Mustang Misfire
Discussion
1966 Ford Mustang with a 302ci V8 which has HEI fitted (High Energy Ignition - coil in distributor).
It has developed an intermittent misfire that seems to get worse when the engine gets hot.
From what I can see using my spark tester it has a weak or no spark on cylinder number 1 (all others appear to be fine) and will lose spark on this cylinder for a few seconds before stalling at idle (when running I can pull the ignition lead to this cylinder and it makes no difference to the rough running). Spark becomes stronger at higher revs but with occasional misfire/backfire.
So far I have tried and tested:
Why would I see the problem on one cylinder alone? It seems like an ignition issue rather than fueling or compression, otherwise I'd expect the problem to be across all or more cylinders.
It has developed an intermittent misfire that seems to get worse when the engine gets hot.
From what I can see using my spark tester it has a weak or no spark on cylinder number 1 (all others appear to be fine) and will lose spark on this cylinder for a few seconds before stalling at idle (when running I can pull the ignition lead to this cylinder and it makes no difference to the rough running). Spark becomes stronger at higher revs but with occasional misfire/backfire.
So far I have tried and tested:
- swapping the HT lead to cylinder 1 with one of the others: no change.
- swapping spark plug in cylinder 1 with one of the others: no change.
- swapped out the ignition control module within the distributor: no change, and dwell meter shows dwell angle increasing with revs as expected.
- static test on the primary and secondary coils: within spec for impedance.
- static test on distributor pick-up coil: within spec for impedance.
Why would I see the problem on one cylinder alone? It seems like an ignition issue rather than fueling or compression, otherwise I'd expect the problem to be across all or more cylinders.
Not being familiar with HEI I may be talking rubbish, so please beware of that ignorance on my behalf.
You say the spark to No 1 is weak, so what is exclusive to no 1?
Is there any potential induction issues that could be isolated to no 1?
Is the dizzy good as I have seen them with corrosion/erosion on one more than others?
I would be replacing dizzy & rotor & any condenser for cheapness & making sure that side is all good.
I would also likely be changing coil as once again, they are cheap enough & that is pretty much all of the HT side known good.
You say the spark to No 1 is weak, so what is exclusive to no 1?
Is there any potential induction issues that could be isolated to no 1?
Is the dizzy good as I have seen them with corrosion/erosion on one more than others?
I would be replacing dizzy & rotor & any condenser for cheapness & making sure that side is all good.
I would also likely be changing coil as once again, they are cheap enough & that is pretty much all of the HT side known good.
E-bmw said:
You say the spark to No 1 is weak, so what is exclusive to no 1?
Is there any potential induction issues that could be isolated to no 1?
Is the dizzy good as I have seen them with corrosion/erosion on one more than others?
I would be replacing dizzy & rotor & any condenser for cheapness & making sure that side is all good.
I would also likely be changing coil as once again, they are cheap enough & that is pretty much all of the HT side known good.
Thanks for the ideas.Is there any potential induction issues that could be isolated to no 1?
Is the dizzy good as I have seen them with corrosion/erosion on one more than others?
I would be replacing dizzy & rotor & any condenser for cheapness & making sure that side is all good.
I would also likely be changing coil as once again, they are cheap enough & that is pretty much all of the HT side known good.
- I can't see any induction issues that could be isolated to cylinder no. 1 (other than a valve problem I guess). It has a relatively new Edelbrock carb on an inlet manifold common to all cylinders.
- Distributor also looks relatively new, and inspection inside the cap doesn't show any corrosion or cracking (nor signs of sparks tracking). I cleaned the contacts for good measure.
- The distributor is points-less (a pickup coil detects shaft position and triggers the integral ignition control module) and also has the condenser and coil internally. Replacing the distributor unfortunately isn't a particularly cheap option, so I was trying to get a more definitive diagnosis before throwing (expensive) parts at the problem.
Do you have enough travel on the dizzy to turn it by a whole cylinder's worth? If so, you could prove definitively that the problem is within the dizzy.
Have you proved that the spark strength is only changing on the affected cylinder? I suppose it's possible you're getting a false reading for some reason and the cylinder misfire is the result of some other problem.
Have you proved that the spark strength is only changing on the affected cylinder? I suppose it's possible you're getting a false reading for some reason and the cylinder misfire is the result of some other problem.
I thought I'd round out this thread with what is hopefully the final resolution.
Further diagnosis and trials included:
I can take some comfort from the fact that my diagnosis was correct - the pickup coil appears to have been failing when hot - and that it wasn't a straightforward job to swap. IGS American in Surbiton did a great job, and also cleaned and adjusted the carb so it appears to be running very sweetly at the moment.
Now, on to the other little jobs ...
Further diagnosis and trials included:
- swapping out all the spark plugs
- checked the switched +12V to the distributor and fixed (by-passing the ballast resistance wire which is not required by HEI).
- checking ignition with a timing light. When failing, the "revs" displayed on the timing fluctuated wildly, on all cylinders (not just cylinder 1); the light itself also fluctuated at the same time.
I can take some comfort from the fact that my diagnosis was correct - the pickup coil appears to have been failing when hot - and that it wasn't a straightforward job to swap. IGS American in Surbiton did a great job, and also cleaned and adjusted the carb so it appears to be running very sweetly at the moment.
Now, on to the other little jobs ...
Gassing Station | Engines & Drivetrain | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff