Running a DBS (Compared to a Vantage?)

Running a DBS (Compared to a Vantage?)

Author
Discussion

Shmee

Original Poster:

7,565 posts

219 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
Some questions out of curiosity of the comparison in cost of a DBS against a V8 Vantage; I'm certainly not changing before a year of owning my V8V but I'm interested to know for the future, whether it's a reasonable goal or not!

So I'm currently running a 59 V8V Roadster, the costs are along the lines of 14mpg over 12k miles per year and a £1000 service every 10k miles (only talking cars well within warranty so no issues there). My insurance hikes from £1200 to £2300 doing a quote now but what are the other expenses to take into consideration on top of presumably something like a mere 10mpg on fuel (if you do 10-12k miles a year that's a lot!). Are DBS services significantly more expensive and/or more regular? Completely ignoring the additional depreciation of a more expensive car too!

Something like this really doesn't feel too far away:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2011...



If they drop down to nearer to the £100k mark I could see one being a real possibility nearer the end of 2011!

Adam2S

5,126 posts

183 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
Well I switched last year from a '09 4.7 V8V to a '10 V12V which must be a similar swap in terms of running costs.

My fuel economy on the V8 was around 12mpg and I now get around 10mpg out of the V12V - so thats 20% more fuel. The insurance went up by around 15% but Im pretty sure that most of the rise is due to the value of the car, as it will be in your case too I'm sure. Other cost factors include tyres and servicing but these are all insignificant compared to the depreciation on any £100k+ car. If you can afford the depreciation then the other factors really dont come into it.

Guycord

744 posts

179 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
Adam2S said:
Well I switched last year from a '09 4.7 V8V to a '10 V12V which must be a similar swap in terms of running costs.

My fuel economy on the V8 was around 12mpg and I now get around 10mpg out of the V12V - so thats 20% more fuel. The insurance went up by around 15% but Im pretty sure that most of the rise is due to the value of the car, as it will be in your case too I'm sure. Other cost factors include tyres and servicing but these are all insignificant compared to the depreciation on any £100k+ car. If you can afford the depreciation then the other factors really dont come into it.
Likewise did the same thing. Although I must have been doing something wrong because I was getting 24mpg on the 4.7 and that dropped to 14mpg on the 6.0L.

My understanding is a 10000mi/1st year service at AMWS is a grand all-in (inc.VAT)for the V12V. I know official dealer services are circa £850 for the 4.7L V8V.

With my little knowledge I assume;
a) more oil in V12
b) harder to service a V12V (crowded engine bay, hard to get at filter)- but might be the case in a DBS
c) the 4yr/40,000mile service is the killer (£???) as the ceramic anchors need to come off and be weighted.
d) not sure if the DBS active suspension needs any service.

On insurance, I'm with Locktons and the key driver of their policies is the insured value. Therefore DBS will cost more to insure than a V12V and inturn will be more than a V8V for the same age/mileage. IIRC, my brand new 4.7L V8V was less than a £100 differential on a 6 month old V12V for same mileage premium.

All-in all, I dont see the V12V/DBS service costs to be silly compared to the V8.

G



Edited by Guycord on Tuesday 15th March 11:32

Shmee

Original Poster:

7,565 posts

219 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
Many thanks for the replies, you are sort of implying what I thought in that it might be slightly more work and slightly more expensive in terms of day to day running but not hugely, it's really down to thinking about the depreciation costs when the appropriate time comes around. Understanding the service routine was really my goal so that's a relief that it's not much different.

I'm going to keep a close eye on what the prices do at the end of this summer, no rush because the V8V is AWESOME! But we all like to keep our eyes on what comes next biggrin

DSLiverpool

15,041 posts

208 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
They have had that car for ages, must be the colour or people are scared of buying a £100k+ car from an indie ?

I was / am definately having a DBS Volante either late this year or early next, I want to see what happens when a few scary economic scenarios kick in.

bananarob

1,177 posts

187 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
I swapped a 4.7 V8V last August for a 10 DBS. I would say i get around 13mpg which is mostly A and B road with about 25% Motorway/carriageway. Very little town use. I used to get about 18 in the Vantage. I dont use it every day so it does tend to get used for longer runs. As for Service costs, can only compare by first service but the Vantage was around £640 last year and the DBS cost me £823 last week, same main dealer. Insurance increased by about 15%. Im not looking forward to changing the tyres as I understand these to be DBS specific!

Shmee

Original Poster:

7,565 posts

219 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
bananarob said:
I swapped a 4.7 V8V last August for a 10 DBS. I would say i get around 13mpg which is mostly A and B road with about 25% Motorway/carriageway. Very little town use. I used to get about 18 in the Vantage. I dont use it every day so it does tend to get used for longer runs. As for Service costs, can only compare by first service but the Vantage was around £640 last year and the DBS cost me £823 last week, same main dealer. Insurance increased by about 15%. Im not looking forward to changing the tyres as I understand these to be DBS specific!
Ouch tyres, didn't really think about that. The V8V ones are about £200 each and living in central London with excessive roadworks between my cars I've had 5 punctures in the last 12 months so that would have to be considered! Not to mention how long off the road to get hold of them...

