F-Type R to 718 Cayman GTS

F-Type R to 718 Cayman GTS

Author
Discussion

shatnersbassoon79

Original Poster:

1 posts

10 months

Friday 10th November 2023
quotequote all
Hi All,

Probably the Porsche forum is the wrong place to ask for an unbiased opinion, but I'm considering changing my Jag F-type R to a Cayman GTS (manual gearbox).
My F-Type is a 2017 convertible and would possibly be considering a 718 Cayman GTS.

Has anyone else made the same change?
Was it worth it? What did you miss about the F-Type, or was there no regrets?

Matt

stanlow45

304 posts

11 months

Friday 10th November 2023
quotequote all
Not done it exactly but have certainly driven both at length. You will get a lot more road noise in the Cayman. Which may or may not be a concern if you are doing long journeys, I found the Cayman very loud indeed and on the concrete sections of the M25, close to unbearable. Less of an issue on smoothly surfaced European tarmac of course. I also think the Porsche F6 is very overrated, certainly compared to a pre gpf V8 is not in the same league and the gearing is a little bit too long for a sports car.

That said the mid engined handling of the Porsche is unreal, the f type is closer to a GT in comparison. With prices coming down fast now you may find it worth holding off until Jan/Feb unless cost is of little concern.
Cayman likely to be a lot more reliable too, and the Porsche official warranty is usually pretty good.