At what point do they close Snake Pass permanently?

At what point do they close Snake Pass permanently?

Author
Discussion

Hugo Stiglitz

Original Poster:

38,038 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
If you know the Peak nearby is the abandoned road from Castleton upto Mam Tor.

Yet another closure:
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=pfbid0...

At what point do they either dig deep and relay properly with deep foundations or make it two ends (no through road). There's at least three parts that are continously moving and when hard ground frost comes..

Niponeoff

2,411 posts

34 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
Sounds like they are investigating to find out what the issue is. Hence why its closed even to cyclists.

MikeGTi

2,548 posts

208 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
I imagine it's too arterial for a permanent closure; I doubt Woodhead or the route through Hope Valley--especially the two 90 degree bends in Castleton and Winnat's Pass--could take the additional strain.

slopes

40,142 posts

194 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
Hugo Stiglitz said:
If you know the Peak nearby is the abandoned road from Castleton upto Mam Tor.

.
Been along that road before it was permanently closed back when i was a young un

vaud

52,394 posts

162 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
Hugo Stiglitz said:
If you know the Peak nearby is the abandoned road from Castleton upto Mam Tor.

Yet another closure:
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=pfbid0...

At what point do they either dig deep and relay properly with deep foundations or make it two ends (no through road). There's at least three parts that are continously moving and when hard ground frost comes..
Well written post by the council. Nice to see plain English....

RogerDodgerSuperTodger

5,185 posts

193 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
Has there ever been a weight limit in place? No wagons, nothing over 7.5T, not letting your mum over etc hehe

Pretty glad I didn't buy that house in Bamford a few years ago…

Riley Blue

21,633 posts

233 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
vaud said:
Hugo Stiglitz said:
If you know the Peak nearby is the abandoned road from Castleton upto Mam Tor.

Yet another closure:
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=pfbid0...

At what point do they either dig deep and relay properly with deep foundations or make it two ends (no through road). There's at least three parts that are continously moving and when hard ground frost comes..
Well written post by the council. Nice to see plain English....
I thought you were being sarcastic but no, it's a genuinely well written explanation.

Wacky Racer

38,984 posts

254 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
There is absolutely no way they will ever close the Snake pass.

The road at Castleton next to The Blue John mine is different because the side of Mam Tor actually collapsed big style, however there is an easy alternative via nearby Winnats pass,



I drove down the Mam Tor road many times in the 1970's before the closure when it was in good condition.

Hugo Stiglitz

Original Poster:

38,038 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
They keep instigating repairs on the cheap.

The only way that they can properly repair for a longterm solution would be to cut out, foundation rods inserted and at numerous points along Snake.

With the coming winter and probable government spending cuts to come I can't see this happening.

Someone's going to get hurt. Beit in a car or more likely a motorbike. With the tilt in surface etc
The traffic lights round a blind bend etc system didn't work either. Especially when people still do 50 until they realise there's a line of stationary cars.







Edited by Hugo Stiglitz on Thursday 18th August 13:17

blueacid

483 posts

148 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
Went over the Snake a few weeks ago, didn't realise what those traffic lights were for until reading this here today!

Hope it can be repaired easily. Another vote of support for that message from that council though, that was excellent.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

197 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
Hugo Stiglitz said:
They keep instigating repairs on the cheap.

The only way that they can properly repair for a longterm solution would be to cut out, foundation rods inserted and at numerous points along Snake.
Maybe, maybe not. Are you in a qualified position to say that would be the way to "fix" it?

Hugo Stiglitz

Original Poster:

38,038 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
Maybe, maybe not. Are you in a qualified position to say that would be the way to "fix" it?
This lower set should do it



RogerDodgerSuperTodger

5,185 posts

193 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
Hugo Stiglitz said:
They keep instigating repairs on the cheap.

The only way that they can properly repair for a longterm solution would be to cut out, foundation rods inserted and at numerous points along Snake.
Maybe, maybe not. Are you in a qualified position to say that would be the way to "fix" it?
Never one to let us down.