ETA: DBS tyres seem to be about £400 a corner; it could be worse... Ahh yes it is, they are Pirelli's which means they go like lightning too and forever need replacing.

Edited by Shmee on Tuesday 15th March 16:01

Vantagefan

643 posts

176 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
I seem to recall reading that the warranty costs for a V12V are similar to a V8V with the DBS and DB9 being more expensive. Despite having the same engine the V12V seems to offer a better deal on that front.

mikey k

13,014 posts

222 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
DSLiverpool said:
They have had that car for ages, must be the colour or people are scared of buying a £100k+ car from an indie ?

I was / am definately having a DBS Volante either late this year or early next, I want to see what happens when a few scary economic scenarios kick in.
Yep it is my local Subaru Garage "playing" with high end stuff. 16M and GT40 in as well.
I'd be interested to see peoples thoughts & experiences on this as it looks like there won't be a V12V roadster frown

robgt

2,586 posts

168 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
Dear God, what are you boys doing? I am fortunate to own a spanking new V8V . I am truly amazed at the fuel consumption . 23 - 25 is no problem. We go fast we go slow, we play a bit but most of all we just love it. My wife says Bugger the the fuel. Off to Scotland in May I am expecting to be " Feeling very Lucky.
RobGT

jonamv8

3,176 posts

172 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
Robgt - good work getting that MPG! I'm doing 17 in a 4.3 V8, cruise on otorway and hammered down lanes mainly

UH-Matt

2,172 posts

246 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
DSLiverpool said:
They have had that car for ages, must be the colour or people are scared of buying a £100k+ car from an indie ?

I was / am definately having a DBS Volante either late this year or early next, I want to see what happens when a few scary economic scenarios kick in.
Definitely the colour. That interior colour is terrible. If your going to spend £130k, then spend £140k and buy a better spec that will always sell easily!!

george h

14,713 posts

170 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
Shmee said:
presumably something like a mere 10mpg on fuel
Depends entirely where its driven, can get 25ish out of DB9 volante on motorway runs, but then again can drop to around 6 when driving round town.

Just have to resist the urge to floor the throttle at every occasion, though it is hard!

Shmee

Original Poster:

7,565 posts

219 months

Tuesday 15th March 2011
quotequote all
george h said:
Depends entirely where its driven, can get 25ish out of DB9 volante on motorway runs, but then again can drop to around 6 when driving round town.

Just have to resist the urge to floor the throttle at every occasion, though it is hard!
As mentioned I get 14mpg in my V8 Vantage 4.7, so really looking for a like-for-like comparison as most of my driving is in city, from the above replies 10 seems about how it would come out.

Springbok

334 posts

260 months

Wednesday 16th March 2011
quotequote all
I also usually get 22-24 mpg from a tank.

Have got up to 30 mpg on a motorway only run - admittedly I was in no hurry though, just cruising gently at about 65.

Simon



AMArchie

269 posts

176 months

Wednesday 16th March 2011
quotequote all
Interesting comments on fuel consumption. I have done about 3000 miles in my V12V, and the little trip computer thingy says I've averaged 17mpg overall ( I have yet to reset it since it arrived from the dealer last July).
Obviously my driving is not spirited enough!!!

JohnG1

3,485 posts

211 months

Thursday 17th March 2011
quotequote all
Shmee said:
Something like this really doesn't feel too far away:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2011...



If they drop down to nearer to the £100k mark I could see one being a real possibility nearer the end of 2011!
Love the exterior - but the interior - are you kidding me?????? That car has been on the shelf for a while and that's your reason...

If you are a long term buy and hold kind of guy then go for it and be happy, but if you chop and change every 18 months be prepared to get screwed or forced into SOR basis....

Shmee

Original Poster:

7,565 posts

219 months

Thursday 17th March 2011
quotequote all
JohnG1 said:
Love the exterior - but the interior - are you kidding me?????? That car has been on the shelf for a while and that's your reason...

If you are a long term buy and hold kind of guy then go for it and be happy, but if you chop and change every 18 months be prepared to get screwed or forced into SOR basis....
Sorry I tried to make it clear I wasn't interested until late this year at the very least - the specific car is irrelevant!

JohnG1

3,485 posts

211 months

Thursday 17th March 2011
quotequote all
Shmee said:
Sorry I tried to make it clear I wasn't interested until late this year at the very least - the specific car is irrelevant!
I know, I read your point. But I think this will still be on sale then!!!

Shmee

Original Poster:

7,565 posts

219 months

Thursday 17th March 2011
quotequote all
JohnG1 said:
I know, I read your point. But I think this will still be on sale then!!!
Haha it may well be, there are of course some other options too and to be honest I don't dislike this one at all wink