Electric or air impact wrench ?

Electric or air impact wrench ?

Author
Discussion

Vitesse39

Original Poster:

726 posts

253 months

Monday 22nd August 2005
quotequote all

Anyone had a blast with both ?
Are the electric battery powered ones any good. I know some of them say they will do up to 200 Nm of torque but is that right or is it sales BS.

Incorrigible

13,668 posts

266 months

Monday 22nd August 2005
quotequote all
Electric ones are very good

All depends on how big your compressor is and whether you need the portability/how much cash you've got

Vitesse39

Original Poster:

726 posts

253 months

Monday 22nd August 2005
quotequote all

Cheers m8, it could be a toss up between buy a new electric jobby or a second hand compressor et al on ebay !

dern

14,055 posts

284 months

Monday 22nd August 2005
quotequote all
Are we talking about the 12-24v portable things that look like drills? What sort of force would you need to take a hub nut off a car for example?

Regards,

Mark

eliot

11,690 posts

259 months

Monday 22nd August 2005
quotequote all
And you need a 3 horsepower 14 cfm beltdrive compressor with a decent sized tank to run air-tools (£300+)

DONT get suckered into buying the direct drive ~7cfm ones that comes with an assortment of tools, usually including an impact wrench - they will undo one nut if youre lucky (tanks are too small)

>> Edited by eliot on Monday 22 August 17:06

Vitesse39

Original Poster:

726 posts

253 months

Monday 22nd August 2005
quotequote all
dern said:
Are we talking about the 12-24v portable things that look like drills? What sort of force would you need to take a hub nut off a car for example?


That's the ones. I've seen some on ebay 24V, as I say stated as being 200 lbft, but are they.........

stevieturbo

17,453 posts

252 months

Monday 22nd August 2005
quotequote all
Mate has a Snap On 18v impact gun. Its a superb tool, and has plenty of power. Bit noisy though.

I have heard comments on other brands, such as Sealey, and they werent rated highly. Depends what usage its for. His gun will do most crank bolts etc. Wheelnuts are a breeze for it.

eliot

11,690 posts

259 months

Monday 22nd August 2005
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:
Mate has a Snap On 18v impact gun. Its a superb tool, and has plenty of power. Bit noisy though.

I have heard comments on other brands, such as Sealey, and they werent rated highly. Depends what usage its for. His gun will do most crank bolts etc. Wheelnuts are a breeze for it.

Ive seen a snap-on gun used to swap an entire set of wheels on a 4x4 (5 nuts per wheel) - no problems at-all, Impressive. I would be wary of a cheaper brand though.

Mikey G

4,757 posts

245 months

Monday 22nd August 2005
quotequote all
Ive got a 24v battery one i bought off ebay and tested it to 150lb/ft came with 2 batteries and a 1hour charger. On the other hand my mate bought a 24v one slightly different to mine and it struggles with tight wheel nuts whereas mine will undo them quite well
He also tried an 18v one and that struggled to undo ANY wheelnut

grahambell

2,718 posts

280 months

Monday 22nd August 2005
quotequote all
Have used a Sealey a lot and it copes well with most jobs. For the ones it couldn't cope with I ended up using an air wrench...

nighthawk

1,757 posts

249 months

Monday 22nd August 2005
quotequote all
I have a snap on 18volt impact gun, it's great for removing wheel nuts from cars, doesn't compare in terms of sustainable power to my Ingersol rand windy gun though.

This all depends on what it's going to be used for really.

trackcar

6,453 posts

231 months

Monday 22nd August 2005
quotequote all
Another vote for the snap on range of battery guns. bought one for our race car at meets and it's a god-send. bought the best one i could afford .. at 300 pounds it's not cheap but worth it's weight in gold, and it's heavy!
waaay better than any other portable gun i've ever used.

shpub

8,507 posts

277 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2005
quotequote all
Some lower cost options.... I use a 12V RAC electric impact wrench from Argos to undo wheel nuts etc when the 520 is out and about. Not as nice as the real electric ones but it runs off the car battery and at around £20 works pretty well.

At home I do use an air tool and I use a Northern Tool impact wrench at around the £30 mark and surprisingly enough it copes with most jobs especially wheel nuts even running on a 25L compressor. It really all depends on how much you want to spend and how extreme the jobs can be.

I have noticed that the CFM rating is important as it does vary a lot for tools that do the same job. It is worth getting smaller CFM tools if you have a smaller compressor. My unit cost around £80 with some tools and has been a Godsend. I do agree with bigger is better and some day I will upgrade but for the jobs I do it works well for me.

Incorrigible

13,668 posts

266 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2005
quotequote all
While a high CFM is nice it's not essential IMO unles you're doing extended jobs with a compressor (like sanding)

They also take up a shit load of room (which is what I'm short of)

I beleive Dontlift, our resident tool man does a good deal on the battery or air impact wreches

grahambell

2,718 posts

280 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2005
quotequote all
Incorrigible said:

I beleive Dontlift, our resident tool man does a good deal on the battery or air impact wreches


He also does a good deal on recon compressors...