Countdown

42,037 posts

203 months

Thursday 18th August 2022
quotequote all
Not afraid to admit that road scares the crap out of me.

I'm getting old.

Allegro_Snapon

557 posts

35 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
I love(d) this road.

I grew up in Sheffield. We had a game that you left the top of the Pass to come back to Ladybower and you ragged your car as fast as possible until the Snake Inn. Momentum only after that, clutch in Neutral. Colins XR3i made it to Ladybower Bridger with three of us jumping out and running pushing the car about two miles after Snake Inn and ironically just after the Alport River passed under the road.

In the 1990s I commuted from Sheffield to Salford daily, in an 1100cc Fiesta. It was so easy to overtake slower vehicles once you knew the sightlines both after Glossop golf course and on the descent past Alport which was a good place to get past five or six cars obviously not overtaking. bit of hanging back and slingshotting out the bends when you could see the road was clear.....

Did get stopped once though...by the 80 ft deep snowdrifts 1 mile West of the Snake Inn.

However, not surprised this is happening, the whole route is built on "fluid" shale. That bouncy bit that has been getting worse since the 1980s between Snake Inn and Alport.......geologists knew this..Alport is the biggest mainland landslip in the UK. (Above nearby Whaley Bridge is another land slipping hill...which may end up in a rebuilt Toddbrook reservoir).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alport_Castles

The Mam Tor route was similar, unstable soft ground is easy to build a road on until the weight of the road collapses it! Anything north of the Peak Forrest Road (A627) has these problems.

So you are left with Woodhead Pass and the suicide lanes of Stocksbridge Bypass. I lost three friends in two different accidents on there (none fault to the dead, wrong time, wrong place).

M67 -Mottram Bypass - Woodhead - M1 via the unused Woodhead tunnel seems a major but forgotten UK road scheme.

soad

33,454 posts

183 months

Saturday 20th August 2022
quotequote all
Wacky Racer said:
There is absolutely no way they will ever close the Snake pass.

The road at Castleton next to The Blue John mine is different because the side of Mam Tor actually collapsed big style, however there is an easy alternative via nearby Winnats pass,



I drove down the Mam Tor road many times in the 1970's before the closure when it was in good condition.
Winnats Pass is a good call, “accidentally” stumbled upon it after visiting Odin Mine last year. driving








JmatthewB

919 posts

129 months

Monday 22nd August 2022
quotequote all
Images never really do the Winnats Pass justice. It is spectacular driving down there.

Hugo Stiglitz

Original Poster:

38,038 posts

218 months

Monday 22nd August 2022
quotequote all
JmatthewB said:
Images never really do the Winnats Pass justice. It is spectacular driving down there.
Until someone slows down there stops to take pictures.

When challenged 'what's wrong mate why can't I stop on a steep climb to take numerous phone pictures...

Allegro_Snapon

557 posts

35 months

Wednesday 24th August 2022
quotequote all
I grew up in Sheffield and remember going over the old road that landslipped away, down into second gear for the hairpin in an A35 and if you were lucky you'd just about get around and keep going.

"Winnets Pass" even when the old A625 was available before the landslip you'd avoid Winnets as 'Winnets' were a slang for haemorrhoids. "Hi John, I'm going to have to dock your pay this morning as you were forty minutes in the Loo". "Boss please don't, I've got Winnets and they wouldn't let the Bismarck Pass".




mattyprice4004

1,327 posts

181 months

Friday 26th August 2022
quotequote all
Wacky Racer said:
There is absolutely no way they will ever close the Snake pass.

The road at Castleton next to The Blue John mine is different because the side of Mam Tor actually collapsed big style, however there is an easy alternative via nearby Winnats pass,



I drove down the Mam Tor road many times in the 1970's before the closure when it was in good condition.
I went there for a geology field trip in 2006, and while there we met 2 other colleges doing the same thing!

Seems a popular spot for it - and an absolutely fascinating place to walk around.