise i will loose some money, but limiting that amount is my primary aim.
I can go for unique'ish car like the subaru, or something normal like an exciting Vectra. I just thought i far more likely to save money buying something a bit unique, rather than a 'normal'car.

Pulsatingstar

1,717 posts

255 months

Thursday 12th May 2005
quotequote all
I was under the impression that P1 engines didnt last that many miles. But its 2nd hand info and I dont know personally so im not saying the figure.

shadowninja

77,499 posts

289 months

Thursday 12th May 2005
quotequote all
Why is it so cheap in the first place? You may have problems selling it too?

Anyway... P1 as a summer car??? It's hardly a high power rear wheel drive roadster!

Munter

31,327 posts

248 months

Thursday 12th May 2005
quotequote all
lewistintin said:

1) Are these cars pretty reliable, assuming i get an AA inspection, Im not likely to incur engine failures and alike?


AA inspection! Bahahahahahaha. *cough*

Sorry about that. But they are a total waste of your time. They can only do a visual check of the engine. So so long as no oil is falling out they'll not say anything about it...

Things the AA missed on my car:
Rear lights had wrong bulbs so brake lights didn't work.
Replacement body panels not fitted correctly.
Overspray on windscreen.
Dodgy spray job on one side.
(They did say the spray job on the other side of the car was satisfoctory...)
Nail in a tyre.

You'd be better saving the £200 and spending it as part of a good service...

vixpy1

42,676 posts

271 months

Thursday 12th May 2005
quotequote all
Pulsatingstar said:
I was under the impression that P1 engines didnt last that many miles. But its 2nd hand info and I dont know personally so im not saying the figure.


Well, most of em have had rebuids at some point.

LaurenceFrost

691 posts

259 months

Friday 13th May 2005
quotequote all
Munter said:

AA inspection! Bahahahahahaha. *cough*

Sorry about that. But they are a total waste of your time. They can only do a visual check of the engine. So so long as no oil is falling out they'll not say anything about it...

Things the AA missed on my car:
Rear lights had wrong bulbs so brake lights didn't work.
Replacement body panels not fitted correctly.
Overspray on windscreen.
Dodgy spray job on one side.
(They did say the spray job on the other side of the car was satisfoctory...)
Nail in a tyre.

You'd be better saving the £200 and spending it as part of a good service...

Well I had an RAC inspection on my Evo and it was superb. Extremely thorough and didn't miss a thing.

As for the P1's they hold their value better than most cars due to their limited numbers, but I think you'll be paying more than £13k to get a good'un.

DJFish

5,964 posts

270 months

Friday 13th May 2005
quotequote all
AA: Don't bother, they missed the 5th gear problem on my yr2000 Impreza.

Obviously you'll want to join the www.p1woc.co.uk forum and ask there.

Then do a search for '5th gear' on scoobynet, it's a common problem affecting all my2000 cars including the P1.

Nicol@

3,850 posts

243 months

Friday 13th May 2005
quotequote all
I know a few people who own/have owned p1's (one of them owned from new and sold a few weeks ago).

None of them have had any problems or engine issues.

They are pretty robust cars.

rustybin

1,769 posts

245 months

Friday 13th May 2005
quotequote all
Subarus around the 99/00 period seem to have taken a bit of a price tumble recently. This could be good for you if it has bottomed out a bit or not if they are still falling. It's a bit like interest rates, you will get plenty of opinion as to what they will be doing in the next few months but no-one will be able to tell you for sure.

I would suggest you might be better off buying the best 'regular' Impreza you can afford than the cheapest special.

jaker

3,934 posts

276 months

Friday 13th May 2005
quotequote all
My mate's P1 completely lunched its engine

on the plus side, Prodrive fixed it for free!

dnb

3,330 posts

249 months

Monday 16th May 2005
quotequote all
My experience is that the "good" specials - P1, 22B etc hold their value much better than the other cars provided they don't have a huge milage put on them.

The engine failure problem on P1s is pretty minor and is caused by a combination of the airflow sensor (a problem on all MY99/00 Imprezas) and the knock correction system employed by Prodrive when they made the P1. (This can be fixed very satisfactorily with an ECUTek Tek3 remap )